
Text -- Acts 15:37-41 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Robertson: Act 15:37 - -- Was minded to take with them ( ebouleto sunparalabein ).
Imperfect middle (ebouleto ), not aorist middle ebouleusato of the Textus Receptus. Barna...
Was minded to take with them (
Imperfect middle (

Robertson: Act 15:38 - -- But Paul thought not good to take with them ( Paulos de ēxiou̇̇mē sunparalambanein touton ).
The Greek is far more effective than this English ...
But Paul thought not good to take with them (
The Greek is far more effective than this English rendering. It is the imperfect active of

Robertson: Act 15:39 - -- A sharp contention ( paroxusmos ).
Our very word paroxysm in English. Old word though only twice in the N.T. (here and Heb 10:24), from paroxunō , ...
A sharp contention (
Our very word paroxysm in English. Old word though only twice in the N.T. (here and Heb 10:24), from

Robertson: Act 15:39 - -- So that they parted asunder from one another ( hōste apochōristhēnai autous ap' allēlōn ).
Actual result here stated by hōste and the f...
So that they parted asunder from one another (
Actual result here stated by

Robertson: Act 15:39 - -- And Barnabas took Mark with him and sailed away to Cyprus ( ton te Barnaban paralabonta ton Markon ekpleusai eis Kupron ).
Second infinitival clause ...
And Barnabas took Mark with him and sailed away to Cyprus (
Second infinitival clause

Robertson: Act 15:40 - -- Chose ( epilexamenos ).
First aorist middle (indirect) participle of epilegō , choosing for himself, as the successor of Barnabas, not of Mark who ...
Chose (
First aorist middle (indirect) participle of

Robertson: Act 15:40 - -- Commended ( paradotheis ).
First aorist passive of paradidōmi , the same verb employed about Paul and Barnabas (Act 14:26) on their return from the...
Commended (
First aorist passive of

Robertson: Act 15:41 - -- @@Went through (diērcheto ). Imperfect middle. So Paul went forth on his second mission tour with heart-aches and high hopes mingled together. Syri...
@@Went through (
Vincent: Act 15:38 - -- Him ( τοῦτον )
Lit., that one. It marks him very strongly, and is an emphatic position at the end of the sentence.
Him (
Lit., that one. It marks him very strongly, and is an emphatic position at the end of the sentence.

Vincent: Act 15:38 - -- Departed ( ἀποστάντα )
Rev., withdrew. It furnishes the derivation of our word apostatize.
Departed (
Rev., withdrew. It furnishes the derivation of our word apostatize.

Vincent: Act 15:39 - -- The contention was so sharp ( ἐγένετο παροξυσμὸς )
More correctly, there arose a sharp contention. Only here and Heb 10:...
The contention was so sharp (
More correctly, there arose a sharp contention. Only here and Heb 10:24. Our word paroxysm is a transcription of

Barnabas
The last mention of him in the Acts.

Vincent: Act 15:40 - -- Recommended
Which was not the case with Barnabas, leading to the inference that the church at Antioch took Paul's side in the dispute.
Recommended
Which was not the case with Barnabas, leading to the inference that the church at Antioch took Paul's side in the dispute.
His kinsman.

Wesley: Act 15:38 - -- To trust him again, who had deserted them before: who had shrunk from the labour and danger of converting those they were now going to confirm.
To trust him again, who had deserted them before: who had shrunk from the labour and danger of converting those they were now going to confirm.

Wesley: Act 15:39 - -- Literally, a paroxysm, or fit of a fever. But nothing in the text implies that the sharpness was on both sides. It is far more probable that it was no...
Literally, a paroxysm, or fit of a fever. But nothing in the text implies that the sharpness was on both sides. It is far more probable that it was not; that St. Paul, who had the right on his side, as he undoubtedly had,) maintained it with love. And Barnabas taking Mark with him, sailed away to Cyprus - Forsaking the work in which he was engaged, he went away to his own country.

Wesley: Act 15:40 - -- Held on his intended course: being recommended by the brethren to the grace of God - We do not find that Barnabas stayed for this. O how mighty is the...
Held on his intended course: being recommended by the brethren to the grace of God - We do not find that Barnabas stayed for this. O how mighty is the grace of God! which in the midst of the world, in the midst of sin, among so many snares of Satan, and in spite of the incredible weakness and depravity of nature, yet overcomes all opposition, sanctifies, sustains, and preserves us to the end! It appears not only that Paul and Barnabas were afterward thoroughly reconciled, 1Co 9:6; Gal 2:9; but also that John was again admitted by St. Paul as a companion in his labours, Col 4:10; Phm 1:24; 2Ti 4:11.

JFB: Act 15:38 - -- That is, who had departed; but the word is stronger than this--"who stood aloof" or "turned away" from them.
That is, who had departed; but the word is stronger than this--"who stood aloof" or "turned away" from them.

JFB: Act 15:38 - -- The work yet before them. The allusion is to what is recorded in Act 13:13 (see on Act 13:13).

Such was the "irritation," or "exacerbation."

JFB: Act 15:39 - -- Said they not truly to the Lystrians that they were "men of like passions with them"; (Act 14:15). But who was to blame? (1) That John Mark had either...
Said they not truly to the Lystrians that they were "men of like passions with them"; (Act 14:15). But who was to blame? (1) That John Mark had either tired of the work or shrunk from the dangers and fatigues that yet lay before them, was undeniable; and Paul concluded that what he had done he might, and probably would, do again. Was he wrong in this? (See Pro 25:19). But (2) To this Barnabas might reply that no rule was without exception; that one failure, in a young Christian, was not enough to condemn him for life; that if near relationship might be thought to warp his judgment, it also gave him opportunities of knowing the man better than others; and that as he was himself anxious to be allowed another trial (and the result makes this next to certain), in order that he might wipe out the effect of his former failure and show what "hardness he could now endure as a good soldier of Jesus Christ," his petition ought not to be rejected. Now, since John Mark did retrieve his character in these respects, and a reconciliation took place between Paul and him, so cordial that the apostle expresses more than once the confidence he had in him and the value he set upon his services (Col 4:10-11; 2Ti 4:11), it may seem that events showed Barnabas to be in the right, and Paul too harsh and hasty in his judgment. But, in behalf of Paul, it may well be answered, that not being able to see into the future he had only the unfavorable past to judge by; that the gentleness of Barnabas (Act 4:36; Act 11:24) had already laid him open to imposition (see on Gal 2:13), to which near relationship would in this case make him more liable; and that in refusing to take John Mark on this missionary journey he was not judging his Christian character nor pronouncing on his fitness for future service, but merely providing in the meantime against being again put to serious inconvenience and having their hands weakened by a possible second desertion. On the whole, then, it seems clear that each of these great servants of--Christ had something to say for himself, in defense of the position which they respectively took up; that while Barnabas was quite able to appreciate the grounds on which Paul proceeded, Paul was not so competent to judge of the considerations which Barnabas probably urged; that while Paul had but one object in view, to see that the companion of their arduous work was one of thoroughly congenial spirit and sufficient nerve, Barnabas, over and above the same desire, might not unreasonably be afraid for the soul of his nephew, lest the refusal to allow him to accompany them on their journey might injure his Christian character and deprive the Church of a true servant of Jesus Christ; and that while both sought only the glory of their common Master, each looked at the question at issue, to some extent, through the medium of his own temperament, which grace sanctifies and refines, but does not destroy--Paul, through the medium of absolute devotion to the cause and kingdom of Christ, which, warm and womanly as his affections were, gave a tinge of lofty sternness to his resolves where that seemed to be affected; Barnabas, through the medium of the same singleness of heart in Christ's service, though probably not in equal strength (Gal 2:13), but also of a certain natural gentleness which, where a Christian relative was concerned, led him to attach more weight to what seemed for his spiritual good than Paul could be supposed to do. In these circumstances, it seems quite possible that they might have amicably "agreed to differ," each taking his own companion, as they actually did. But the "paroxysm" (as the word is), the "exacerbation" which is expressly given as the cause of their parting, shows but too plainly, that human infirmity amidst the great labors of the Church at Antioch at length sundered those who had sweetly and lovingly borne together the heat and burden of the day during a protracted tour in the service of Christ. "Therefore let no man glory in men" (1Co 3:21). As for John Mark, although through his uncle's warm advocacy of his cause he was put in a condition to dissipate the cloud that hung over him, how bitter to him must have ever afterwards been the reflection that it was his culpable conduct which gave occasion to whatever was sinful in the strife between Paul and Barnabas, and to a separation in action, though no doubt with a mutual Christian regard, between those who had till then wrought nobly together! How watchful does all this teach Christians, and especially Christian ministers and missionaries, to be against giving way to rash judgment and hot temper towards each other, especially where on both sides the glory of Christ is the ground of difference! How possible is it that in such cases both parties may, on the question at issue, be more or less in the right! How difficult is it even for the most faithful and devoted servants of Christ, differing as they do in their natural temperament even under the commanding influence of grace, to see even important questions precisely in the same light! And if, with every disposition to yield what is unimportant, they still feel it a duty each to stand to his own point, how careful should they be to do it lovingly, each pursuing his own course without disparagement of his Christian brother! And how affectingly does the Lord overrule such difference of judgment and such manifestations of human infirmity, by making them "turn out rather unto the furtherance of the Gospel"; as in this case is eminently seen in the two missionary parties instead of one, not travelling over the same ground and carrying their dispute over all the regions of their former loving labors, but dividing the field between them!

JFB: Act 15:39 - -- (See on Act 15:34) --going two and two, as the Twelve and the Seventy (Mar 6:7; Luk 10:1).

JFB: Act 15:40 - -- (No doubt by some solemn service; see Act 13:3), as in Act 14:26. It does not follow from the historian's silence that Barnabas was not so recommended...
(No doubt by some solemn service; see Act 13:3), as in Act 14:26. It does not follow from the historian's silence that Barnabas was not so recommended, too; for this is the last mention of Barnabas in the history, whose sole object now is to relate the proceedings of Paul. Nor does it seem quite fair (with DE WETTE, MEYER, HOWSON, ALFORD, HACKET, WEBSTER and WILKINSON, &c.) to conclude from this that the Church at Antioch took that marked way of showing their sympathy with Paul in opposition to Barnabas.

JFB: Act 15:41 - -- "It is very likely that Paul and Barnabas made a deliberate and amicable arrangement to divide the region of their first mission between them; Paul ta...
"It is very likely that Paul and Barnabas made a deliberate and amicable arrangement to divide the region of their first mission between them; Paul taking the continental, and Barnabas the insular, part of the proposed visitation. If Barnabas visited Salamis and Paphos, and if Paul (travelling westward), after passing through Derbe, Lystra, and Iconium, went as far as Antioch in Pisidia, the whole circuit of the proposed visitation was actually accomplished, for it does not appear that any converts had been made at Perga and Attalia" [HOWSON]. "This second missionary tour appears to have proceeded at first solely from the desire of visiting the churches already planted. In the end, however, it took a much wider sweep, for it brought the apostle to Europe" [OLSHAUSEN].
PAUL'S SECOND MISSIONARY JOURNEY.

JFB: Act 15:41 - -- (See on Act 15:23). Taking probably the same route as when despatched in haste from Jerusalem to Tarsus, he then went by land (see on Act 9:30).
Clarke: Act 15:37 - -- Barnabas determined to take with them John - John Mark was his sister’ s son; and natural affection might have led him to the partiality here m...
Barnabas determined to take with them John - John Mark was his sister’ s son; and natural affection might have led him to the partiality here mentioned.

Clarke: Act 15:38 - -- But Paul thought not good to take him with them - On this subject, see the note on Act 13:13.
But Paul thought not good to take him with them - On this subject, see the note on Act 13:13.

Clarke: Act 15:39 - -- The contention was so sharp between them - For all this sentence, there is only in the Greek text εγενετο ουν παροξυσμος ; ther...
The contention was so sharp between them - For all this sentence, there is only in the Greek text

Clarke: Act 15:40 - -- Being recommended - unto the grace of God - Much stress has been laid upon this, to show that Barnabas was in the wrong, and Paul in the right, beca...
Being recommended - unto the grace of God - Much stress has been laid upon this, to show that Barnabas was in the wrong, and Paul in the right, because "the brethren recommended Paul and Silas to the grace of God; but they did not recommend Barnabas and John Mark: this proves that the Church condemned the conduct of Barnabas, but approved that of Paul."Now, there is no proof that the Church did not recommend Barnabas to the grace of God, as well as Paul; but, as St. Luke had for the present dropped the story of Barnabas, and was now going on with that of Paul and Silas, he begins it at this point, viz. his being recommended by the brethren to the grace of God; and then goes on to tell of his progress in Syria, Derbe, Lystra, etc., etc. See the next chapter. And with this verse should the following chapter begin; and this is the division followed by the most correct copies of the Greek text.

Clarke: Act 15:41 - -- Confirming the Churches - This was the object of his journey: they were young converts, and had need of establishment; and there is no doubt that, b...
Confirming the Churches - This was the object of his journey: they were young converts, and had need of establishment; and there is no doubt that, by showing them the decision made at the late council of Jerusalem, their faith was greatly strengthened, their hope confirmed, and their love increased. It was this consideration, no doubt, that led some ancient MSS. and some versions to add here, They delivered them the decrees of the apostles and elders to keep; which clause certainly was not an original part of the text, but seems to have been borrowed from the fourth verse of the following chapter. Some have thought that the fourth and fifth verses of the next chapter really belong to this place; or that the first, second, and third verses of it should be read in a parenthesis; but of this there does not appear to be any particular necessity
Calvin -> Act 15:37
Calvin: Act 15:37 - -- 37.And Barnabas gave counsel Luke doth here set down that doleful disagreement which ought to make all the godly afraid for just causes. The society ...
37.And Barnabas gave counsel Luke doth here set down that doleful disagreement which ought to make all the godly afraid for just causes. The society of Paul and Barnabas was consecrated by the heavenly oracle. They had long time labored, being of one mind, under this yoke whereunto the Lord had tied them; they had, by many experiences, tried [felt] the excellent favor of God, yea, that wonderful success mentioned heretofore by Luke was a manifest blessing of God. Though they had been almost drowned so often in so many tempests of persecution, and were set upon so sore − 165 by infinite enemies, though domestical sedition were everywhere kindled against them, yet they were so far from being pulled in sunder, that their agreement was then most of all tried, [proved.] But now, for a light matter, and which might easily have been ended, they break that holy bond of God’s calling. −
This could not fall out without great perturbance to all the godly. Seeing that the heat of the contention was so great and vehement in these holy men, who had long time accustomed themselves to suffer all things, what shall befall us, whose affections being not as yet so brought to obey God, do oftentimes rage − 166 without modesty? Seeing that a light occasion did separate them, who had long time, amidst so great trials, retained unity holily, how easily may Satan cause those to be divided who have either none, or, at least, a cold desire to foster peace? What great pride was it for Barnabas, who had no more honorable thing than to be Paul’s companion, that he might behave himself like a son towards his father, so stubbornly to refuse his counsel? Peradventure, also, some might think that Paul was not very courteous in that he did not forgive a faithful helper this fault. Therefore, we be admonished by this example, that unless the servants of Christ take great heed, there be many chinks through which Satan will creep in, to disturb that concord which is among them. −
But now we must examine the cause itself, for some there be who lay the blame of the disagreement upon Paul; − 167 and, at the first hearing, the reasons which they bring seem probable. John Mark is rejected, because he withdrew himself from Paul’s company; but he fell not away from Christ. A young man, being as yet unacquainted with bearing the cross, returned home from his journey. He was somewhat to be borne with for his age, being a fresh-water soldier [a tyro] he fainted in troubles even at the first dash; he was not, therefore, about to be a slothful soldier during his whole life. Now, forasmuch as his returning to Paul is an excellent testimony of repentance, it seemeth to be a point of discourtesy − 168 to reject him; for those must be handled more courteously, who punish themselves for their own offenses of their own accord. There were also other causes which ought to have made Paul more courteous. The house of John Mark was a famous inn, − 169 ( Act 12:12;) his mother had entertained the faithful in most grievous persecution; when Herod and all the people were in a rage, they were wont to have their secret meetings there, as Luke reported before. Surely he ought to have borne with such a holy and courageous woman, lest immoderate rigor should alienate her. She was desirous to have her son addicted to preach the gospel; now, what a great grief might it have been to her that his pains and industry should be refused − 170 for one light fault? And now whereas John Mark doth not only bewail his fault, but in very deed amend the same, Barnabas hath a fair color why he should pardon him. − 171 −
Yet we may gather out of the text, that the Church did allow Paul’s counsel. For Barnabas departeth, and with his companion he saileth into Cyprus. There is no mention made of the brethren, (as if he had departed privily without taking his leave;) but the brethren commend Paul in their prayers to the grace of God; whereby appeareth that the Church stood on his side. Secondly, whereas God showeth forth the power of his Spirit in blessing Paul, and doth bless his labors with happy success of his grace, and leaveth Barnabas, as it were, buried, there may a probable reason be drawn thence, that it pleased him that such an example of severity should be showed. And surely the offense of John Mark was greater than it is commonly taken for. He slid not back, indeed, from the faith of Christ, yet did he forsake his calling, and was a revolt [apostate] from the same; therefore, it was a matter which might have given evil example, if he had been straightway received again into the calling from which he was slid back. He had given himself over to serve Christ upon this condition, that he should be free no longer. It was no more lawful for him to break his promise made in this behalf, than it is for a husband to leave his wife, or for a son to forsake his father. Neither doth infirmity excuse his unfaithfulness, whereby the holiness of the calling was violated. −
And we must note, that he was not altogether rejected of Paul; he counted him as a brother, so he would be content with the common order; he refused to admit him unto the common [public] function of teaching, from whence he fell filthily through his own fault. And there is no great difference between these two, whether he which hath offended be quite excluded from pardon, or he have only public honor denied him; though it may be that they did both exceed measure, as accidents do oftentimes mar a matter which is otherwise good. It was well done of Paul, and according to the right of discipline profitably, not to admit him to be his companion, whose inconstancy he had once tried, [experienced;] but when he saw Barnabas so importunate, he might have yielded to his desire. We ought to make more account of the truth than of the favor of all the whole world; but it is convenient that we ponder wisely what great weight there is in the matter which is in hand. For if, in a matter of no weight or edification, a man vaunt of his constancy, prepare himself for the conflict, and cease not to defend that until the end, wherein he did once take delight it shall be but foolish and perverse obstinacy. There was also some middle way and means whereby Paul might have granted somewhat to the importunateness of his fellow [colleague] in office, and yet have not revolted from the truth. It was not for him to flatter Mark, or to cloak his offense, yet was he not letted by religion, but that after he had freely professed what he thought, he might suffer himself to be overcome in that matter, which did neither indamage true doctrine, nor endanger man’s salvation; which I say for this cause, that we may learn to moderate our desire, even in the best causes, lest it pass measure, and be too fervent.
Defender -> Act 15:39
Defender: Act 15:39 - -- Even though this contention seemed unfortunate, God used it for good. Now there were two missionary teams instead of one. Similar happenings still occ...
Even though this contention seemed unfortunate, God used it for good. Now there were two missionary teams instead of one. Similar happenings still occur today. The ministry of Paul and Silas was extraordinarily fruitful, and Mark was reclaimed spiritually and was even used to write one of the four gospels (2Ti 4:11)."


TSK: Act 15:39 - -- the contention : Act 15:2, Act 6:1; Psa 106:33, Psa 119:96; Ecc 7:20; Rom 7:18-21; Jam 3:2
and sailed : Act 4:36, Act 11:20, Act 13:4-12, Act 27:4
the contention : Act 15:2, Act 6:1; Psa 106:33, Psa 119:96; Ecc 7:20; Rom 7:18-21; Jam 3:2
and sailed : Act 4:36, Act 11:20, Act 13:4-12, Act 27:4

TSK: Act 15:40 - -- chose : Act 15:22, Act 15:32, Act 16:1-3
being : Act 13:3, Act 14:26, Act 20:32; 1Co 15:10; 2Co 13:14; 2Ti 4:22; Tit 3:15; 2Jo 1:10,2Jo 1:11

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Act 15:37 - -- And Barnabas determined - Greek: willed, or was disposed to ( ἐβουλεύσαντο ebouleusanto ). John ... - See the notes o...
And Barnabas determined - Greek: willed, or was disposed to (
John ... - See the notes on Act 12:12. He had been with them before as a traveling companion, Act 12:25; Act 13:5. He was the son of a sister of Barnabas Col 4:10, and it is probable that Barnabas’ affection for his nephew was the main reason for inducing him to wish to take him with him in the journey.

Barnes: Act 15:38 - -- But Paul thought not good - Did not think it proper. Because he could not confide in his perseverance with them in the toils and perils of thei...
But Paul thought not good - Did not think it proper. Because he could not confide in his perseverance with them in the toils and perils of their journey.
Who departed from them ... - Act 13:13. Why he did this is not known. It was evidently, however, for some cause which Paul did not consider satisfactory, and which, in his view, disqualified him from being their attendant again.
To the work - Of preaching the gospel.

Barnes: Act 15:39 - -- And the contention was so sharp - The word used here παροξυσμός paroxusmos is that from which our word "paroxysm"is derived. ...
And the contention was so sharp - The word used here
And sailed into Cyprus - This was the native place of Barnabas. See the notes on Act 4:36.

Barnes: Act 15:40 - -- Being recommended - Being commended by prayer to God. See notes on Act 14:26.
Being recommended - Being commended by prayer to God. See notes on Act 14:26.

Barnes: Act 15:41 - -- Syria and Cilicia - These were countries lying near to each other, which Paul, in company with Barnabas, had before visited. Confirming th...
Syria and Cilicia - These were countries lying near to each other, which Paul, in company with Barnabas, had before visited.
Confirming the churches - Strengthening them by instruction and exhortation. It has no reference to the rite of confirmation. See the notes on Act 14:22.
In regard to this unhappy contention between Paul and Barnabas, and their separation from each other, we may make the following remarks:
(1) That no apology or vindication of it is offered by the sacred writer. It was undoubtedly improper and evil. It was a melancholy instance in which even apostles evinced an improper spirit, and engaged in improper strife.
\caps1 (2) i\caps0 n this contention it is probable that Paul was, in the main, right. Barnabas seems to have been influenced by attachment to a relative; Paul sought a helper who would not shrink from duty and danger. It is clear that Paul had the sympathies and prayers of the church in his favor Act 15:40, and it is more than probable that Barnabas departed without any such sympathy, Act 15:39.
\caps1 (3) t\caps0 here is reason to think that this contention was overruled for the furtherance of the gospel. They went to different places, and preached to different people. It often happens that the unhappy and wicked strifes of Christians are the means of exciting their mutual zeal, and of extending the gospel, and of establishing churches. But no thanks to their contention; nor is the guilt of their anger and strife mitigated by this.
\caps1 (4) t\caps0 his difference was afterward reconciled, and Paul and Barnabas again became traveling companions, 1Co 9:6; Gal 2:9.
\caps1 (5) t\caps0 here is evidence that Paul also became reconciled to John Mark, Col 4:10; Phm 1:24; 2Ti 4:11. How long this separation continued is not known; but perhaps in this journey with Barnabas John gave such evidence of his courage and zeal as induced Paul again to admit him to his confidence as a traveling companion, and as to become a profitable fellow-laborer. See 2Ti 4:11, "Take Mark, and bring him with thee; for he is profitable to me for the ministry."
\caps1 (6) t\caps0 his account proves that there was no collusion or agreement among the apostles to impose upon mankind. Had there been such an agreement, and had the books of the New Testament been an imposture, the apostles would have been represented as perfectly harmonious, and as united in all their views and efforts. What impostor would have thought of the device of representing the early friends of the Christian religion as divided, and contending, and separating from each other? Such a statement has an air of candor and honesty, and at the same time is apparently so much against the truth of the system, that no impostor would have thought of resorting to it.
This John or Mark, was sister’ s son to Barnabas, as Col 4:10 .

Poole: Act 15:38 - -- This deserting of Paul and Barnabas by John, is mentioned Act 13:13 .
To the work the work unto which the Spirit had called them, Act 13:2 , which...
This deserting of Paul and Barnabas by John, is mentioned Act 13:13 .
To the work the work unto which the Spirit had called them, Act 13:2 , which was to offer life and salvation unto the Gentiles, and to gather them into the fold of Jesus Christ. This objection was very considerable, and ought to have weighed more than this John’ s propinquity, or nearness in blood, unto Barnabas.

Poole: Act 15:39 - -- They departed asunder as Abraham and Lot parted, Gen 13:9 , yet keeping the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace; loving of and praying for one a...
They departed asunder as Abraham and Lot parted, Gen 13:9 , yet keeping the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace; loving of and praying for one another, as we may judge, being both good men. But they verified here what they had said at Lystra, Act 14:15 ,
We are men of like passions with you yet God overruled these very divisions between Paul and Barnabas for his own glory, and the enlargement of the kingdom of Jesus Christ, several places being by this means blessed with the gospel. And this reflection upon this John Mark, is thought, to have made him for the future more diligent and valiant in the cause of the gospel, which occasioned that kind salutation from St. Paul unto him, Col 4:10 .
Cyprus an island in the Mediterranean Sea.

Poole: Act 15:40 - -- The favour of God, as Act 14:26 , which the wisest and holiest men stand in need of in all their undertakings; as also his gracious conduct and assi...
The favour of God, as Act 14:26 , which the wisest and holiest men stand in need of in all their undertakings; as also his gracious conduct and assistance.

Poole: Act 15:41 - -- Syria and Cilicia where there were several brethren by reason of the dispersion that was upon Stephen’ s death, Act 11:19 ; and unto whom also t...
Syria and Cilicia where there were several brethren by reason of the dispersion that was upon Stephen’ s death, Act 11:19 ; and unto whom also the before recited letter was written, Act 15:23 .
Confirming the churches puting them in mind of the gospel of Christ, which they had heard and believed; and encouraging of them to persevere in the profession of it, and being ready to answer any objection that could be brought against it.
Haydock -> Act 15:39
Haydock: Act 15:39 - -- There was a dissension, [2] or dispute, with reasoning, and arguing upon the matter. St. Paul represented to St. Barnabas, that he was not for having...
There was a dissension, [2] or dispute, with reasoning, and arguing upon the matter. St. Paul represented to St. Barnabas, that he was not for having John Mark to be their companion, because he had before left them, but St. Barnabas was for having with them his kinsman Mark; and the dispute was such, that upon is St. Paul and Barnabas separated; which gave occasion to the preaching of the gospel in more places. See St. John Chrysostom, hom. xxxiii. ---
The fault in this contention lay with St. Barnabas; Greek: o Paulos to dikaion, o Barnabas to philanthropon: Paul sought what was just; Barnabas what was pleasing to nature. The Greeks, moreover remark, that this severity of Paul was of service in strengthening the to pliant character of Mark, and as such he is saluted by Paul. (Colossians iv. 10.) They separated, as formerly Abraham and Lot, without prejudice to their friendship. (Genesis xiii. 9.) (Mat. Polus, synop. criticorum, fol. 4. p. 1528.)
===============================
[BIBLIOGRAPHY]
Dissentio, Greek: paroxusmos, acris disceptatio. See. St. John Chrysostom.
====================
Gill: Act 15:37 - -- And Barnabas determined,.... Or consulted, and contrived in his own mind, and purposed within himself; the Alexandrian copy, and two of Beza's, the Vu...
And Barnabas determined,.... Or consulted, and contrived in his own mind, and purposed within himself; the Alexandrian copy, and two of Beza's, the Vulgate Latin, Syriac, and Ethiopic versions read, "he would", or was willing; he had a mind, a very great desire,
to take with them John, whose surname was Mark; of whom see Act 12:12 he being his sister's son, Col 4:10 him they brought with them to Antioch, when they returned from Jerusalem thither, where they had been sent by the church at Antioch, with money for the relief of the poor saints; see Act 11:29 and who seems to have come with them from Jerusalem again; for thither he went, when he parted from them at Pamphylia, Act 13:13.

Gill: Act 15:38 - -- But Paul thought not good to take him with them,.... He did not think him worthy, or a fit and proper person to go with them, as the word used seems t...
But Paul thought not good to take him with them,.... He did not think him worthy, or a fit and proper person to go with them, as the word used seems to signify, and therefore he refused to take him: the Syriac version renders it, "but Paul would not take him with them"; and, the Ethiopic version is very expressive, though it renders it in softer language, "Paul prayed, or entreated Barnabas that he would leave Mark"; that is, behind them at Antioch: his reasons were as follow:
who departed from them from Pamphylia; see Gill on Act 13:13; either through the fatigue of the journey, or fear of danger, or weariness in his work, or affection to his mother; or be it what it will, it seems in the apostle's opinion of the matter, he was very blameworthy, and on account of it very undeserving, at least at present, of being a companion of theirs in their travels:
and went not with them to the work; the Arabic version adds, "of preaching"; that is, the Gospel, in the several places whither they went, and to which the Holy Ghost had called them, and for which the church at Antioch had separated, and sent them forth; but in the midst of this John deserted them; and which the apostle resented, he having, as yet, not given any evidence of his sense of his evil, and of his repentance for it, to his satisfaction; though it seems as if he afterwards did, since in Col 4:10 he speaks of him with great respect, as one of his fellow workers, and who had been a comfort to him.

Gill: Act 15:39 - -- And the contention was so sharp between them,.... About this matter; Barnabas insisting on it, that John Mark should go with them, he being a relation...
And the contention was so sharp between them,.... About this matter; Barnabas insisting on it, that John Mark should go with them, he being a relation of his; and in whose favour it might be urged, that his mother Mary was an excellent good woman, who had received the saints into her house, in a time of persecution; and that it should be considered, that this her son was but a young man, and could not be thought to have that courage, resolution, constancy, and solidity, as older professors and ministers; and that his crime was not very heinous, and should be overlooked. Paul, on the other hand, opposing his going with them, as a very unworthy person, because he had behaved so cowardly, and had shown such a coldness and indifference to the work of the ministry, and had so shamefully left them; and thus they disputed the point till there was a paroxysm between them, as is the word used: they were irritated and provoked by one another, and were so warmed and heated on both sides,
that they departed asunder one from another; thus as soon almost as peace was made in the church, a difference arises among the ministers of the word, who are men of like passions with others; and though it is not easy to say which was to blame most in this contention; perhaps there were faults on both sides, for the best men are not without their failings; yet this affair was overruled by the providence of God, for the spread of his Gospel, and the enlargement of his interest; for when these two great and good men parted from one another, they went to different places, preaching the word of God:
and so Barnabas took Mark and sailed unto Cyprus;
See Gill on Act 13:4.

Gill: Act 15:40 - -- And Paul chose Silas,.... To be his companion and assistant; this being the design of the Holy Ghost in influencing his, mind to stay longer at Antioc...
And Paul chose Silas,.... To be his companion and assistant; this being the design of the Holy Ghost in influencing his, mind to stay longer at Antioch, after he, with Judas, was dismissed by the church to go to Jerusalem, Act 15:33.
and departed; that is, from Antioch:
being recommended by the brethren unto the grace of God;
See Gill on Act 13:26. The apostle having such a recommendation by the brethren of the church at Antioch, when he departed from them, and nothing of this kind being said with respect to Barnabas, have induced some to think, that the church took the part of the apostle against Barnabas, in the dispute between them; since the one went away saluted by them, and the other not.

Gill: Act 15:41 - -- And he went through Syria and Cilicia,.... Antioch was the metropolis of the former, and Tarsus, the apostle's native place, was in the latter; and in...
And he went through Syria and Cilicia,.... Antioch was the metropolis of the former, and Tarsus, the apostle's native place, was in the latter; and in both these countries he had been before, and had been the instrument of converting many souls, and of planting churches, which he now visited, as he proposed to Barnabas to do: for it follows,
confirming the churches; in the Gospel, and the truths and ordinances of it, he had before instructed them in: of the church at Antioch; see Gill on Act 11:26. And that there were also churches in Cilicia, is very manifest; and particularly there was one at Tarsus, the chief city in it. Herodian, of whom we read in Rom 16:11 and Jason, in Act 17:5 who are reckoned among the seventy disciples, are said to be bishops or pastors of this church; See Gill on Luk 10:1. In the "second" century there was a church in that city, to which Ignatius wrote an epistle, still extant o, in which he makes mention of Philo their deacon: in the "third" century Helenus presided over this church, and was present at a synod at Antioch, when Paulus Samosatenus was condemned for heresy p: in the "fourth" century mention is made of several churches in Cilicia, and the bishops of them; there was a church at Apsis in Cilicia, Amphion was bishop of Epiphania, Theodorus of Mopsuestia, Cyriacus of Adanan, and Sylvanus of Tarsus, the metropolis; in which last place, in the beginning of this century, several martyrs suffered under Dioclesian, particularly Tharatus, Probus, and Andronicus: here the orthodox, in the times of Valens, would have convened a synod against the Arians, but were hindered by him; and in this century Diodorus, bishop of Tarsus, had the care of all the churches in Cilicia committed to him; in this age also we read of Antoninus, a presbyter of this church, afterwards made bishop of it: in the "fifth" century mention is made of the bishops of several churches in Cilicia, as of Mopsuesta, Irenopolis, Epiphania, Tarsus, Anazarbus, Sebaste, and others who were present at several councils held at different places in this century; in the "sixth" century, out of the cities of Cilicia, Jotapa, Pisidia, Pompeiopolis, Tarsus, Coricus, Anemurius, bishops are said to come to the synod at Rome and Constantinople: in the seventh century, Tarsus was the metropolitan church of Cilicia; and mention is made of the bishops of that and of other cities in this country, who assisted at the sixth council at Constantinople: in the "eighth" century, notice is taken of a Church at Sida in Cilicia q; so long the Christian name was in those parts. Beza's ancient copy adds, "delivering the commandments of the elders"; and the Vulgate Latin version, "bidding" them to keep the commandments of the apostles and elders; see Act 16:4, namely; the decrees of the assembly at Jerusalem; which seems very agreeable, since the letters were directed and sent to the brethren of the Gentiles in Syria and Cilicia, as well as in Antioch; see Act 15:23.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Act 15:38 Pamphylia was a province in the southern part of Asia Minor. See Acts 13:13, where it was mentioned previously.

NET Notes: Act 15:39 Cyprus is a large island in the Mediterranean off the south coast of Asia Minor.

NET Notes: Act 15:40 Grk “by the brothers.” Here it it is highly probable that the entire congregation is in view, not just men, so the translation “brot...

Geneva Bible: Act 15:37 ( 15 ) And Barnabas determined to take with them John, whose surname was Mark.
( 15 ) A lamentable example of discord between excellent men and very ...

Geneva Bible: Act 15:39 ( 16 ) And ( r ) the contention was so sharp between them, that they departed asunder one from the other: and so Barnabas took Mark, and sailed unto C...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Act 15:1-41
TSK Synopsis: Act 15:1-41 - --1 Great dissensions arise touching circumcision.5 The apostles consult about it,22 and send their determination by letters to the churches.36 Paul and...




Maclaren -> Act 15:37-38
Maclaren: Act 15:37-38 - --A Good Man's Faults
And Barnabas determined to take with them John, whose surname was Mark. 38. But Paul thought not good to take him with them, who ...
MHCC -> Act 15:36-41
MHCC: Act 15:36-41 - --Here we have a private quarrel between two ministers, no less than Paul and Barnabas, yet made to end well. Barnabas wished his nephew John Mark to go...
Matthew Henry -> Act 15:36-41
Matthew Henry: Act 15:36-41 - -- We have seen one unhappy difference among the brethren, which was of a public nature, brought to a good issue; but here we have a private quarrel be...
Barclay -> Act 15:36-41
Barclay: Act 15:36-41 - --Paul was a born adventurer and could never stay long in the one place. He decided to take the road again; but the preparations for the journey ended...
Constable: Act 9:32--Rom 1:1 - --III. THE WITNESS TO THE UTTERMOST PART OF THE EARTH 9:32--28:31
Luke next recorded the church's expansion beyond...

Constable: Act 12:25--16:6 - --B. The extension of the church to Cyprus and Asia Minor 12:25-16:5
Luke recorded that Jesus came to brin...

Constable: Act 15:36--16:6 - --5. The strengthening of the Gentile churches 15:36-16:5
Luke reported Paul and Barnabas' efforts...
