collapse all
Text -- Leviticus 5:1-2 (NET)

Parallel
Cross Reference (TSK)
ITL
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Lev 5:1 - -- And for that is, as that particle is often used. For this declares in particular what the sin was. Or, namely, that of cursing, or blasphemy, or execr...
And for that is, as that particle is often used. For this declares in particular what the sin was. Or, namely, that of cursing, or blasphemy, or execration, as the word commonly signifies, and that either against one's neighbour, or against God. This may seem to be principally intended here, because the crime spoken of is of so high a nature, that he who heard it, was obliged to reveal it, and prosecute the guilty.

Wesley: Lev 5:1 - -- That is, the punishment of it; so that word is oft used, as Gen 19:15, Num 18:1.

Wesley: Lev 5:2 - -- If he do it unawares, yet that would not excuse him, because he should have been more circumspect to avoid all unclean things. Hereby God designed to ...
If he do it unawares, yet that would not excuse him, because he should have been more circumspect to avoid all unclean things. Hereby God designed to awaken men to watchfulness against, and repentance for, their unknown, or unobserved sins.

Wesley: Lev 5:2 - -- Not morally, for the conscience was not directly polluted by these things, but ceremonially.
Not morally, for the conscience was not directly polluted by these things, but ceremonially.
JFB: Lev 5:1 - -- Or, according to some, "the words of adjuration." A proclamation was issued calling any one who could give information, to come before the court and b...
Or, according to some, "the words of adjuration." A proclamation was issued calling any one who could give information, to come before the court and bear testimony to the guilt of a criminal; and the manner in which witnesses were interrogated in the Jewish courts of justice was not by swearing them directly, but adjuring them by reading the words of an oath: "the voice of swearing." The offense, then, for the expiation of which this law provides, was that of a person who neglected or avoided the opportunity of lodging the information which it was in his power to communicate.

JFB: Lev 5:2 - -- A person who, unknown to himself at the time, came in contact with any thing unclean, and either neglected the requisite ceremonies of purification or...
A person who, unknown to himself at the time, came in contact with any thing unclean, and either neglected the requisite ceremonies of purification or engaged in the services of religion while under the taint of ceremonial defilement, might be afterwards convinced that he had committed an offense.
Clarke: Lev 5:1 - -- If a soul sin - It is generally supposed that the case referred to here is that of a person who, being demanded by the civil magistrate to answer up...
If a soul sin - It is generally supposed that the case referred to here is that of a person who, being demanded by the civil magistrate to answer upon oath, refuses to tell what he knows concerning the subject; such a one shall bear his iniquity - shall be considered as guilty in the sight of God, of the transgression which he has endeavored to conceal, and must expect to be punished by him for hiding the iniquity to which he was privy, or suppressing the truth which, being discovered, would have led to the exculpation of the innocent, and the punishment of the guilty.

Clarke: Lev 5:2 - -- Any unclean thing - Either the dead body of a clean animal, or the living or dead carcass of any unclean creature. All such persons were to wash the...
Any unclean thing - Either the dead body of a clean animal, or the living or dead carcass of any unclean creature. All such persons were to wash their clothes and themselves in clean water, and were considered as unclean till the evening, Lev 11:24-31. But if this had been neglected, they were obliged to bring a trespass-offering. What this meant, see in the notes on Leviticus 7 (note).
Calvin: Lev 5:1 - -- 1.And if a soul sin The three kinds of offense, to which Moses refers in the beginning of the chapter, seem to differ much from each other; for the f...
1.And if a soul sin The three kinds of offense, to which Moses refers in the beginning of the chapter, seem to differ much from each other; for the first, when a person concealed a matter which he knew, could not arise from error, yet I include this concealment of which he treats under the head of error, by supposing it to have been when a person should be induced by shame or fear to connive at any crime or offense respecting which he might be interrogated, and so, without any design of perjuring himself, but by blinding himself, should withhold what he would have said, if he had duly examined the matter. Yet these words must be more narrowly discussed, respecting the meaning of which men are not well agreed. Some think that the word

Calvin: Lev 5:2 - -- 2.Or if a soul touch any unclean thing This precept seems not only to be superfluous but also absurd; for Moses had already shewn sufficiently how un...
2.Or if a soul touch any unclean thing This precept seems not only to be superfluous but also absurd; for Moses had already shewn sufficiently how uncleanness contracted by touching a dead body, or any other unclean thing, was to be purged, and had prescribed an easy and inexpensive mode of purification. This repetition appears, therefore, to be useless. But to impose a heavier punishment on an offense which is extenuated by the pretext of error, than where there is no allusion to error, is unjust. But we must remember that not only is the uncleanness itself here punished, but; the inadvertence, from whence it arose that he who was polluted omitted the purification. For it may be that those who thus lie torpid in their sins pollute for a season the service of God. No wonder, then, that a heavier punishment is inflicted, where error, springing from supine and gross security, begets still more sins, that thus believers may be aroused to greater vigilance. Let the reader, therefore, recollect that the offense which is now adverted to did not consist in the mere touching of a dead body, but in the thoughtlessness itself; for if all would diligently meditate on the Law of God, forgetfulness would not so easily steal over them, whereby the distinction between right and wrong is lost. The same is the reason for the following ordinance, where Moses subjects to the same punishment any one who shall have touched an unclean or defiled man: thus the very contact of a woman at a particular period produces pollution.
TSK: Lev 5:1 - -- a soul : Lev 5:15, Lev 5:17, Lev 4:2; Eze 18:4, Eze 18:20
hear : Exo 22:11; Jdg 17:2; 1Ki 8:31, 1Ki 22:16; 2Ch 18:15; Pro 29:24, Pro 30:9; Mat 26:63
t...
a soul : Lev 5:15, Lev 5:17, Lev 4:2; Eze 18:4, Eze 18:20
hear : Exo 22:11; Jdg 17:2; 1Ki 8:31, 1Ki 22:16; 2Ch 18:15; Pro 29:24, Pro 30:9; Mat 26:63
the voice of swearing :
bear : Lev 5:17, Lev 7:18, Lev 17:16, Lev 19:8, Lev 20:17; Num 9:13; Psa 38:4; Isa 53:11; 1Pe 2:24

TSK: Lev 5:2 - -- touch : Lev 7:21, Lev 11:24, Lev 11:28, Lev 11:31, Lev 11:39; Num 19:11-16; Deu 14:8; Isa 52:11; Hag 2:13; 2Co 6:17
hidden : Lev 5:4, Lev 5:17; Psa 19...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Lev 5:1-13
Barnes: Lev 5:1-13 - -- Special occasions are mentioned on which sin-offerings are to be made with a particular confession of the offence for which atonement is sought Lev ...
Special occasions are mentioned on which sin-offerings are to be made with a particular confession of the offence for which atonement is sought Lev 5:5.
Swearing - Adjuration. The case appears to be that of one who has been put upon his oath as a witness by a magistrate, and fails to utter all he has seen and heard (compare the marginal references. and Pro 29:24; Num 5:21).
Hid from him - Either through forgetfulness or indifference, so that purification had been neglected. In such a case there had been a guilty negligence, and a sin-offering was required. On the essential connection between impurity and the sin-offering, see Lev 12:1.
Pronouncing - Idly speaking Psa 106:33. The reference is to an oath to do something uttered in recklessness or passion and forgotten as soon as uttered.
His trespass offering - Rather, as his forfeit, that is, whatever is due for his offence. The term "trespass-offering"is out of place here, since it has become the current designation for a distinct kind of sin-offering mentioned in the next section (see Lev 5:14 note).
A lamb or a kid of the goats - A sheep Lev 4:32 or a shaggy she-goat Lev 4:23.
See Lev 1:14-16; Lev 12:8. In the larger offerings of the ox and the sheep, the fat which was burned upon the altar represented, like the burnt-offering, the dedication of the worshipper; in this case, the same meaning was conveyed by one of the birds being treated as a distinct burnt-offering.
A lamb - One of the flock, either a sheep or a goat.
For his trespass, which he hath committed - As his forfeit for the sin he hath committed.
tenth part of an ephah i. e. - " the tenth deal;"probably less than half a gallon. See Lev 19:36 note. This sin-offering of meal was distinguished from the ordinary
Poole: Lev 5:1 - -- And hear and for that is , as that particle is often used, as Gen 13:15 1Ch 21:12 , compared with 2Sa 24:13 ; for this declares in particular what...
And hear and for that is , as that particle is often used, as Gen 13:15 1Ch 21:12 , compared with 2Sa 24:13 ; for this declares in particular what the sin was. The voice of swearing ; either,
1. Of adjuration upon oath, when the judge adjures a witness to speak the whole truth; of which see Mat 26:63 . But this seems too much to narrow the sense; and this and the other laws, both before and after it, speak of private sins committed through ignorance. Or,
2. Of false swearing before a judge. But that is expressly forbidden, Lev 6:3 . Or rather,
3. Of cursing, or blasphemy, or execration, as the word commonly signifies; and that either,
1. Against one’ s neighbour, as 2Sa 16:7 ; or,
2. Against God, as Lev 24:10,11 ; which may seem to be principally intended here, because the crime here spoken of is of so high a nature, that he who heard it was obliged to reveal it, and prosecute the guilty. And though God be not here mentioned, yet the general word is here to be understood of the most famous particular, as it is frequently in all authors, of which there are many instances.
Whether he hath seen being present when it was said.
Or known by sufficient information from others. He shall bear his iniquity, i.e. the punishment of it, as that word is oft used, as Gen 19:15 Num 18:1 . See of this phrase Lev 17:16 20:20 Isa 53:11 .

Poole: Lev 5:2 - -- Touch any unclean thing to wit, ceremonially; of which see more fully Lev 11:24 , &c.; De 14 .
If it be hidden from him if he do it unwittingly, ye...
Touch any unclean thing to wit, ceremonially; of which see more fully Lev 11:24 , &c.; De 14 .
If it be hidden from him if he do it unwittingly, yet that would not excuse him, because he should have been more diligent and circumspect to avoid all unclean things. Hereby God designed to awaken men to watchfulness against, and repentance for, their unknown or unobserved sins. See Psa 19:12 1Jo 3:20 .
Guilty not morally, for the conscience was not directly polluted by these things, Mat 15:11,18 , but ceremonially.
Haydock: Lev 5:1 - -- Swearing. We are accountable for the sins of others, to which we are accessory, as appears from this and part of the following chapter. No distinct...
Swearing. We are accountable for the sins of others, to which we are accessory, as appears from this and part of the following chapter. No distinction of persons is here noticed. If any one, therefore, be witness to another's promise, confirmed by oath, and, being cited to the bar, refuse to speak, he shall be guilty of sin, and offer the sacrifice proscribed (ver. 6,) for all the preceding cases. Restitution must also be made to the injured person. (Menochius) ---
But others suppose that no sacrifice was allowed for such an obstinate wretch as when not answered when the judge swore or adjured him. He was liable to be put to death. The associate of the thief fell under the like punishment as the thief himself, when he would not reveal the theft to the judge, Proverbs xxix. 24. Others again understand this swearing to mean blaspheming God. If the hearer do not reprehend him, he shall suffer as his accomplice. (Origen; Philo) ---
Junius thinks that the neglect of fraternal correction, was to be expiated by the sacrifice prescribed for the sins of ignorance, concerning which Moses is treating. But it seems that the person here mentioned was to die, as the words he shall bear his iniquity, commonly denote, chap. xix. 8.; &c. (Calmet) ---
When perjury prejudiceth another's cause, we are bound to reveal what we know to the judge, if it can be done so as to avoid scandal. (Worthington) ---
Not. Hebrew editions read loa, instead of la, both here and in 34 other places; an irregularity unknown in some manuscripts, and to the Samaritan copy. Perhaps it may have been occasioned by lu, "to him," being of the same sound with la. (Kennicott)

Haydock: Lev 5:2 - -- Beast. All wild beasts were deemed unclean; but domestic clean cattle, though slain, did not defile; (Calmet) while some of the unclean did, even al...
Beast. All wild beasts were deemed unclean; but domestic clean cattle, though slain, did not defile; (Calmet) while some of the unclean did, even alive, chap. xi. 26, 31. (Haydock) ---
Fishes are comprised under the name reptiles; yet some were not unclean, chap. xi. 9. The Septuagint neglect reptiles, and put "the carcasses of impure abominations;" by which they probably mean dogs, and such things as the Egyptians adored. This verse does not regard those who had only touched something unclean, as such were to be purified at night, by washing their garments; but it refers to those who, having neglected that ordinance, had still ventured to touch something sacred, and were therefore required to offer the sacrifice, assom, (Calmet) as for an irreligious behaviour towards God. (Tirinus)
Gill: Lev 5:1 - -- And if a soul sin,.... The soul is put for the person, and is particularly mentioned, as Ben Melech says, because possessed of will and desire:
and...
And if a soul sin,.... The soul is put for the person, and is particularly mentioned, as Ben Melech says, because possessed of will and desire:
and hear the voice of swearing; or cursing, or adjuration; not of profane swearing, and taking the name of God in vain, but either of false swearing, or perjury, as when a man hears another swear to a thing which he knows is false; or else of adjuration, either the voice of a magistrate or of a neighbour adjuring another, calling upon him with an oath to bear testimony in such a case; this is what the Jews r call the oath of testimony or witness, and which they say s is binding in whatsoever language it is heard:
and is a witness; is able to bear witness to the thing he is adjured about:
whether he hath seen or known of it; what he has seen with his eyes, or knows by any means: of such a case, the Jews observe t, that there may be seeing without knowing, or knowing without seeing, and in either case a man ought to bear witness:
if he do not utter it; tell the truth, declare what he has seen or known:
then he shall bear his iniquity; he shall be charged with sin, and be obliged to acknowledge his offence, and bring a trespass offering for it: it is said u, that the witnesses are not guilty of the oath of the testimony, but in these ten cases; if they are required; if the testimony is concerning goods; if the goods are movable; if he that requires binds himself to pay for their testimony only, in case they bear witness; if they refuse after required; if they refuse in the sanhedrim; if the adjuration or oath is made there by the name of God, or his titles; if knowledge of the testimony goes before the oath; if he particularizes his witnesses in the time of the oath, or at the time of the requirement; and if the oath is in a language they understood.

Gill: Lev 5:2 - -- Or if a soul touch any unclean thing,.... Meaning an Israelite, for only such were bound by this law, which pronounced a person unclean that touched a...
Or if a soul touch any unclean thing,.... Meaning an Israelite, for only such were bound by this law, which pronounced a person unclean that touched anything that was so in a ceremonial sense; this is the general, including whatsoever by the law was unclean; the particulars follow:
whether it be a carcass of an unclean beast, as the camel, the coney, the hare, and the swine, Lev 11:2.
or a carcass of unclean cattle; as the horse, and the ass, which were unclean for food, and their dead carcasses not to be touched, Lev 11:26.
or the carcass of unclean creeping things: such as are mentioned in Lev 11:29.
and if it be hidden from him; that he has touched them; or the uncleanness contracted by touching, he having inadvertently done it; or being ignorant of the law concerning such uncleanness:
he also shall be unclean; in a ceremonial sense, by thus touching them:
and guilty; of a breach of the command which forbids the touching of them: this is by way of prolepsis or anticipation; for as yet the law concerning unclean beasts, and creeping things, and pollution by touching them, was not given: Jarchi and Gersom interpret this guilt, of eating of holy things, and going into the sanctuary when thus defiled: in the Jewish Misnah w it is said, the word "hidden" is twice used, to show that he is guilty, for the ignorance of uncleanness, and for the ignorance of the sanctuary.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Lev 5:1 Heb “and he shall bear his iniquity.” The rendering “bear the punishment (for the iniquity)” reflects the use of the word R...

NET Notes: Lev 5:2 Lev 5:2-3 are parallel laws of uncleanness (contracted from animals and people, respectively), and both seem to assume that the contraction of unclean...
Geneva Bible -> Lev 5:1
Geneva Bible: Lev 5:1 And if a soul sin, and hear the voice of swearing, and [is] a witness, whether he hath seen or ( a ) known [of it]; if he do not utter [it], then he s...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Lev 5:1-19
TSK Synopsis: Lev 5:1-19 - --1 He that sins in concealing his knowledge;2 in touching an unclean thing;4 or in making an oath.6 His trespass offering, of the flock;7 of fowls;11 o...
MHCC -> Lev 5:1-13
MHCC: Lev 5:1-13 - --The offences here noticed are, 1. A man's concealing the truth, when he was sworn as a witness to speak the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but th...
Matthew Henry -> Lev 5:1-6
Matthew Henry: Lev 5:1-6 - -- I. The offences here supposed are, 1. A man's concealing the truth when he was sworn as a witness to speak the truth, the whole truth, and nothing b...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Lev 5:1-13
Keil-Delitzsch: Lev 5:1-13 - --
There follow here three special examples of sin on the part of the common Israelite, all sins of omission and rashness of a lighter kind than the ca...
Constable: Lev 1:1--16:34 - --I. The public worship of the Israelites chs. 1--16
Leviticus continues revelation concerning the second of three...

Constable: Lev 1:1--7:38 - --A. The laws of sacrifice chs. 1-7
God designed the offerings to teach the Israelites as well as to enabl...




