
Text -- Nehemiah 11:1-3 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Neh 11:1 - -- That the buildings of the city might be compleated, and the safety of it better provided for.
That the buildings of the city might be compleated, and the safety of it better provided for.

Wesley: Neh 11:2 - -- Because they denied themselves, and their own safety and profit for the publick good; for this city was the butt of all the malicious plots of their e...
Because they denied themselves, and their own safety and profit for the publick good; for this city was the butt of all the malicious plots of their enemies; and for the present it was rather chargeable than beneficial to its inhabitants.

Of Judea, which was now made a province.

Wesley: Neh 11:3 - -- The generality of the people of Israel, whether of Judah, or Benjamin, or any other tribe. These he calls Israel rather than Judah, because there were...
The generality of the people of Israel, whether of Judah, or Benjamin, or any other tribe. These he calls Israel rather than Judah, because there were many of the other tribes now incorporated with them; and because none of the tribes of Israel, except Judah and Benjamin, dwelt in Jerusalem.
JFB: Neh 11:1 - -- That city being the metropolis of the country, it was right and proper that the seat of government should be there. But the exigency of the times requ...
That city being the metropolis of the country, it was right and proper that the seat of government should be there. But the exigency of the times required that special measures should be taken to insure the residence of an adequate population for the custody of the buildings and the defense of the city. From the annoyances of restless and malignant enemies, who tried every means to demolish the rising fortifications, there was some danger attending a settlement in Jerusalem. Hence the greater part of the returned exiles, in order to earn as well as secure the rewards of their duty, preferred to remain in the country or the provincial towns. To remedy this state of things, it was resolved to select every tenth man of the tribes of Judah and Benjamin by lot, to become a permanent inhabitant of the capital. The necessity of such an expedient commended it to the general approval. It was the more readily submitted to because the lot was resorted to on all the most critical conjunctures of the Jewish history, and regarded by the people as a divine decision (Pro 18:18). This awakened strongly the national spirit; and patriotic volunteers came forward readily to meet the wishes of the authorities, a service which, implying great self-denial as well as courage, was reckoned in the circumstances of so much importance as entitled them to the public gratitude. No wonder that the conduct of these volunteers drew forth the tribute of public admiration; for they sacrificed their personal safety and comfort for the interests of the community because Jerusalem was at that time a place against which the enemies of the Jews were directing a thousand plots. Therefore, residence in it at such a juncture was attended with expense and various annoyances from which a country life was entirely free.

JFB: Neh 11:3 - -- That is, Judea. Nehemiah speaks of it, as it then was, a small appendix of the Persian empire.
That is, Judea. Nehemiah speaks of it, as it then was, a small appendix of the Persian empire.

JFB: Neh 11:3 - -- The returned exiles, who had come from Babylon, repaired generally, and by a natural impulse, to the lands and cities throughout the country which had...
The returned exiles, who had come from Babylon, repaired generally, and by a natural impulse, to the lands and cities throughout the country which had been anciently assigned them.

JFB: Neh 11:3 - -- This general name, which designated the descendants of Jacob before the unhappy division of the two kingdoms under Rehoboam, was restored after the ca...
This general name, which designated the descendants of Jacob before the unhappy division of the two kingdoms under Rehoboam, was restored after the captivity, the Israelites being then united with the Jews, and all traces of their former separation being obliterated. Although the majority of the returned exiles belonged to the tribes of Judah and Benjamin, they are here called Israel because a large number out of all the tribes were now intermingled, and these were principally the occupiers of the rural villages, while none but those of Judah and Benjamin resided in Jerusalem.

JFB: Neh 11:3 - -- These took possession of the cities allotted to them according as they had opportunity.
These took possession of the cities allotted to them according as they had opportunity.

JFB: Neh 11:3 - -- A certain order of men, either Gibeonites or persons joined with them, who were devoted to the service of God.
A certain order of men, either Gibeonites or persons joined with them, who were devoted to the service of God.
Clarke: Neh 11:1 - -- To bring one of ten - Jerusalem certainly had many inhabitants at this time; but not sufficient to preserve the city, which was now encompassed with...
To bring one of ten - Jerusalem certainly had many inhabitants at this time; but not sufficient to preserve the city, which was now encompassed with a wall, and the rebuilding of which was going on fast. Nehemiah therefore obliged one tenth of the country people to come and dwell in it, that the population might be sufficient for the preservation and defense of the city. Ten were set apart, and the lot cast among them to see which one of the ten should take up his residence in the city.

Clarke: Neh 11:2 - -- All the men that willingly offered - Some volunteered their services, which was considered a sacrifice to patriotism at that time, as Jerusalem affo...
All the men that willingly offered - Some volunteered their services, which was considered a sacrifice to patriotism at that time, as Jerusalem afforded very few advantages, and was a place of considerable danger; hence the people spoke well of them, and no doubt prayed for God’ s blessing upon them.

Clarke: Neh 11:3 - -- Now these are the chief - A good deal of difference will be found between the enumeration here and that in 1Ch 9:2, etc. There, those only who came ...
Now these are the chief - A good deal of difference will be found between the enumeration here and that in 1Ch 9:2, etc. There, those only who came with Zerubbabel appear to be numbered; here, those, and the persons who came with Ezra and Nehemiah, enter into the account.
Defender: Neh 11:2 - -- With the walls completed and temple services fully operational, it was necessary to increase the internal population of Jerusalem in order to make the...
With the walls completed and temple services fully operational, it was necessary to increase the internal population of Jerusalem in order to make the city function effectively. In addition to the leaders and the Nethinims, it was desired that ten percent of the Israelites live there. Some volunteered; others were selected by lot (Neh 11:1)."

Defender: Neh 11:3 - -- The list of names in Nehemiah 11:3-24 corresponds in general to the list of returnees in 1 Chronicles 9:2-17. Probably these were the organized groups...
The list of names in Nehemiah 11:3-24 corresponds in general to the list of returnees in 1 Chronicles 9:2-17. Probably these were the organized groups and their leaders when Nehemiah arrived at Jerusalem."
TSK: Neh 11:1 - -- the rulers : Neh 7:4, Neh 7:5; Deu 17:8, Deu 17:9; Psa 122:5
cast lots : Jerusalem certainly had many inhabitants at this time, but not sufficient to ...
the rulers : Neh 7:4, Neh 7:5; Deu 17:8, Deu 17:9; Psa 122:5
cast lots : Jerusalem certainly had many inhabitants at this time, but not sufficient to preserve the city, which was now encompassed with a wall, the building of which was going on fast. Nehemiah, therefore, obliged one-tenth of the country people to come and dwell in it, that the population might be sufficient for the defence of the city. Some volunteered their services, which was at that time considered a sacrifice to patriotism; as Jerusalem then afforded very few advantages, and was a place of considerable dangercaps1 . hcaps0 ence ""the people blessed them that willingly offered themselves.""Neh 10:34; Jos 18:10; 1Ch 26:13; Pro 16:33; Act 1:24
one of ten : Jdg 20:9, Jdg 20:10
the holy : Neh 11:18; Isa 48:2, Isa 52:1; Mat 4:5, Mat 27:53

TSK: Neh 11:2 - -- blessed : Deu 24:13; Job 29:13, Job 31:20
willingly : Jdg 5:9; 2Co 8:16, 2Co 8:17

TSK: Neh 11:3 - -- Now : There is a good deal of difference between this enumeration and that in Chronicles; as this comprehends not only those who came first with Zerub...
Now : There is a good deal of difference between this enumeration and that in Chronicles; as this comprehends not only those who came first with Zerubbabel, but also those who came with Ezra and Nehemiah. See note on 1Ch 9:18.
Israel : Neh 7:73; 1Ch 9:1-3; Ezr 2:70
Nethinims : Ezr 2:43, Ezr 2:55
the children : Neh 7:57-60; Ezr 2:55-58

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Neh 11:1
Barnes: Neh 11:1 - -- To bring one of ten - Artificial enlargements of capitals by forcible transfers of population to them, were not unusual in ancient times. About...
To bring one of ten - Artificial enlargements of capitals by forcible transfers of population to them, were not unusual in ancient times. About 500 B.C., Syracuse became a great city in this way. Tradition ascribed the greatness of Rome, in part, to this cause.
Poole: Neh 11:1 - -- The rulers of the people dwelt at Jerusalem which their very office in some sort obliged them to do. To bring one of ten to dwell in Jerusalem that...
The rulers of the people dwelt at Jerusalem which their very office in some sort obliged them to do. To bring one of ten to dwell in Jerusalem that the buildings of the city might be completed, and the honour and safety of it better provided for.

Poole: Neh 11:2 - -- Because they denied themselves, and their own safety and profit, for the public good; for this city was the butt of all the malicious plots of their...
Because they denied themselves, and their own safety and profit, for the public good; for this city was the butt of all the malicious plots of their enemies; and for the present it was rather chargeable than beneficial to its inhabitants; whereas the country did more easily and certainly afford them supplies.

Poole: Neh 11:3 - -- The chief of the province i.e. of Judea, which was now made a province.
To wit, Israel i.e. the generality of the people of Israel, whether of Juda...
The chief of the province i.e. of Judea, which was now made a province.
To wit, Israel i.e. the generality of the people of Israel, whether of Judah, or Benjamin, or any other tribe; as appears by this general enumeration of all the inhabitants of the land, in which either the people of Judah and Benjamin are included under the title of Israel, or they are not here mentioned; which is absurd to think, because they made up the greatest number of them. And these he calls
Israel rather than Judah, partly because there were many of the other tribes now joined and incorporated with them; and partly because none of the tribes of Israel, except Judah and Benjamin, dwelt in Jerusalem, as appears from the sequel.
Haydock: Neh 11:1 - -- Lots. Those who had a mind to fix their abode at Jerusalem, received every encouragement. But some were compelled, that the city might regain its a...
Lots. Those who had a mind to fix their abode at Jerusalem, received every encouragement. But some were compelled, that the city might regain its ancient splendour, and become the bulwark of the nation. Josephus ([Antiquities?] xi. 5.) says, that Nehemias built at his own expense houses for the priest and Levites, who chose to reside there.

Haydock: Neh 11:2 - -- Blessed. Applauding their zeal and disinterestedness, as the city was yet only a heap of ruins. (Calmet) ---
Some from the other ten tribes return...
Blessed. Applauding their zeal and disinterestedness, as the city was yet only a heap of ruins. (Calmet) ---
Some from the other ten tribes returned; but the transactions of three tribes are more particularly noticed. (Ven. Bede) (Worthington)

Solomon. See 1 Esdras ii. 55., and 1 Paralipomenon ix. 2.
Gill: Neh 11:1 - -- And the rulers of the people dwelt at Jerusalem,.... Where it was proper they should, being the metropolis of the nation, both for the performance of ...
And the rulers of the people dwelt at Jerusalem,.... Where it was proper they should, being the metropolis of the nation, both for the performance of their offices, and to protect and defend it, as well as to set an example to the people, and encourage them to dwell there also:
the rest of the people also cast lots to bring one of ten to dwell in Jerusalem the holy city; so called, because of the temple and the worship of God in it; and so it is called by Julian the emperor g; and some h have thought that the Cadytis of Herodotus i is the same with Jerusalem, which had its name from
and nine parts to dwell in other cities; to which they belonged, or where they pleased, any where in the land of Israel.

Gill: Neh 11:2 - -- And the people blessed all the men that willingly offered themselves to dwell at Jerusalem. Who were not taken by lot, but of their own accord settled...
And the people blessed all the men that willingly offered themselves to dwell at Jerusalem. Who were not taken by lot, but of their own accord settled at Jerusalem; they praised them for it, and wished them all happiness and prosperity, since they denied themselves of ease and profit for the sake of the public good; and it is this which makes the difference between the list of the inhabitants of Jerusalem in 1Ch 9:2 &c. and this here, that takes in all that settled there, whether voluntarily or by lot; this only such as were fixed by the lot, and of them only those who were of greatest note and esteem, as Jarchi observes, and so it follows.

Gill: Neh 11:3 - -- Now these are the chief of the province that dwelt in Jerusalem,.... That is, of Judea, reduced to a province by the king of Babylon, and now a provin...
Now these are the chief of the province that dwelt in Jerusalem,.... That is, of Judea, reduced to a province by the king of Babylon, and now a province of the Persian monarchy:
but in the cities of Judah dwelt everyone in his possession in their cities; in which they or their ancestors had formerly dwelt: to wit, Israel: the people in general of the tribes of Judah and Benjamin, and such of the other tribes that returned with them:
the priests, and the Levites, and the Nethinims, and the children of Solomon's servants; of whom see Ezr 2:55.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Neh 11:1 Heb “nine of the hands.” The word “hand” is used here in the sense or a part or portion.

Geneva Bible -> Neh 11:1
Geneva Bible: Neh 11:1 And the rulers of the people dwelt at Jerusalem: the rest of the people also cast lots, ( a ) to bring one of ten to dwell in Jerusalem the holy city,...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Neh 11:1-36
TSK Synopsis: Neh 11:1-36 - --1 The rulers, voluntary men, and the tenth man chosen by lot, dwell at Jerusalem.3 A catalogue of their names.20 The residue dwell in other cities.
MHCC -> Neh 11:1-36
MHCC: Neh 11:1-36 - --In all ages, men have preferred their own ease and advantage to the public good. Even the professors of religion too commonly seek their own, and not ...
Matthew Henry -> Neh 11:1-19
Matthew Henry: Neh 11:1-19 - -- Jerusalem is called here the holy city (Neh 11:1), because there the temple was, and that was the place God had chosen to put his name there; upon...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Neh 11:1-2; Neh 11:3-6
Keil-Delitzsch: Neh 11:1-2 - --
Neh 11:1 and Neh 11:2 narrate the carrying out of Nehemiah's resolution, Neh 7:4, tomake Jerusalem more populous, and follow Neh 7:5 as to matter, b...

Keil-Delitzsch: Neh 11:3-6 - --
The inhabitants of Jerusalem and the other cities . - Neh 11:3 The title reads: "These are the heads of the province who dwelt atJerusalem; and in ...
Constable: Neh 7:73--13:31 - --II. THE RESTORATION OF THE JEWS chs. 8--13
One writer viewed chapters 8-13 (really 7:73-13:37) as the third part...

Constable: Neh 11:1--12:27 - --B. The Residents of the Land 11:1-12:26
When the exiles returned to the Promised Land, living in Jerusal...
