
Text -- Luke 6:6-11 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Robertson: Luk 6:6 - -- On another sabbath ( en heterōi sabbatōi ).
This was a second (heteron , as it often means), but not necessarily the next, sabbath. This incident...
On another sabbath (
This was a second (

Robertson: Luk 6:6 - -- Right hand ( hē dexia ).
This alone in Luke, the physician’ s eye for particulars.
Right hand (
This alone in Luke, the physician’ s eye for particulars.

Robertson: Luk 6:7 - -- The scribes and the Pharisees ( hoi grammateis kai hoi Pharisaioi ).
Only Luke here though Pharisees named in Mat 12:14 and Pharisees and Herodians i...

Robertson: Luk 6:7 - -- Watched him ( paretērounto auton ).
Imperfect middle, were watching for themselves on the side (para ). Mar 3:2 has the imperfect active paretēr...
Watched him (
Imperfect middle, were watching for themselves on the side (

Robertson: Luk 6:7 - -- Would heal ( therapeusei ).
But the present active indicative (therapeuei ) may be the correct text here. So Westcott and Hort.
Would heal (
But the present active indicative (

Robertson: Luk 6:7 - -- That they might find out how to accuse him ( hina heurōsin katēgorein autou ).
Second aorist active subjunctive of heuriskō and the infinitiv...
That they might find out how to accuse him (
Second aorist active subjunctive of

Robertson: Luk 6:8 - -- But he knew their thoughts ( autos de ēidei tous dialogismous autōn ).
In Luke alone. Imperfect in sense, second past perfect in form ēidei f...
But he knew their thoughts (
In Luke alone. Imperfect in sense, second past perfect in form

Robertson: Luk 6:8 - -- His hand withered ( xēran tēn cheira ).
Predicate position of the adjective. So in Mar 3:3.
His hand withered (
Predicate position of the adjective. So in Mar 3:3.

Robertson: Luk 6:8 - -- Stand forth ( stēthi ).
Luke alone has this verb, second aorist active imperative. Mar 3:3 has Arise into the midst (egeire eis to meson ). Luke...
Stand forth (
Luke alone has this verb, second aorist active imperative. Mar 3:3 has Arise into the midst (

Robertson: Luk 6:9 - -- I ask you ( eperōtō humās ).
They had questions in their hearts about Jesus. He now asks in addition (ep' ) an open question that brings the w...
I ask you (
They had questions in their hearts about Jesus. He now asks in addition (

Robertson: Luk 6:9 - -- A life ( psuchēn ).
So the Revised Version. The rabbis had a rule: Periculum vitae pellit sabbatum . But it had to be a Jew whose life was in peri...
A life (
So the Revised Version. The rabbis had a rule: Periculum vitae pellit sabbatum . But it had to be a Jew whose life was in peril on the sabbath. The words of Jesus cut to the quick.

Robertson: Luk 6:9 - -- Or to destroy it ( ē apolesai ).
On this very day these Pharisees were plotting to destroy Jesus (Luk 6:7).
Or to destroy it (
On this very day these Pharisees were plotting to destroy Jesus (Luk 6:7).

Robertson: Luk 6:10 - -- He looked round about on them all ( periblepsamenos ).
First aorist middle participle as in Mar 3:5, the middle voice giving a personal touch to it a...
He looked round about on them all (
First aorist middle participle as in Mar 3:5, the middle voice giving a personal touch to it all. Mark adds "with anger"which Luke here does not put in.

Robertson: Luk 6:10 - -- All three Gospels have the identical command: Stretch forth thy hand (exteinon tēn cheira sou ). First aorist active imperative.
@@Stretch out
,...
All three Gospels have the identical command: Stretch forth thy hand (
, clean out, full length. All three Gospels also have the first aorist passive indicative

Robertson: Luk 6:11 - -- They were filled with madness ( eplēsthēsan anoias )
First aorist passive (effective) with genitive: In Luk 5:26 we saw the people filled with fe...

Robertson: Luk 6:11 - -- Communed ( dielaloun )
, imperfect active, picturing their excited counsellings with one another. Mar 3:6 notes that they bolted out of the synagogue...
Communed (
, imperfect active, picturing their excited counsellings with one another. Mar 3:6 notes that they bolted out of the synagogue and outside plotted even with the Herodians how to destroy Jesus, strange co-conspirators these against the common enemy.

Robertson: Luk 6:11 - -- What they might do to Jesus ( ti an poiēsaien Iēsou ).
Luke puts it in a less damaging way than Mar 3:6; Mat 12:14. This aorist optative with an ...
What they might do to Jesus (
Luke puts it in a less damaging way than Mar 3:6; Mat 12:14. This aorist optative with
Vincent: Luk 6:6 - -- His right hand ( ἡ χεὶρ αὐτοῦ ἡ δεξιὰ )
A very precise mode of statement. Lit., his hand the right one. Luke only s...
His right hand (
A very precise mode of statement. Lit., his hand the right one. Luke only specifies which hand was withered. This accuracy is professional. Ancient medical writers always state whether the right or the left member is affected.

Vincent: Luk 6:7 - -- He would heal ( θεραπεύσει )
So Rev. Some authorities, however, read θεραπεύει , " whether he is healing. " This may me...
He would heal (
So Rev. Some authorities, however, read

Vincent: Luk 6:7 - -- Find
Peculiar to Luke, and emphasizing the eagerness of the Pharisees to discover a ground of accusation.
Find
Peculiar to Luke, and emphasizing the eagerness of the Pharisees to discover a ground of accusation.

He knew (
Imperfect. He was all along aware.


Vincent: Luk 6:9 - -- I will ask ( ἐπερωτήσω )
Peculiar to Luke's narrative. The best texts read ἐπερωτῶ , the present tense, I ask . So Rev.
I will ask (
Peculiar to Luke's narrative. The best texts read

Vincent: Luk 6:9 - -- Life ( ψυχὴν )
Better as Rev., a life. Though the question is a general one, it carries a hint of an individual life thrown into it by...
Life (
Better as Rev., a life. Though the question is a general one, it carries a hint of an individual life thrown into it by the special case at hand. See on Mar 12:30. Wyc., to make a soul safe.

Vincent: Luk 6:11 - -- They were filled with madness
Peculiar to Luke. Ἄνοια , madness, is, properly, want of understanding. The word thus implies senseles...
They were filled with madness
Peculiar to Luke.

He just then probably saw the design to kill him rising in their hearts.
JFB: Luk 6:7 - -- In Matthew (Mat 12:9) this is put as an ensnaring question of theirs to our Lord, who accordingly speaks to the state of their hearts (Luk 6:9), just ...

JFB: Luk 6:9 - -- By this novel way of putting His case, our Lord teaches the great ethical principle, that to neglect any opportunity of doing good is to incur the gui...
By this novel way of putting His case, our Lord teaches the great ethical principle, that to neglect any opportunity of doing good is to incur the guilt of doing evil; and by this law He bound His own spirit. (See Mar 3:4.)

JFB: Luk 6:11 - -- The word denotes senseless rage at the confusion to which our Lord had put them, both by word and deed.
The word denotes senseless rage at the confusion to which our Lord had put them, both by word and deed.
Clarke: Luk 6:6 - -- Whose right hand was withered - See on Mat 12:10 (note), etc. The critic who says that ξηραν χειρα signifies a luxated arm, and that the...

Clarke: Luk 6:7 - -- Watched him - Παρετηρουν αυτον, They maliciously watched him. This is the import of the word, Luk 14:1; Luk 20:20, and in the parall...

Clarke: Luk 6:7 - -- An accusation against him - Instead of κατηγοριαν αυτου, his accusation, several eminent MSS. and versions add κατα, against, w...
An accusation against him - Instead of

Clarke: Luk 6:9 - -- I will ask you one thing - I will put a question to you. See on Mar 3:4, Mar 3:5 (note).

Clarke: Luk 6:10 - -- Whole as the other - Many MSS., both here and in the parallel place, Mar 3:5, omit the word ὑγιης, whole. Griesbach leaves it out of the tex...
Whole as the other - Many MSS., both here and in the parallel place, Mar 3:5, omit the word

Clarke: Luk 6:11 - -- They were filled with madness - Pride, obstinacy, and interest, combined together, are capable of any thing. When men have once framed their conscie...
They were filled with madness - Pride, obstinacy, and interest, combined together, are capable of any thing. When men have once framed their conscience according to their passions, madness passes for zeal, the blackest conspiracies for pious designs, and the most horrid attempts for heroic actions. Quesnel.
Calvin -> Luk 6:8
Calvin: Luk 6:8 - -- Luk 6:8.But he knew their thoughts If Matthew states the truth, they had openly declared by their language what was in their minds; and therefore Chri...
Luk 6:8.But he knew their thoughts If Matthew states the truth, they had openly declared by their language what was in their minds; and therefore Christ replies not to their secret thoughts, but to express words. But both may be true, that they spoke plainly, and yet that Christ discerned their secret thoughts; for they did not openly avow their designs, and Matthew himself tells us that their question was intended to take Christ by surprise; and, consequently, Luke means nothing more than that Christ was aware of their insidious designs, though not expressed in words.
TSK: Luk 6:6 - -- it came : Mat 12:9-14; Mar 3:1-6
he : Luk 4:16, Luk 4:31, Luk 13:10,Luk 13:13, Luk 13:14, Luk 14:3; Mat 4:23; Joh 9:16
there : 1Ki 13:4; Zec 11:17; Jo...

TSK: Luk 6:7 - -- watched : Luk 13:14, Luk 14:1-6; Psa 37:32, Psa 37:33, Psa 38:12; Isa 29:21; Jer 20:10; Mar 3:2; Joh 5:10-16, Joh 9:16, Joh 9:26-29
that : Luk 11:53, ...

TSK: Luk 6:8 - -- But : Luk 5:22; 1Ch 28:9, 1Ch 29:17; Job 42:2; Psa 44:21; Joh 2:25, Joh 21:17; Heb 4:13; Rev 2:23
Rise : Isa 42:4; Joh 9:4; Act 20:24, Act 26:26; Phi ...



TSK: Luk 6:11 - -- they : Luk 4:28; Psa 2:1, Psa 2:2; Ecc 9:3; Act 5:33, Act 7:54, Act 26:11
communed : Mat 12:14, Mat 12:15, Mat 21:45; Joh 7:1, Joh 11:47; Act 4:15, Ac...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Luk 6:8 - -- But he knew there thoughts - He knew their thoughts - their dark, malicious designs - by the question, which they proposed to him, whether it w...
But he knew there thoughts - He knew their thoughts - their dark, malicious designs - by the question, which they proposed to him, whether it was lawful to heal on the Sabbath-days (Matthew). In "reply"to their question, Jesus asked them whether they would not release a "sheep"on the Sabbath-day if it was fallen into a pit, and also asked "them"whether it was better to do good than to do evil on that day, implying that to "omit"to do "good"was, in fact, doing "evil."

Barnes: Luk 6:11 - -- Were filled with madness - Probably, 1. Because he had shown his "power"to work a miracle. 2. Because he h...
Were filled with madness - Probably,
1. Because he had shown his "power"to work a miracle.
2. Because he had shown his power to do it "contrary"to what "they"thought was right.
3. Because by doing it he had shown that he was from "God,"and that "they"were therefore "wrong"in their views of the Sabbath. And,
4. Because he had shown no respect "to their views"of what the law of God demanded.
Pride, obstinacy, malice, and disappointed self-confidence were "all"combined, therefore, in producing madness. Nor were they alone. Men are often enraged because others do good in a way which "they"do not approve of. God gives success to others; and because he has not accommodated himself to "their"views of what is right, and done it in the way which "they"would have prescribed, they are enraged, and filled with envy at people more successful than themselves.
Communed one with another - Spoke together, or laid a plan.
Poole -> Luk 6:6-11
Poole: Luk 6:6-11 - -- Ver. 6-11. See Poole on "Mat 12:10" , and following verses to Mat 12:13 , See Poole on "Mar 3:1" , and following verses to Mar 3:5 . In both which ...
Ver. 6-11. See Poole on "Mat 12:10" , and following verses to Mat 12:13 , See Poole on "Mar 3:1" , and following verses to Mar 3:5 . In both which places we met with the same history, and with some more circumstances. Mark tells us that the subject of their deliberation, what they might do to Jesus, was, how they might destroy him; this the evangelist maketh the effect of their madness,
Gill: Luk 6:6 - -- And it came to pass also on another sabbath,.... Whether the following sabbath, or some time after, is not certain,
that he entered into the synago...
And it came to pass also on another sabbath,.... Whether the following sabbath, or some time after, is not certain,
that he entered into the synagogue. The Arabic version reads, "into their synagogue", as in Mat 12:9 the synagogue of the Jews; in what place, whether at Capernaum, or some other city of Galilee, is not so clear:
and taught; explained the Scriptures to the people, and instructed them in the doctrines of the Gospel:
and there was a man whose right hand was withered; who was in the synagogue, and one of his hearers; See Gill on Mat 12:10

Gill: Luk 6:7 - -- And the Scribes and Pharisees watched him,.... See Gill on Mar 3:2.
whether he would heal on the sabbath day: there being such an object before him...
And the Scribes and Pharisees watched him,.... See Gill on Mar 3:2.
whether he would heal on the sabbath day: there being such an object before him:
that they might find an accusation against him; as they had before against his disciples.

Gill: Luk 6:8 - -- But he knew their thoughts,.... Being the omniscient God; though they had said nothing of their intentions, he knew what they designed, should he heal...
But he knew their thoughts,.... Being the omniscient God; though they had said nothing of their intentions, he knew what they designed, should he heal the man with his withered hand, as they expected he would:
and said to the man which had the withered hand, rise up, and stand forth in the midst. The Syriac and Persic versions add, "of the synagogue", and which is the true sense; See Gill on Mar 3:3.
and he arose and stood forth; he rose up from his seat, and stood up in the midst of the synagogue, and of the people, that he might be seen of all.

Gill: Luk 6:9 - -- Then said Jesus unto them,.... The Scribes and Pharisees, who were watching him, and whose thoughts, and the reasonings of their minds, purposes, and ...
Then said Jesus unto them,.... The Scribes and Pharisees, who were watching him, and whose thoughts, and the reasonings of their minds, purposes, and intentions, he full well knew:
I will ask you one thing; or question, as they had asked him one before; Mat 12:10
is it lawful on the sabbath days to do good, or to do evil? to save life, or to destroy it? See Gill on Mar 3:4 to which may be added, that to save life on the sabbath day was agreeable to their own canons: there were many things which they allowed might be done on the sabbath day, when life was in danger, which otherwise were not lawful; See Gill on Mat 12:8.

Gill: Luk 6:10 - -- And looking round about upon them all,.... The Scribes and Pharisees, and the rest of the people in the synagogue; See Gill on Mar 3:5.
he said to ...
And looking round about upon them all,.... The Scribes and Pharisees, and the rest of the people in the synagogue; See Gill on Mar 3:5.
he said to the man; who had the withered hand,
stretch forth thy hand, and he did so; he stretched it out, as the Syriac and Persic versions render it, which he was not able to do before:
and his hand was restored well as the other; the phrase, "well as the other", is left out in one copy, and in the Vulgate Latin version; and so is the word "well" in the Syriac and Arabic versions; and the word "immediately" is added in the Ethiopic version. And certain it is, that his withered hand was restored sound and well as the other, directly.

Gill: Luk 6:11 - -- And they were filed with madness,.... Both at the cure, and because they could not answer him; nor properly fix a charge upon him, or accuse him befor...
And they were filed with madness,.... Both at the cure, and because they could not answer him; nor properly fix a charge upon him, or accuse him before the people, without bringing their resentments on them:
and communed one with another what they might do with Jesus: this they did after they came out of the synagogue, and when with the Herodians, as in See Gill on Mar 3:6.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Luk 6:7 The background for this is the view that only if life was endangered should one attempt to heal on the Sabbath (see the Mishnah, m. Shabbat 6.3; 12.1;...

NET Notes: Luk 6:8 Here καί (kai) has been translated as “so” to indicate the man’s action was a result of Jesus’ order.

NET Notes: Luk 6:9 With the use of the plural pronoun (“you”), Jesus addressed not just the leaders but the crowd with his question to challenge what the lea...

NET Notes: Luk 6:10 The passive was restored points to healing by God. Now the question became: Would God exercise his power through Jesus, if what Jesus was doing were w...

NET Notes: Luk 6:11 The use of the optative (ποιήσαιεν, poihsaien, “might do”) in an indirect question indicates...
Geneva Bible: Luk 6:6 ( 2 ) And it came to pass also on another sabbath, that he entered into the synagogue and taught: and there was a man whose right hand was withered.
...

Geneva Bible: Luk 6:9 Then said Jesus unto them, I will ask you one thing; Is it lawful on the sabbath days to do good, or to do evil? to save life, or to ( b ) destroy [it...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Luk 6:1-49
TSK Synopsis: Luk 6:1-49 - --1 Christ reproves the Pharisees;12 chooses apostles;17 heals the diseased;20 preaches to his disciples before the people.
MHCC -> Luk 6:6-11
MHCC: Luk 6:6-11 - --Christ was neither ashamed nor afraid to own the purposes of his grace. He healed the poor man, though he knew that his enemies would take advantage a...
Matthew Henry -> Luk 6:1-11
Matthew Henry: Luk 6:1-11 - -- These two passages of story we had both in Matthew and Mark, and they were there laid together (Mat 12:1; Mar 2:23; Mar 3:1), because, though happen...
Barclay -> Luk 6:6-11
Barclay: Luk 6:6-11 - --By this time the opposition to Jesus was quite open. He was teaching in the synagogue on the Sabbath day and the scribes and Pharisees were there wit...
Constable: Luk 4:14--9:51 - --IV. Jesus' ministry in and around Galilee 4:14--9:50
Luke commenced Jesus' public ministry with His return to Ga...

Constable: Luk 5:12--6:12 - --B. The beginning of controversy with the Pharisees 5:12-6:11
One of Luke's purposes in his Gospel and in...
