collapse all  

Text -- Luke 9:54 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
9:54 Now when his disciples James and John saw this, they said, “Lord, do you want us to call fire to come down from heaven and consume them?”
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Names, People and Places:
 · James a son of Zebedee; brother of John; an apostle,a son of Alpheus; an apostle,a brother of Jesus; writer of the epistle of James,the father (or brother) of the apostle Judas
 · John a son of Zebedee; younger brother of James; the beloved disciple of Christ,a relative of Annas the high priest,a son of Mary the sister of Barnabas, and surnamed Mark,the father of Simon Peter


Dictionary Themes and Topics: Revenge | Retaliation | Rashness | Presumption | Persecution | Malice | LUKE, THE GOSPEL OF | John | Jesus, The Christ | James | FISHER; FISHERMAN | Elijah | CONSUME | Bigotry | BOANERGES | Apostles | APOSTLE | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Robertson , Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Barclay , Constable , College , McGarvey , Lapide

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Robertson: Luk 9:54 - -- Saw this ( idontes ). Second aorist active participle of horaō . Saw the messengers returning.

Saw this ( idontes ).

Second aorist active participle of horaō . Saw the messengers returning.

Robertson: Luk 9:54 - -- We bid ( theleis eipōmen ). Deliberative subjunctive eipōmen after theleis without hina , probably two questions, Dost thou wish? Shall we bi...

We bid ( theleis eipōmen ).

Deliberative subjunctive eipōmen after theleis without hina , probably two questions, Dost thou wish? Shall we bid? Perhaps the recent appearance of Elijah on the Mount of Transfiguration reminded James and John of the incident in 2Ki 1:10-12. Some MSS. add here "as Elijah did."The language of the lxx is quoted by James and John, these fiery Sons of Thunder. Note the two aorist active infinitives (katabēnai , analōsai , the first ingressive, the second effective).

Wesley: Luk 9:54 - -- At or near this very place, which might put it into the minds of the apostles to make the motion now, rather than at any other time or place, where Ch...

At or near this very place, which might put it into the minds of the apostles to make the motion now, rather than at any other time or place, where Christ had received the like affront.

JFB: Luk 9:54 - -- Not Peter, as we should have expected, but those "sons of thunder" (Mar 3:17), who afterwards wanted to have all the highest honors of the Kingdom to ...

Not Peter, as we should have expected, but those "sons of thunder" (Mar 3:17), who afterwards wanted to have all the highest honors of the Kingdom to themselves, and the younger of whom had been rebuked already for his exclusiveness (Luk 9:49-50). Yet this was "the disciple whom Jesus loved," while the other willingly drank of His Lord's bitter cup. (See on Mar 10:38-40; and Act 12:2). That same fiery zeal, in a mellowed and hallowed form, in the beloved disciple, we find in 1Jo 5:10; 3Jo 1:10.

JFB: Luk 9:54 - -- A plausible case, occurring also in Samaria (2Ki 1:10-12).

A plausible case, occurring also in Samaria (2Ki 1:10-12).

Clarke: Luk 9:54 - -- That we command fire - Vengeance belongs to the Lord. What we suffer for his sake, should be left to himself to reprove or punish. The insult is off...

That we command fire - Vengeance belongs to the Lord. What we suffer for his sake, should be left to himself to reprove or punish. The insult is offered to him, not to us. See the note on Mar 3:17.

Calvin: Luk 9:54 - -- 54.And when His disciples James and John saw it. The country itself had perhaps suggested to them the desire of thundering immediately against the un...

54.And when His disciples James and John saw it. The country itself had perhaps suggested to them the desire of thundering immediately against the ungodly; for it was there that Elijah had formerly destroyed, by a fire from heaven, the king’s soldiers who had been sent to apprehend him, (2Kg 1:10.) It therefore occurred to them that the Samaritans, who so basely rejected the Son of God, were at that time devoted to a similar destruction. And here we see to what we are driven by a foolish imitation 591 of the holy fathers. James and John plead the example of Elijah, but they do not consider how far they differ from Elijah; they do not examine properly their own intemperate zeal, nor do they look at the calling of God. Under a pretext equally plausible did the Samaritans cloak their idolatry, our fathers worshipped in this mountain, (Joh 4:20.) But both were in the wrong; for, neglecting the exercise of judgment, they were apes rather than imitators of the holy fathers. Now though it is doubtful whether they think that they have the power in their own hand, or ask Christ to give it to them, I think it more probable that, elated with foolish confidence, they entertain no doubt that they are able to execute vengeance, provided that Christ give his consent.

Defender: Luk 9:54 - -- This was an unthinking emotional outburst by the "sons of thunder," who certainly had no authority or ability to call down fire from heaven as Elijah ...

This was an unthinking emotional outburst by the "sons of thunder," who certainly had no authority or ability to call down fire from heaven as Elijah had done in the land of Samaria 900 years before."

TSK: Luk 9:54 - -- wilt : 2Sa 21:2; 2Ki 10:16, 2Ki 10:31; Jam 1:19, Jam 1:20, Jam 3:14-18 fire : 2Ki 1:10-14; Act 4:29, Act 4:30; Rev 13:3

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Luk 9:54 - -- James and John - They were called Boanerges - sons of thunder - probably on account of their energy and power in preaching the gospel, or of th...

James and John - They were called Boanerges - sons of thunder - probably on account of their energy and power in preaching the gospel, or of their vehement and rash zeal - a remarkable example of which we have in this instance, Mar 3:17.

Wilt thou ... - The insult had been offered to Jesus, their friend, and they felt it; but their zeal was rash and their spirit bad. Vengeance belongs to God: it was not theirs to attempt it.

Fire from heaven - Lightning, to consume them.

As Elias did - By this they wished to justify their zeal. Perhaps, while they were speaking, they saw Jesus look at them with disapprobation, and to vindicate themselves they referred to the case of Elijah. The case is recorded in 2Ki 1:10-12.

Poole: Luk 9:54 - -- The history of Elijah to which the disciples refer, is doubtless that, 2Ki 1:10 , where Elijah, not without direction from God, called fire from hea...

The history of Elijah to which the disciples refer, is doubtless that, 2Ki 1:10 , where Elijah, not without direction from God, called fire from heaven to destroy those captains and their fifties which the king sent to take him.

Haydock: Luk 9:54 - -- Wilt thou that we command fire, &c. In the Greek is added as Elias did. These words might be first in the margin, and thence by transcribers take...

Wilt thou that we command fire, &c. In the Greek is added as Elias did. These words might be first in the margin, and thence by transcribers taken into the text. The two apostles, called the sons of thunder, knew their Master was greater than Elias; and therefore they are for calling for fire from heaven, as he had done. (Witham) ---

It was probably this trait in the life of James and John, which gained t hem the name of boanerges, the sons of thunder. Their too great zeal for the glory of Jesus Christ, and the spirit of revenge, of which they were not yet healed, caused them to make this petition; which seemed in some manner justified by the example of Elias, 4th book of Kings, chap. i. 10. Many editions have the addition of these words, as Elias did. (Calmet)

Gill: Luk 9:54 - -- And when his disciples, James and John, saw this,.... The Persic version reads thus; when "James and John, and the disciples saw this"; that is, the o...

And when his disciples, James and John, saw this,.... The Persic version reads thus; when "James and John, and the disciples saw this"; that is, the other disciples besides them, so making all the disciples say what follows; whereas only those two are intended, who having been the messengers, were the more provoked at this indignity to their Lord and master:

they said, Lord, wilt thou that we command fire to come down from heaven, and consume them; being enraged at this conduct of the Samaritans towards, Christ, and burning with love to him, and zeal for his honour; being "Boanerges's", sons of thunder, they were for punishing of them in a most terrible manner, even with, fire from heaven; by which Sodom and Gomorrah, and the cities of the plain, were destroyed: this they doubted not of doing, knowing what miraculous power was conferred upon them; but did not think proper to attempt to exert it, until they had asked leave of Christ to do it:

even as Elias did; upon the two captains of fifties, with their fifties, as recorded in 2Ki 1:9 This clause was wanting in a certain copy of Beza's, and is not in the Vulgate Latin version; but is in other copies and versions, and by all means to be retained.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Luk 9:54 An allusion to 2 Kgs 1:10, 12, 14.

Geneva Bible: Luk 9:54 ( 12 ) And when his disciples James and John saw [this], they said, Lord, wilt thou that we command fire to come down from heaven, and consume them, e...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Luk 9:1-62 - --1 Christ sends his apostles to work miracles, and to preach.7 Herod desires to see Christ.10 The apostles return.12 Christ feeds five thousand;18 enqu...

MHCC: Luk 9:51-56 - --The disciples did not consider that the conduct of the Samaritans was rather the effect of national prejudices and bigotry, than of enmity to the word...

Matthew Henry: Luk 9:51-56 - -- This passage of story we have not in any other of the evangelists, and it seems to come in here for the sake of its affinity with that next before, ...

Barclay: Luk 9:49-56 - --Here we have two lessons in tolerance. There were many exorcists in Palestine, all claiming to be able to cast out demons; and no doubt John regarde...

Constable: Luk 9:51--19:28 - --V. Jesus' ministry on the way to Jerusalem 9:51--19:27 This large section of the Book of Luke has no counterpart...

Constable: Luk 9:51--10:25 - --A. The responsibilities and rewards of discipleship 9:51-10:24 This part of the new section continues to...

Constable: Luk 9:51-56 - --1. The importance of toleration 9:51-56 The first verse (9:51) sets the agenda for all that follows until Jesus' Triumphal Entry. It was now time for ...

College: Luk 9:1-62 - --LUKE 9 J. JESUS AND HIS APOSTLES (9:1-50) 1. Jesus Sends Out the Twelve (9:1-6) 1 When Jesus had called the Twelve together, he gave them power and...

McGarvey: Luk 9:51-56 - -- LXXVI. THE PRIVATE JOURNEY TO JERUSALEM. (Through Samaria. Probably September, A. D. 29.) cLUKE IX. 51-56; dJOHN VII. 10.    d10 But ...

Lapide: Luk 9:1-62 - --CHAPTER 9 Ver. 8.— One of the old prophets was risen again. As Enoch and Elias will rise again before the end of all things, to resist Antichrist....

expand all
Introduction / Outline

Robertson: Luke (Book Introduction) THE GOSPEL OF LUKE By Way of Introduction There is not room here for a full discussion of all the interesting problems raised by Luke as the autho...

JFB: Luke (Book Introduction) THE writer of this Gospel is universally allowed to have been Lucas (an abbreviated form of Lucanus, as Silas of Silvanus), though he is not expressly...

JFB: Luke (Outline) ANNOUNCEMENT OF THE FORERUNNER. (Luke 1:5-25) ANNUNCIATION OF CHRIST. (Luk 1:26-38) VISIT OF MARY TO ELISABETH. (Luke 1:39-56) BIRTH AND CIRCUMCISION...

TSK: Luke (Book Introduction) Luke, to whom this Gospel has been uniformly attributed from the earliest ages of the Christian church, is generally allowed to have been " the belove...

TSK: Luke 9 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Luk 9:1, Christ sends his apostles to work miracles, and to preach; Luk 9:7, Herod desires to see Christ; Luk 9:10, The apostles return; ...

Poole: Luke 9 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 9

MHCC: Luke (Book Introduction) This evangelist is generally supposed to have been a physician, and a companion of the apostle Paul. The style of his writings, and his acquaintance w...

MHCC: Luke 9 (Chapter Introduction) (Luk 9:1-9) The apostles sent forth. (Luk 9:10-17) The multitude miraculously fed. (Luk 9:18-27) Peter's testimony to Christ, Self-denial enjoined. ...

Matthew Henry: Luke (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Gospel According to St. Luke We are now entering into the labours of another evangelist; his name ...

Matthew Henry: Luke 9 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have, I. The commission Christ gave to his twelve apostles to go out for some time to preach the gospel, and confirm it by mira...

Barclay: Luke (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO SAINT LUKE A Lovely Book And Its Author The gospel according to St. Luke has been called the loveliest book ...

Barclay: Luke 9 (Chapter Introduction) Emissaries Of The King (Luk_9:1-9) Food For The Hungry (Luk_9:10-17) The Great Discovery (Luk_9:18-22) The Conditions Of Service (Luk_9:23-27) Th...

Constable: Luke (Book Introduction) Introduction Writer Several factors indicate that the writer of this Gospel was the sa...

Constable: Luke (Outline) Outline I. Introduction 1:1-4 II. The birth and childhood of Jesus 1:5-2:52 ...

Constable: Luke Luke Bibliography Alford, Henry. The Greek Testament. New ed. 4 vols. London: Rivingtons, 1880. ...

Haydock: Luke (Book Introduction) THE HOLY GOSPEL OF JESUS CHRIST, ACCORDING TO ST. LUKE. INTRODUCTION St. Luke was a physician, a native of Antioch, the metropolis of Syria, a...

Gill: Luke (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO LUKE The writer of this Gospel, Luke, has been, by some, thought, as Origen a relates, to be the same with Lucius, mentioned in Ro...

College: Luke (Book Introduction) FOREWORD "Many have undertaken" to write commentaries on the Gospel of Luke, and a large number of these are very good. "It seemed good also to me" t...

College: Luke (Outline) OUTLINE There is general agreement among serious students of Luke's Gospel regarding its structure. I. Prologue Luke 1:1-4 II. Infancy Narrative...

Lapide: Luke (Book Introduction) S. LUKE'S GOSPEL Third Edition JOHN HODGES, AGAR STREET, CHARING CROSS, LONDON. 1892. INTRODUCTION. ——o—— THE Holy Gospel of Jesus Ch...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


created in 0.09 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA