
Text -- Nehemiah 8:16-18 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Neh 8:17
Wesley: Neh 8:17 - -- So, as to the manner and circumstances. They never kept this feast so joyfully, having not only the same causes of rejoicing which they formerly had, ...
So, as to the manner and circumstances. They never kept this feast so joyfully, having not only the same causes of rejoicing which they formerly had, but special causes to increase their joy; they never kept it so solemnly and religiously: for whereas at other times, only the first and last day of that feast were celebrated with an holy convocation, now there was an holy convocation, and the people assembled, and attended upon the reading of the law, every day of this feast.

JFB: Neh 8:17 - -- This national feast had not been neglected for so protracted a period. Besides that it is impossible that such a flagrant disregard of the law could h...
This national feast had not been neglected for so protracted a period. Besides that it is impossible that such a flagrant disregard of the law could have been tolerated by Samuel, David, and other pious rulers, its observance is sufficiently indicated (1Ki 8:2, 1Ki 8:65; 2Ch 7:9) and expressly recorded (Ezr 3:4). But the meaning is, that the popular feelings had never been raised to such a height of enthusiastic joy since the time of their entrance into Canaan, as now on their return after a long and painful captivity.

JFB: Neh 8:18 - -- This was more than was enjoined (Deu 31:10-12), and arose from the exuberant zeal of the time.
This was more than was enjoined (Deu 31:10-12), and arose from the exuberant zeal of the time.

JFB: Neh 8:18 - -- This was the last and great day of the feast (see on Num 29:35). In later times, other ceremonies which increased the rejoicing were added (Joh 7:37).
Clarke: Neh 8:16 - -- Upon the roof of his house - It need scarcely be repeated, that the houses in the East are generally built with flat roofs. On these they reposed; o...
Upon the roof of his house - It need scarcely be repeated, that the houses in the East are generally built with flat roofs. On these they reposed; on these they took the air in the heats of summer; and on these they oftentimes slept.

Clarke: Neh 8:17 - -- Since the days of Joshua - No feast of tabernacles since Joshua’ s time had been so heartily and so piously celebrated. The story of the sacred...
Since the days of Joshua - No feast of tabernacles since Joshua’ s time had been so heartily and so piously celebrated. The story of the sacred fire now discovered, which had been hidden by the order of Jeremiah in a dry well, and now, some of the mud from the bottom being brought upon the altar, was kindled afresh by the rays of the sun, which suddenly broke out, though before covered with clouds, etc., is worthy of no credit. Those who wish to see the detail may consult 2 Maccabees 1:18-36
On the subject in Neh 8:8, I beg leave to make a few observations: - So they read in the book in the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to understand the reading. The Israelites, having been lately brought out of the Babylonish captivity, in which they had continued seventy years, according to the prediction of Jeremiah, Jer 25:11, were not only extremely corrupt, but it appears that they had in general lost the knowledge of the ancient Hebrew to such a degree, that when the book of the law was read, they did not understand it: but certain Levites stood by, and gave the sense, i. e., translated into the Chaldee dialect. This was not only the origin of the Chaldee Targums, or translation of the law and prophets into that tongue but was also, in all probability, the origin of preaching from a text; for it appears that the people were not only ignorant of their ancient language, but also of the rites and ceremonies of their religion, having been so long in Babylon, where they were not permitted to observe them. This being the case, not only the language must be interpreted, but the meaning of the rites and ceremonies must also be explained; for we find from Neh 8:13, etc., of this chapter, that they had even forgotten the feast of tabernacles, and every thing relative to that ceremony
As we nowhere find that what is called preaching on or expounding a text was ever in use before that period, we are probably beholden to the Babylonish captivity for producing, in the hand of Divine Providence, a custom the most excellent and beneficial ever introduced among men
What the nature of preaching or expounding the word of God was, at this early period of its institution, we learn from the above cited text
I. They read in the book of the law of God. - The words of God, the doctrines of Divine revelation, are the proper matter of preaching; for they contain the wisdom of the Most High, and teach man the things which belong to his peace and happiness
II. They read distinctly -
III. They gave the sense -
IV. They caused them to understand the reading -
This was the ancient method of expounding the word of God among the Jews; and this mode is still more necessary for Us: -
1. Because the sacred writings, as they came from God, are shut up in languages no longer vernacular; and no translation ever did or ever can reach the force of the original words, though perhaps our own in general, comes nearest to this of all versions, whether ancient or modern
2. Ninety-nine out of a hundred know nothing of these languages; and consequently cannot, of themselves, reap all the requisite benefit from reading the Scriptures
3. Sacred things are illustrated in the Bible by a reference to arts and sciences, of which the mass of the people are as ignorant as they are of the original tongues
4. Provincial customs and fashions are mentioned in these writings, which must be understood, or the force and meaning of many texts cannot be comprehended
5. There is a depth in the word of God which cannot be fathomed except either by Divine inspiration, or by deep study and research, for which the majority of the people have no time
6. The people in general trust to the piety, learning and abilities of their ministers, and maintain them as persons capable of instructing them in all the deep things of God; and believing them to be holy men, they are confident they will not take their tithes, their food, and their raiment, under a pretense of doing a work for which they have not the ordinary qualifications. Where there is not such preaching as this, the people "sit in darkness, and in the valley of the shadow of death;"sinners are not converted unto God; neither are believers "built up on their most holy faith.
Reader - Art thou a Christian minister? Dost thou feed the flock of God? Let thy conduct, thy conscience, and the fruits of thy ministry answer for thee.
Defender -> Neh 8:17
Defender: Neh 8:17 - -- Although the children of Israel had occasionally observed the feasts of the Lord, as commanded in Leviticus 23, the observances had generally been per...
Although the children of Israel had occasionally observed the feasts of the Lord, as commanded in Leviticus 23, the observances had generally been perfunctory and often ignored altogether. The feast of tabernacles had actually been observed by the captives who returned to Jerusalem with Zerubbabel and Jeshua (Ezr 3:4), but it was not like this, with all the people of Israel dwelling in their own hand-made "booths," with great gladness everywhere."
TSK: Neh 8:16 - -- the roof : Deu 22:8; 2Sa 11:2; Jer 19:13, Jer 32:29
the courts : 2Ch 20:5, 2Ch 33:5
the street of the water gate : Neh 8:3, Neh 3:26, Neh 12:37
gate o...

TSK: Neh 8:17 - -- sat under : Joh 1:14; Heb 11:9, Heb 11:13
Jeshua : Jos 1:1, Joshua, Heb 4:8, Jesus
had not : 2Ch 7:8-10, 2Ch 8:13; Ezr 3:4
done so : 2Ch 30:26, 2Ch 35...

TSK: Neh 8:18 - -- day by day : Deu 31:10-13
a solemn assembly : Heb. a restraint
according : Lev 23:36; Num 29:35; Joh 7:37
day by day : Deu 31:10-13
a solemn assembly : Heb. a restraint

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Neh 8:17
Barnes: Neh 8:17 - -- It is not the intention of the writer to state that the Feast of tabernacles had not been kept from the time of Joshua until this occasion (see 1Ki ...
Poole: Neh 8:16 - -- Booths upon the roof of his house for the houses there were made flat; of which See Poole "Deu 22:8" .
In their courts belonging to their own hous...
Booths upon the roof of his house for the houses there were made flat; of which See Poole "Deu 22:8" .
In their courts belonging to their own houses; for these might be any where in the open air.
In the street of the gate of Ephraim that gate of the city which led to the tribe of Ephraim.

Poole: Neh 8:17 - -- For since the days of Jeshua or, surely since the days, as the Hebrew chi is oft used, as hath been noted before. For the following words seem no...
For since the days of Jeshua or, surely since the days, as the Hebrew chi is oft used, as hath been noted before. For the following words seem not so much to give a reason of what was last said or done concerning their dwelling in booths, as to contain the holy writer’ s reflection upon the present celebration of this feast.
Had not the children of Israel done so either,
1. So as to the matter or substance of the thing. So it implies that all this while the feast of tabernacles was not observed; which seems altogether improbable, considering how expressly this was commanded to be celebrated, Le 23 , &c, and what excellent kings, and priests, and prophets there had been within that time, such as were persons of great understanding, and most expert and studious in God’ s word, and therefore could not be ignorant of so plain a duty; and withal so thoroughly pious, and careful, and zealous for God, and the observation of his law and worship, and some of them commended for their universal obedience to all God’ s commands; and therefore would not be guilty of so gross a neglect. Besides, that this feast was observed is sufficiently implied in 1Ki 8:2,65 2Ch 7:9 , and is particularly expressed Ezr 3:4 . Or rather,
2. So , as to the manner and circumstances. They never kept this feast so joyfully, as the next words declare, having not only the same causes of rejoicing which they formerly had, but some special causes to increase their joy, to wit, the remembrance of their stupendous deliverance, both out of the land of their captivity, and out of the hands of their wicked and malicious neighbours ever since their return, and especially now when they were new building the walls of Jerusalem: they never kept it so solemnly and religiously; for whereas at other times only the first and last day of that feast were celebrated with a holy convocation, Lev 23:35,36 Joh 7:37 , now there was a holy convocation, and the people assembled, and attended upon the reading of the law, every day of this feast, as is noted in the next verse.

Poole: Neh 8:18 - -- He read in the book of the law of God which was commanded to be done at this feast, Deu 31:10-12 , though not enjoined to be done every day, as now o...
He read in the book of the law of God which was commanded to be done at this feast, Deu 31:10-12 , though not enjoined to be done every day, as now out of a singular zeal they did.
Haydock: Neh 8:16 - -- House, which was flat. (Haydock) ---
The tents might be erected in any place; in the open air. (Tirinus)
House, which was flat. (Haydock) ---
The tents might be erected in any place; in the open air. (Tirinus)

Haydock: Neh 8:17 - -- Done so, with such alacrity, though they had displayed more magnificence. See the meaning of similar expressions, 4 Kings xxiii. 22. (Calmet)
Done so, with such alacrity, though they had displayed more magnificence. See the meaning of similar expressions, 4 Kings xxiii. 22. (Calmet)

Haydock: Neh 8:18 - -- Assembly. Literally, "the collect." (Haydock) ---
Hebrew, "the day of retention;" the people being kept at the temple. (Calmet) ---
Septuagint, ...
Assembly. Literally, "the collect." (Haydock) ---
Hebrew, "the day of retention;" the people being kept at the temple. (Calmet) ---
Septuagint, "the dismission;" as they were afterwards permitted to depart. (Haydock) ---
See Leviticus xxiii. 26. ---
It was probably on this occasion, that the sacred fire was found again; (2 Machabees i. 18.; Calmet) and also the ark, the tabernacle, and the altar of incense, which had been hidden by Jeremias, 2 Machabees ii. 4. (Torniel, the year of the world 3610.) (Cano, &c.) ---
But this is not so certain. (Haydock) (Calmet, Diss.)
Gill: Neh 8:16 - -- So the people went forth, and brought them,.... Went out of Jerusalem to the mountains adjacent, and fetched in branches of the said trees, one or ano...
So the people went forth, and brought them,.... Went out of Jerusalem to the mountains adjacent, and fetched in branches of the said trees, one or another:
and made themselves booths, everyone upon the roof of his house; which were flat, Deu 22:8, and they might be made anywhere, so be it they were open to the air:
and in their courts, and in the courts of the house of God; the common people in the courtyards belonging to their houses, and the priests and Levites in the courts of the temple, the yards or open places adjoining to them:
and in the street of the watergate; which led to that, and seems to have been a very large street, in which many booths might be built, Neh 3:26
and in the street of the gate of Ephraim; which led to the gate through which the road lay to the tribe of Ephraim, see 2Ki 14:13, none were erected without the walls of the city, for fear of the enemy.

Gill: Neh 8:17 - -- And all the congregation of them that were come again out of captivity made booths,.... These came to Jerusalem, and made them booths there; for there...
And all the congregation of them that were come again out of captivity made booths,.... These came to Jerusalem, and made them booths there; for there only was this feast kept, see Joh 7:2,
and sat under the booths; there they dwelt during the seven days of it, in commemoration of their ancestors dwelling in booths in the wilderness, see Lev 23:42
for since the days of Jeshua the son of Nun unto that day had not the children of Israel done so; Joshua observed it, when be had brought and settled the people of Israel in the land of Canaan; and it had been observed since, before this time, as appears from 1Ki 8:2 Ezr 3:4; but not so, with such exactness, with such zeal and affection, with such a regard to the law of God, as to read it every day of the feast, as in the next verse, and with such joy and gladness; wherefore there is no reason to suspect a corruption in the text, as a learned man w does, who supposes that Joshua is put for Josiah:
and there was very great gladness; that they were restored unto and settled in their land, had the book of the law, and the knowledge of it, and were directed and enabled to observe it.

Gill: Neh 8:18 - -- Also day by day, from the first day unto the last day, he read in the book of the law of God,.... That is, Ezra; this was done by him every day during...
Also day by day, from the first day unto the last day, he read in the book of the law of God,.... That is, Ezra; this was done by him every day during the feast, whereas only the first and last days were the holy convocations on which it seems to have been read:
and they kept the feast seven days, and on the eighth day was a solemn assembly, according to the manner; prescribed in Lev 23:39.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes


Geneva Bible: Neh 8:16 So the people went forth, and brought [them], and made themselves booths, every one upon the ( h ) roof of his house, and in their courts, and in the ...

Geneva Bible: Neh 8:17 And all the congregation of them that were come again out of the captivity made booths, and sat under the booths: for since the ( i ) days of Jeshua t...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Neh 8:1-18
TSK Synopsis: Neh 8:1-18 - --1 The religious manner of reading and hearing the law.9 They comfort the people.13 The forwardness of them to hear and be instructed.16 They keep the ...
MHCC -> Neh 8:13-18
MHCC: Neh 8:13-18 - --They found written in the law about the feast of tabernacles. Those who diligently search the Scriptures, find things written there which they have fo...
Matthew Henry -> Neh 8:13-18
Matthew Henry: Neh 8:13-18 - -- We have here, I. The people's renewed attendance upon the word. They had spent the greatest part of one day in praying and hearing, and yet were so ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Neh 8:13-18
Keil-Delitzsch: Neh 8:13-18 - --
Celebration of the feast of tabernacles . - Neh 8:13 On the second day weregathered together the heads of the houses of all the people, of the prie...
Constable: Neh 7:1--10:39 - --A. The Renewal of the Mosaic Covenant chs. 8-10
"The reading of Scripture (Neh 8) and the act of prayer ...

Constable: Neh 7:73--13:31 - --II. THE RESTORATION OF THE JEWS chs. 8--13
One writer viewed chapters 8-13 (really 7:73-13:37) as the third part...
