collapse all  

Text -- Acts 10:47 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
10:47 “No one can withhold the water for these people to be baptized, who have received the Holy Spirit just as we did, can he?”
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Robertson , Vincent , Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , Combined Bible , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Barclay , Constable , College , McGarvey

Other
Evidence

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Robertson: Act 10:47 - -- Can any man forbid the water? ( Mēti to hudōr dunatai kōlūsai tiṡ ). The negative mēti expects the answer No. The evidence was indispu...

Can any man forbid the water? ( Mēti to hudōr dunatai kōlūsai tiṡ ).

The negative mēti expects the answer No. The evidence was indisputable that these Gentiles were converted and so were entitled to be baptized. See the similar idiom in Luk 6:39. Note the article with "water."Here the baptism of the Holy Spirit had preceded the baptism of water (Act 1:5; Act 11:16). "The greater had been bestowed; could the lesser be withheld?"(Knowling).

Robertson: Act 10:47 - -- That these should not be baptized ( tou mē baptisthēnai toutous ). Ablative case of the articular first aorist passive infinitive of baptizō ...

That these should not be baptized ( tou mē baptisthēnai toutous ).

Ablative case of the articular first aorist passive infinitive of baptizō with the redundant negative after the verb of hindering (kōlūsai ) and the accusative of general reference (toutous ). The redundant negative after the verb of hindering is not necessary though often used in ancient Greek and in the Koiné[28928]š (papyri). Without it see note on Mat 19:14 and note on Act 8:36, and with it see note on Luk 4:42, note on Luk 24:16; and note on Act 14:18. Cf. Robertson, Grammar , pp. 1061, 1094, 1171. The triple negatives here are a bit confusing to the modern mind (mēti in the question, kōlūsai , to hinder or to cut off, mē with baptisthēnai ). Literally, Can any one cut off the water from the being baptized as to these? Meyer: "The water is in this animated language conceived as the element offering itself for the baptism."

Robertson: Act 10:47 - -- As well as we ( hōs kai hēmeis ). The argument was conclusive. God had spoken. Note the query of the eunuch to Philip (Act 8:36).

As well as we ( hōs kai hēmeis ).

The argument was conclusive. God had spoken. Note the query of the eunuch to Philip (Act 8:36).

Vincent: Act 10:47 - -- Water ( τὸ ὕδωρ ) Note the article: the water; co-ordinating the water with the Spirit (see 1Jo 5:8), and designating water as the ...

Water ( τὸ ὕδωρ )

Note the article: the water; co-ordinating the water with the Spirit (see 1Jo 5:8), and designating water as the recognized and customary element of baptism.

Wesley: Act 10:47 - -- He does not say they have the baptism of the Spirit; therefore they do not need baptism with water. But just the contrary: if they have received the S...

He does not say they have the baptism of the Spirit; therefore they do not need baptism with water. But just the contrary: if they have received the Spirit, then baptize them with water. How easily is this question decided, if we will take the word of God for our rule! Either men have received the Holy Ghost or not. If they have not, Repent, saith God, and be baptized, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost. If they have, if they are already baptized with the Holy Ghost, then who can forbid water?

JFB: Act 10:46-48 - -- Mark, he does not say, They have received the Spirit, what need have they for water? but, Having the living discipleship imparted to them and visibly ...

Mark, he does not say, They have received the Spirit, what need have they for water? but, Having the living discipleship imparted to them and visibly stamped upon them, what objection can there be to admitting them, by the seal of baptism, into the full fellowship of the Church?

JFB: Act 10:47 - -- And are thus, in all that is essential to salvation, on a level with ourselves.

And are thus, in all that is essential to salvation, on a level with ourselves.

Clarke: Act 10:47 - -- Can any man forbid water - These had evidently received the Holy Ghost, and consequently were become members of the mystical body of Christ; and yet...

Can any man forbid water - These had evidently received the Holy Ghost, and consequently were become members of the mystical body of Christ; and yet St. Peter requires that they shall receive baptism by water, that they might become members of the Christian Church. In other cases, they received baptism first, and the Spirit afterwards by the imposition of hands: see Act 19:4-6, where the disciples who had received only the baptism of John were baptized again with water in the name of the Lord Jesus; and, after even this, the apostles prayed, and laid their hands on them, before they were made partakers of the Holy Ghost. So we find that Jesus Christ had his water baptism as well as John; and that even he who gave the baptism of the Holy Ghost required the administration of water baptism also. Therefore the baptism of the Spirit did not supersede the baptism by water; nor indeed can it; as baptism, as well as the supper of our Lord, were intended, not only to be means of grace, but standing, irrefragable proofs of the truth of Christianity.

Calvin: Act 10:47 - -- 47.Peter answered Peter reasoneth from the thing to the sign; for, seeing that baptism is an addition or appurtenance of the spiritual grace, he whic...

47.Peter answered Peter reasoneth from the thing to the sign; for, seeing that baptism is an addition or appurtenance of the spiritual grace, he which hath received the Spirit is also apt [fit] to receive baptism; and this is the (most) lawful order, that the minister admit those unto the receiving of the outward sign whom God hath testified to be his children by the mark and pledge of his Spirit; so that faith and doctrine are first. And whereas unlearned men infer thereupon that infants are not to be baptized, it is without all reason. I grant that those who are strangers from the Church must be taught before the sign of adoption be given them; but I say, that the children of the faithful which are born in the Church are from their mother’s womb of the household of the kingdom of God. Yea, the argument which they use preposterously against us do I turn back [retort] upon themselves; for, seeing that God hath adopted the children of the faithful before they be born, I conclude thereupon that they are not to be defrauded of the outward sign; otherwise men shall presume to take that from them which God hath granted them. As touching the manifest grace of the Spirit, there is no absurdity therein, if 720 it follow after baptism in them.

And as this testimony maketh nothing for maintenance of their error, so it doth strongly refute the error of the Papists, who tie the grace of the Spirit to the signs, and think that the same is fet [fetched] from heaven with enchantments, 721 as those witches did think that they did pull down the moon with their charms. But forasmuch as Luke saith that these had the Holy Ghost given them who were not as yet baptized, he showeth that the Spirit is not included in baptism. Lastly, we must note that the apostles were content with water alone when as they did baptize, 722 and would to God this plainness had been retained amongst their posterity, and that they had not gathered here and there divers trifles, whereof baptism is filth in Popery. They think that the worthiness of baptism is adorned with oil, salt, spittle, wax-candles, whereas they are rather filthy pollutions which corrupt the pure and natural [genuine] institution of Christ.

TSK: Act 10:47 - -- Act 8:12, Act 8:36, Act 11:15-17, Act 15:8, Act 15:9; Gen 17:24-26; Rom 4:11, Rom 10:12

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Act 10:47 - -- Can any man forbid water ... - They have shown that they are favored in the same way as the Jewish converts. God has manifested himself to them...

Can any man forbid water ... - They have shown that they are favored in the same way as the Jewish converts. God has manifested himself to them as he did to the Jews on the day of Pentecost. Is it not clear, therefore, that they are entitled to the privilege of Christian baptism? The expression used here is one that would naturally refer to water as being brought; that is, to a small quantity; and would seem to imply that they were baptized, not by immersion, but by pouring or sprinkling.

Poole: Act 10:47 - -- This question, as Act 8:36 , is without question, and denies that any can forbid water, that is, in order to baptize such as these. As if the apostl...

This question, as Act 8:36 , is without question, and denies that any can forbid water, that is, in order to baptize such as these. As if the apostle had argued thus: They that have the grace signified or promised, have a right unto the seal of the promise: but these Gentiles have the grace signified or promised in baptism; they had the inward part, and therefore the outward part could not be denied unto them. He that hath the inheritance, may claim the writings, wax, and parchment that belong unto it.

Haydock: Act 10:47 - -- Can any man forbid water? &c. or doubt that these, on whom the Holy Ghost hath descended, may be made members of the Christian Church, by baptism, a...

Can any man forbid water? &c. or doubt that these, on whom the Holy Ghost hath descended, may be made members of the Christian Church, by baptism, as Christ ordained? (Witham) ---

Such may be the grace of God occasionally towards men, and such their great charity and contrition, that they may have remission, justification, and sanctification, before the external sacraments of baptism, confirmation, and penance be received; as we see in this example: where, at Peter's preaching, they all received the Holy Ghost before any sacrament. But here we also learn one necessary lesson, that such, notwithstanding, must needs receive the sacraments appointed by Christ, which whosoever contemneth, can never be justified. (St. Augustine, sup. Levit. q. 84. T. 4.)

Gill: Act 10:47 - -- Can any man forbid water,.... The use of his river, or bath, or what conveniency he may have for baptizing persons: which shows, that it required a pl...

Can any man forbid water,.... The use of his river, or bath, or what conveniency he may have for baptizing persons: which shows, that it required a place of some quantity of water, sufficient for baptism by immersion, otherwise it would not be in the power of any man to hinder them having a little water, to be sprinkled or poured on the face: unless rather by water should be meant baptism itself; and then the sense is, who can forbid these persons the ordinance of baptism, or deny the administration of it to them? for such who have the Spirit of Christ, are openly Christ's, and therefore have a right to his ordinances; such, being enlightened by him, are able to see to the end of the ordinance; and to such only can it be of use, and they only can please God in it: nor should it be forbidden them; this is to withstand God, act contrary to the commission of Christ, and resist the Holy Ghost; no, not though Gentiles: converted Gentiles, have as good a right as any to this ordinance; descent from Abraham gives no right to it; there is no difference among men under the Gospel dispensation; Christ's commission reaches both to Jews and Gentiles; and there is but one baptism for both.

That these should not be baptized; though they are uncircumcised Gentiles:

which have received the Holy Ghost as well as we; the extraordinary gifts of the Spirit; though, no doubt also, they had received the Spirit, as a spirit of illumination and conviction, as a spirit of regeneration, sanctification, and conversion, and as a spirit of faith and adoption, and as a witness, earnest, and pledge of future glory: and receiving him supposes, that they were without him before, and that he is a gift of God's free grace unto them; and which is no other than the baptism of the Spirit, and is a necessary pre-requisite to water baptism; and they that have the one, are right subjects of the other; nor ought it to be denied them. From hence it appears that water baptism is an ordinance of Christ, to be continued under the Gospel dispensation; it was not only what was practised in the times of John and of Christ, but what was practised by the apostles after the ascension of Christ, in compliance with the commission he gave, which could have respect to no other baptism; since the apostles were not capable of baptizing with any other, not with the baptism of the Spirit: and it is certain from hence, and by other instances, that they did baptize in water; and from the apostle's question it seems, that it must be by immersion in water, as before observed; and from what follows it is clear, that such who are partakers of the Holy Spirit and his grace, are the proper subjects of it.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Act 10:47 The Greek construction anticipates a negative reply which is indicated in the translation by the ‘tag’ question, “can he?” The...

Geneva Bible: Act 10:47 ( 9 ) Can any man forbid water, that these should not be baptized, which have received the Holy Ghost as well as we? ( 9 ) Baptism does not sanctify ...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Act 10:1-48 - --1 Cornelius, a devout man, being commanded by an angel, sends for Peter,11 who by a vision is taught not to despise the Gentiles;17 and is commanded b...

Combined Bible: Act 10:47 - --48. The true explanation of this unusual circumstance is given in the following words, together with Peter's own explanation of it in the eleventh cha...

MHCC: Act 10:44-48 - --The Holy Ghost fell upon others after they were baptized, to confirm them in the faith; but upon these Gentiles before they were baptized, to show tha...

Matthew Henry: Act 10:44-48 - -- We have here the issue and effect of Peter's sermon to Cornelius and his friends. He did not labour in vain among them, but they were all brought ho...

Barclay: Act 10:44-48 - --Even as Peter was speaking things began to happen against which even the Jewish Christians could not argue; the Spirit came upon Cornelius and his fr...

Constable: Act 9:32--Rom 1:1 - --III. THE WITNESS TO THE UTTERMOST PART OF THE EARTH 9:32--28:31 Luke next recorded the church's expansion beyond...

Constable: Act 9:32--12:25 - --A. The extension of the church to Syrian Antioch 9:32-12:24 As Jerusalem had been the Palestinian center...

Constable: Act 10:1--11:19 - --2. The conversion of Cornelius 10:1-11:18 The episode concerning Cornelius is obviously very imp...

Constable: Act 10:44-48 - --The giving of the Holy Spirit to Gentiles 10:44-48 10:44 Peter did not need to call for his hearers to repent on this occasion. As soon as he gave the...

College: Act 10:1-48 - --ACTS 10 F. THE CONVERSION OF THE FIRST GENTILES (10:1-11:18) 1. The Ministry of Peter at Caesarea (10:1-48) The Vision Seen by Cornelius (10:1-8) ...

McGarvey: Act 10:47-48 - --47, 48. The true explanation of this unusual circumstance is given in the following words, together with Peter's own explanation of it in the eleventh...

expand all
Commentary -- Other

Evidence: Act 10:47 Baptism . If we are saved by being water baptized (as certain Scriptures seem to imply), then we are saved by works and not grace. The Holy Spirit fel...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

Robertson: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES By Way of Introduction But for the Acts we should know nothing of the early apostolic period save what is told in the Epi...

JFB: Acts (Book Introduction) THIS book is to the Gospels what the fruit is to the tree that bears it. In the Gospels we see the corn of wheat falling into the ground and dying: in...

JFB: Acts (Outline) INTRODUCTION--LAST DAYS OF OUR LORD UPON EARTH--HIS ASCENSION. (Act 1:1-11) RETURN OF THE ELEVEN TO JERUSALEM--PROCEEDINGS IN THE UPPER ROOM TILL PEN...

TSK: Acts (Book Introduction) The Acts of the Apostles is a most valuable portion of Divine revelation; and, independently of its universal reception in the Christian church, as an...

TSK: Acts 10 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Act 10:1, Cornelius, a devout man, being commanded by an angel, sends for Peter, Act 10:11. who by a vision is taught not to despise the ...

Poole: Acts 10 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 10

MHCC: Acts (Book Introduction) This book unites the Gospels to the Epistles. It contains many particulars concerning the apostles Peter and Paul, and of the Christian church from th...

MHCC: Acts 10 (Chapter Introduction) (Act 10:1-8) Cornelius directed to send for Peter. (Act 10:9-18) Peter's vision. (Act 10:19-33) He goes to Cornelius. (Act 10:34-43) His discourse ...

Matthew Henry: Acts (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Acts of the Apostles We have with an abundant satisfaction seen the foundation of our holy religion...

Matthew Henry: Acts 10 (Chapter Introduction) It is a turn very new and remarkable which the story of this chapter gives to the Acts of the apostles; hitherto, both at Jerusalem and every where...

Barclay: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES A Precious Book In one sense Acts is the most important book in the New Testament. It is the simple truth t...

Barclay: Acts 10 (Chapter Introduction) A Devout Soldier (Act_10:1-8) Peter Learns A Lesson (Act_10:9-16) The Meeting Of Peter And Cornelius (Act_10:17-33) The Heart Of The Gospel (Act_...

Constable: Acts (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The title "Acts of the Apostles" is very ancient. The Anti-Marcioni...

Constable: Acts (Outline) Outline I. The witness in Jerusalem 1:1-6:7 A. The founding of the church 1:1-2:46 ...

Constable: Acts Acts Bibliography Albright, William Foxwell. The Archaeology of Palestine. 1949. Revised ed. Pelican Archaeolog...

Haydock: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES. INTRODUCTION. St. Luke, who had published his gospel, wrote also a second volume, which, from the first ages, hath bee...

Gill: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO ACTS This book, in some copies, is called, "The Acts of the holy Apostles". It contains an history of the ministry and miracles of ...

College: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION As early as the second century the title "The Acts of the Apostles" was given to this document. Before that time the work probably circu...

College: Acts (Outline) OUTLINE I. THE CHURCH IN JERUSALEM - 1:1-8:1a A. INTRODUCTION OF THE BOOK - 1:1-3 B. THE COMMISSIONING OF THE APOSTLES - 1:4-8 C. THE ASCENSI...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #03: Try using operators (AND, OR, NOT, ALL, ANY) to refine your search. [ALL]
created in 0.59 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA