
Text -- Nehemiah 5:1-6 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Which is in itself a blessing, but to us is turned into a curse.

We are forced to take up corn, upon unreasonable terms.

Wesley: Neh 5:3 - -- Which might happen, both from the multitude of the people in and near Jerusalem, from their work, which wholly took them up, and kept them from taking...
Which might happen, both from the multitude of the people in and near Jerusalem, from their work, which wholly took them up, and kept them from taking care of their families, and from the expectation of their enemies invasion, which hindered them from going abroad to fetch provision, and the people round about from bringing it to them.

Wesley: Neh 5:5 - -- We are of the same nature, and religion with them, though they treat us as if we were beasts or Heathens.
We are of the same nature, and religion with them, though they treat us as if we were beasts or Heathens.

We are compelled to sell them for our subsistence.

Wesley: Neh 5:5 - -- Which was an evidence of their great necessity, because their daughters were more tender, and weak, and unfit for bond - service, and more exposed to ...
Which was an evidence of their great necessity, because their daughters were more tender, and weak, and unfit for bond - service, and more exposed to injuries than their sons.
JFB -> Neh 5:1-5; Neh 5:6-12
JFB: Neh 5:1-5 - -- Such a crisis in the condition of the Jews in Jerusalem--fatigued with hard labor and harassed by the machinations of restless enemies, the majority o...
Such a crisis in the condition of the Jews in Jerusalem--fatigued with hard labor and harassed by the machinations of restless enemies, the majority of them poor, and the bright visions which hope had painted of pure happiness on their return to the land of their fathers being unrealized--must have been very trying to their faith and patience. But, in addition to these vexatious oppressions, many began to sink under a new and more grievous evil. The poor made loud complaints against the rich for taking advantage of their necessities, and grinding them by usurious exactions. Many of them had, in consequence of these oppressions, been driven to such extremities that they had to mortgage their lands and houses to enable them to pay the taxes to the Persian government, and ultimately even to sell their children for slaves to procure the means of subsistence. The condition of the poorer inhabitants was indeed deplorable; for, besides the deficient harvests caused by the great rains (Ezr 10:9; also Hag 1:6-11), a dearth was now threatened by the enemy keeping such a multitude pent up in the city, and preventing the country people bringing in provisions.

JFB: Neh 5:6-12 - -- When such disorders came to the knowledge of the governor, his honest indignation was roused against the perpetrators of the evil. Having summoned a p...
When such disorders came to the knowledge of the governor, his honest indignation was roused against the perpetrators of the evil. Having summoned a public assembly, he denounced their conduct in terms of just severity. He contrasted it with his own in redeeming with his money some of the Jewish exiles who, through debt or otherwise, had lost their personal liberty in Babylon. He urged the rich creditors not only to abandon their illegal and oppressive system of usury, but to restore the fields and vineyards of the poor, so that a remedy might be put to an evil the introduction of which had led to much actual disorder, and the continuance of which would inevitably prove ruinous to the newly restored colony, by violating the fundamental principles of the Hebrew constitution. The remonstrance was effectual. The conscience of the usurious oppressors could not resist the touching and powerful appeal. With mingled emotions of shame, contrition, and fear, they with one voice expressed their readiness to comply with the governor's recommendation. The proceedings were closed by the parties binding themselves by a solemn oath, administered by the priests, that they would redeem their pledge, as well as by the governor invoking, by the solemn and significant gesture of shaking a corner of his garment, a malediction on those who should violate it. The historian has taken care to record that the people did according to this promise.
Clarke: Neh 5:2 - -- We, our sons, and our daughters, are many - Our families are larger than we can provide for; we are obliged to go in debt; and our richer brethren t...
We, our sons, and our daughters, are many - Our families are larger than we can provide for; we are obliged to go in debt; and our richer brethren take advantage of our necessitous situation, and oppress us. The details which are given in the next verse are sufficiently plain.

Clarke: Neh 5:3 - -- Because of the dearth - About the time of Zerubbabel, God had sent a judicial dearth upon the land, as we learn from Haggai, Hag 1:9, etc., for the ...
Because of the dearth - About the time of Zerubbabel, God had sent a judicial dearth upon the land, as we learn from Haggai, Hag 1:9, etc., for the people it seems were more intent on building houses for themselves than on rebuilding the house of the Lord: "Ye looked for much, and, lo, it is come to little; because of mine house that is waste; and ye run, every man unto his own house. Therefore the heaven over you is stayed from dew, and the earth is stayed from her fruit. And I called for a drought upon the land, and upon the mountains, and upon the corn, and upon the new wine, and upon the oil, and upon that which the ground brought forth; and upon men, and upon cattle, and upon all the labor of the hands."This dearth might have been continued, or its effects still felt; but it is more likely that there was a new dearth owing to the great number of people, for whose support the land that had been brought into cultivation was not sufficient.

Clarke: Neh 5:4 - -- We have borrowed money - This should be read, We have borrowed money for the king’ s tribute on our lands and vineyards. They had a tax to pay ...
We have borrowed money - This should be read, We have borrowed money for the king’ s tribute on our lands and vineyards. They had a tax to pay to the Persian king in token of their subjection to him, and though it is not likely it was heavy, yet they were not able to pay it.
Defender -> Neh 5:6
Defender: Neh 5:6 - -- Nehemiah's anger was justified. As leader and governor of the Jews in Jerusalem, he had made great sacrifices for the people, both in his labors (Neh ...
Nehemiah's anger was justified. As leader and governor of the Jews in Jerusalem, he had made great sacrifices for the people, both in his labors (Neh 4:21-23) and in his finances (Neh 5:14-18). Yet he was encountering not only fierce external opposition from the people of the land, but also internal profiteering by certain leaders of the Jews (Neh 5:1-5). Those Jews who were either fearful or slothful tried to discourage him (Neh 4:10-12). Christian leaders in every age who have undertaken a vital and needed work for God have repeatedly encountered similar problems, both external and internal. Nehemiah's persistence and courage under such circumstances could be their example and inspiration."
TSK: Neh 5:1 - -- a great cry : Exo 3:7, Exo 22:25-27; Job 31:38, Job 31:39, Job 34:28; Isa 5:7; Luk 18:7; Jam 5:4
their brethren : Lev 25:35-37; Deu 15:7-11; Act 7:26;...
a great cry : Exo 3:7, Exo 22:25-27; Job 31:38, Job 31:39, Job 34:28; Isa 5:7; Luk 18:7; Jam 5:4
their brethren : Lev 25:35-37; Deu 15:7-11; Act 7:26; 1Co 6:6-8

TSK: Neh 5:2 - -- our sons : Psa 127:3-5, Psa 128:2-4; Mal 2:2
we take up corn : Gen 41:57, Gen 42:2, Gen 43:8
our sons : Psa 127:3-5, Psa 128:2-4; Mal 2:2

TSK: Neh 5:4 - -- the king’ s tribute : Neh 9:37; Deu 28:47, Deu 28:48; Jos 16:10; 1Ki 9:21; Ezr 4:13, Ezr 4:20

TSK: Neh 5:5 - -- our flesh : Gen 37:27; Isa 58:7; Jam 2:5, Jam 2:6
we : Exo 21:1-11; Lev 25:39-43; 2Ki 4:1; Mat 18:25
our flesh : Gen 37:27; Isa 58:7; Jam 2:5, Jam 2:6
we : Exo 21:1-11; Lev 25:39-43; 2Ki 4:1; Mat 18:25

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Neh 5:2 - -- Are many - A slight emendation brings this verse into exact parallelism with the next, and gives the sense - "We have pledged our sons and our ...
Are many - A slight emendation brings this verse into exact parallelism with the next, and gives the sense - "We have pledged our sons and our daughters, that we might get corn, and eat and live."Compare Neh 5:5.

Barnes: Neh 5:4 - -- The king’ s tribute - The tax payable to the Persian monarch (compare Ezr 4:13; Est 10:1). In ancient times, heavy taxation was often prod...

Barnes: Neh 5:5 - -- The power of a father to sell his daughter into slavery is expressly mentioned in the Law Exo 21:7. The power to sell a son appears from this passag...
The power of a father to sell his daughter into slavery is expressly mentioned in the Law Exo 21:7. The power to sell a son appears from this passage. In either case, the sale held good for only six years, or until the next year of jubilee (see the marginal references).
Poole: Neh 5:2 - -- We, our sons, and our daughters, are many which is in itself a blessing, but to us is turned into a curse.
We take up corn for them i.e. we are for...
We, our sons, and our daughters, are many which is in itself a blessing, but to us is turned into a curse.
We take up corn for them i.e. we are forced by our and their necessities to take up corn, to wit, upon their own unreasonable terms, as is here implied, and plainly expressed in the following relation. Others, Let us take up , &c., i.e. seeing we do the public work, let provision be made for us and our children out of the public stock. But this is no petition, but a complaint, as will appear.

Poole: Neh 5:3 - -- Which might easily happen, both from the multitude of the people now in and near Jerusalem, and from their building work, which wholly took them up,...
Which might easily happen, both from the multitude of the people now in and near Jerusalem, and from their building work, which wholly took them up, and kept them from taking care of their own families, and from the expectation and dread of their enemies’ invasion, which hindered them from going abroad to fetch in provision, and the people round about from bringing it in to them; or from divers other causes.

Poole: Neh 5:5 - -- Our flesh is as the flesh of our brethren we are of the same nature, and nation, and religion with them although they treat us as if we were beasts o...
Our flesh is as the flesh of our brethren we are of the same nature, and nation, and religion with them although they treat us as if we were beasts or heathens, forgetting both humanity and God’ s law, Deu 15:7 .
We bring into bondage we are compelled to sell them for our subsistence.
Our sons and our daughters which was an evidence of their great necessity, because their daughters were more tender, and weak, and unfit for bond-service, and more exposed to injuries, than their sons.
Neither is it in our power to redeem them which we are allowed to do, Exo 21:7 , but have not wherewith to do it.
Haydock: Neh 5:1 - -- Cry. Ven. Bede (iii. 21.) complains of some pastors who neglect the flock, but exacted revenues. May not the same complaint still be made? (Worthi...
Cry. Ven. Bede (iii. 21.) complains of some pastors who neglect the flock, but exacted revenues. May not the same complaint still be made? (Worthington)

Haydock: Neh 5:2 - -- Very. Syriac, "and our brethren are too numerous" to find meat. ---
For, &c. Hebrew, Septuagint, &c., "by force." (Abenezra, &c.) ---
Yet most ...
Very. Syriac, "and our brethren are too numerous" to find meat. ---
For, &c. Hebrew, Septuagint, &c., "by force." (Abenezra, &c.) ---
Yet most people explain it in the sense of the Vulgate. It was permitted to sell children in extreme distress, Exodus xxi. 7. (Grotius) (Calmet)

Let us. Protestants, "We have mortgaged." ---
Famine, or "hunger." (Haydock)

Haydock: Neh 5:4 - -- Let us. Septuagint Mont.[Montanus?], "We have borrowed" on usury, contrary to Exodus xxii. 25. The Jews were still obliged to pay tribute.
Let us. Septuagint Mont.[Montanus?], "We have borrowed" on usury, contrary to Exodus xxii. 25. The Jews were still obliged to pay tribute.

Haydock: Neh 5:5 - -- Brethren, who are still in captivity, or we are of the same nature as the rich, (Calmet) who so cruelly oppress us. (Menochius)
Brethren, who are still in captivity, or we are of the same nature as the rich, (Calmet) who so cruelly oppress us. (Menochius)
Gill: Neh 5:1 - -- And there was a great cry of the people, and of their wives,.... Those of the poorer sort:
against their brethren the Jews; the rich that oppressed...
And there was a great cry of the people, and of their wives,.... Those of the poorer sort:
against their brethren the Jews; the rich that oppressed them; and this cry or complaint was made to Nehemiah for redress.

Gill: Neh 5:2 - -- For there were that said, we, our sons, and our daughters, are many,.... Not that they complained of the number of their children, for a numerous offs...
For there were that said, we, our sons, and our daughters, are many,.... Not that they complained of the number of their children, for a numerous offspring was always reckoned a blessing with the Jews; but this they observed to show that their families, being large, required a considerable quantity of food to support them:
therefore we take up corn for them, that we may eat and live; that is, they were obliged to take it at an exorbitant price, which is the thing complained of; or otherwise they must starve, the rich taking the advantage of their poverty and present dearth.

Gill: Neh 5:3 - -- Some also there were that said, we have mortgaged our lands, vineyards, and houses,.... Made them over to others, put them into their hands as pledges...
Some also there were that said, we have mortgaged our lands, vineyards, and houses,.... Made them over to others, put them into their hands as pledges for money received of them:
that we may buy corn; for the support of their families:
because of the dearth; or famine; which might be occasioned by their enemies lying in wait and intercepting all provisions that might be brought to them; for this seems not to be the famine spoken of in Hag 1:10 for that was some years before this, and for a reason which now was not.

Gill: Neh 5:4 - -- There were also that said,.... Who though they were able to buy corn for their families without mortgaging their estates: yet, say they:
we have bo...
There were also that said,.... Who though they were able to buy corn for their families without mortgaging their estates: yet, say they:
we have borrowed money for the king's tribute, and that upon our lands and vineyards; for though the priests, Levites, and Nethinims, were exempted from it, yet not the people in common; and some of these were so poor, that they could not pay it without borrowing upon their estates, and paying large usury for it, see Ezr 6:8

Gill: Neh 5:5 - -- Yet now our flesh is as the flesh of our brethren,.... We are of the same nature, nation, stock, and religion: our children as their children; are cir...
Yet now our flesh is as the flesh of our brethren,.... We are of the same nature, nation, stock, and religion: our children as their children; are circumcised as they, and have a right to the same privileges in church and state:
and, lo, we bring into bondage our sons and daughters to be servants; shall be obliged to it, unless relieved:
and some of our daughters are brought into bondage already; sold to be servants, as they might in case of the poverty of parents, Exo 21:7, and some were sometimes taken to be bondmen in payment of their parents' debts, 2Ki 4:1
neither is it in our power to redeem them, for other men have our lands and vineyards; as pledges for money borrowed.

Gill: Neh 5:6 - -- And I was very angry when I heard their cry, and these words. Their complaint expressed in this manner; it not only raised pity and compassion in his ...
And I was very angry when I heard their cry, and these words. Their complaint expressed in this manner; it not only raised pity and compassion in his breast towards these poor distressed people, but indignation at the rich that oppressed them.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes



NET Notes: Neh 5:5 The poor among the returned exiles were being exploited by their rich countrymen. Moneylenders were loaning large amounts of money, and not only colle...

Geneva Bible: Neh 5:1 And there was a great cry of the people and of their wives ( a ) against their brethren the Jews.
( a ) Against the rich who oppressed them.

Geneva Bible: Neh 5:2 For there were that said, We, our sons, and our daughters, [are] many: therefore we take up ( b ) corn [for them], that we may eat, and live.
( b ) T...

Geneva Bible: Neh 5:4 There were also that said, We have borrowed money for the king's ( c ) tribute, [and that upon] our lands and vineyards.
( c ) To pay our tribute to ...

Geneva Bible: Neh 5:5 Yet now our flesh [is] as ( d ) the flesh of our brethren, our children as their children: and, lo, we bring into bondage our sons and our daughters t...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Neh 5:1-19
TSK Synopsis: Neh 5:1-19 - --1 The Jews complain of their debt, mortgage, and bondage.6 Nehemiah rebukes the usurers, and causes them to make a covenant of restitution.14 He forbe...
MHCC -> Neh 5:1-5; Neh 5:6-13
MHCC: Neh 5:1-5 - --Men prey upon their fellow-creatures: by despising the poor they reproach their Maker. Such conduct is a disgrace to any, but who can sufficiently abh...

MHCC: Neh 5:6-13 - --Nehemiah knew that, if he built Jerusalem's walls ever so high, so thick, or so strong, the city could not be safe while there were abuses. The right ...
Matthew Henry -> Neh 5:1-5; Neh 5:6-13
Matthew Henry: Neh 5:1-5 - -- We have here the tears of the oppressed, which Solomon considered, Ecc 4:1. Let us consider them as here they are dropped before Nehemiah, whose off...

Matthew Henry: Neh 5:6-13 - -- It should seem the foregoing complaint was made to Nehemiah at the time when he had his head and hands as full as possible of the public business ab...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Neh 5:1-5; Neh 5:6-13
Keil-Delitzsch: Neh 5:1-5 - --
The people complain of oppression . - Neh 5:1 There arose a greatcry of the people and of their wives against their brethren the Jews, i.e., asappe...

Keil-Delitzsch: Neh 5:6-13 - --
The abolition of usury . - Neh 5:6 Nehemiah was very angry at this complaintand these things, i.e., the injustice which had been brought to hisknow...
Constable: Neh 1:1--7:73 - --I. THE FORTIFICATION OF JERUSALEM chs. 1--7
"The first seven chapters of Nehemiah as well as 12:31-13:31 are wri...

Constable: Neh 3:1--7:5 - --B. The Rebuilding of the Walls 3:1-7:4
Nehemiah described the reconstruction of the walls starting with ...
