![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Acts 17:24-34 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Robertson -> Act 17:24; Act 17:24; Act 17:24; Act 17:24; Act 17:25; Act 17:25; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:28; Act 17:28; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:32; Act 17:32; Act 17:32; Act 17:33; Act 17:34; Act 17:34; Act 17:34
Robertson: Act 17:24 - -- The God that made the world ( Ho theos ho poiēsas ton kosmon ).
Not a god for this and a god for that like the 30,000 gods of the Athenians, but th...
The God that made the world (
Not a god for this and a god for that like the 30,000 gods of the Athenians, but the one God who made the Universe (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:24 - -- And all things therein ( kai panta ta en autōi ).
All the details in the universe were created by this one God. Paul is using the words of Isa 42:5...
And all things therein (
All the details in the universe were created by this one God. Paul is using the words of Isa 42:5. The Epicureans held that matter was eternal. Paul sets them aside. This one God was not to be confounded with any of their numerous gods save with this "Unknown God."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:24 - -- Being Lord of heaven and earth ( ouranou kai gēs huparchōn kurios ).
Kurios here owner, absolute possessor of both heaven and earth (Isa 45:7),...
Being Lord of heaven and earth (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:24 - -- Dwelleth not in temples made with hands ( ouken cheiropoiētois naois katoikei ).
The old adjective cheiropoiētos (cheir , poieō ) already i...
Dwelleth not in temples made with hands (
The old adjective
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:25 - -- As though he needed anything ( prosdeomenos tinos ).
Present middle participle of prosdeomai , to want besides, old verb, but here only in the N.T. T...
As though he needed anything (
Present middle participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:25 - -- Seeing he himself giveth to all ( autos didous pasin ).
This Supreme Personal God is the source of life, breath, and everything. Paul here rises abov...
Seeing he himself giveth to all (
This Supreme Personal God is the source of life, breath, and everything. Paul here rises above all Greek philosophers.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:26 - -- And he made of one ( epoiēsen te exō henos ).
The word haimatos (blood) is absent from Aleph A B and is a later explanatory addition. What Paul...
And he made of one (
The word
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:26 - -- For to dwell ( katoikein ).
Infinitive (present active) of purpose, so as to dwell.
For to dwell (
Infinitive (present active) of purpose, so as to dwell.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:26 - -- Having determined ( horisas ).
First aorist active participle of horizō , old verb to make a horizon as already in ActsAct 10:42 which see. Paul he...
Having determined (
First aorist active participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:26 - -- Appointed seasons ( prostetagmenous kairous ).
Not the weather as in Act 14:17, but "the times of the Gentiles"(kairoi ethnōn ) of which Jesus spo...
Appointed seasons (
Not the weather as in Act 14:17, but "the times of the Gentiles"(
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:26 - -- Bounds ( horothesias ).
Limits? Same idea in Job 12:23. Nations rise and fall, but it is not blind chance or hard fate. Thus there is an interplay be...
Bounds (
Limits? Same idea in Job 12:23. Nations rise and fall, but it is not blind chance or hard fate. Thus there is an interplay between God’ s will and man’ s activities, difficult as it is for us to see with our shortened vision.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:27 - -- That they should seek God ( Zētein ton theon ).
Infinitive (present active) of purpose again. Seek him, not turn away from him as the nations had d...
That they should seek God (
Infinitive (present active) of purpose again. Seek him, not turn away from him as the nations had done (Rom 1:18-32).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:27 - -- If haply they might feel after him ( ei ara geō psēlaphēseian auton ).
First aorist active (Aeolic form) optative of psēlaphaō , old verb f...
If haply they might feel after him (
First aorist active (Aeolic form) optative of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:27 - -- Though he is not far from each one of us ( kai geō ou makran apo henos hekastou hēmōn huparchonta ).
More exactly with B L (kai geō instead...
Though he is not far from each one of us (
More exactly with B L (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:28 - -- For in him ( en autōi gar ).
Proof of God’ s nearness, not stoic pantheism, but real immanence in God as God dwells in us. The three verbs (zo...
For in him (
Proof of God’ s nearness, not stoic pantheism, but real immanence in God as God dwells in us. The three verbs (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:28 - -- As certain even of your own poets ( hōs kai tines tōn kath' humās poiētōn ).
"As also some of the poets among you."Aratus of Soli in Cilici...
As certain even of your own poets (
"As also some of the poets among you."Aratus of Soli in Cilicia (ab. b.c. 270) has these very words in his Ta Phainomena and Cleanthes, Stoic philosopher (300-220 b.c.) in his Hymn to Zeus has
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:29 - -- We ought not to think ( ouk opheilomen nomizein ).
It is a logical conclusion (oun , therefore) from the very language of Aratus and Cleanthes.
We ought not to think (
It is a logical conclusion (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:29 - -- That the Godhead is like ( to theion einai homoion ).
Infinitive with accusative of general reference in indirect discourse. To theion is strictly ...
That the Godhead is like (
Infinitive with accusative of general reference in indirect discourse.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:29 - -- Graven by art and device of man ( charagmati technēs kai enthumēseōs anthrōpou ).
Apposition with preceding and so charagmati in associativ...
Graven by art and device of man (
Apposition with preceding and so
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:30 - -- The times of ignorance ( tous chronous tēs agnoias ).
The times before full knowledge of God came in Jesus Christ. Paul uses the very word for thei...
The times of ignorance (
The times before full knowledge of God came in Jesus Christ. Paul uses the very word for their ignorance (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:30 - -- Overlooked ( huperidōn ).
Second aorist active participle of huperoraō or hupereidō , old verb to see beyond, not to see, to overlook, not "t...
Overlooked (
Second aorist active participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:30 - -- But now ( ta nun ).
Accusative of general reference, "as to the now things or situation."All is changed now that Christ has come with the full knowle...
But now (
Accusative of general reference, "as to the now things or situation."All is changed now that Christ has come with the full knowledge of God. See also Act 27:22.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
All everywhere (
No exceptions anywhere.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:30 - -- Repent ( metanoein ).
Present active infinitive of metanoeō in indirect command, a permanent command of perpetual force. See note on metanoeō ...
Repent (
Present active infinitive of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- Inasmuch as ( kathoti ).
According as (kata , hoti ). Old causal conjunction, but in N.T. only used in Luke’ s writings (Luk 1:7; Luk 19:9; Ac...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- Hath appointed a day ( estēsen hēmeran )
First aorist active indicative of histēmi , to place, set. God did set the day in his counsel and he w...
Hath appointed a day (
First aorist active indicative of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- Will judge ( mellei krinein ).
Rather, is going to judge, mellō and the present active infinitive of krinō . Paul here quotes Psa 9:8 where kri...
Will judge (
Rather, is going to judge,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- By the man whom he hath ordained ( en andri hōi hōrisen ).
Here he adds to the Psalm the place and function of Jesus Christ, a passage in harmony...
By the man whom he hath ordained (
Here he adds to the Psalm the place and function of Jesus Christ, a passage in harmony with Christ’ s own words in Matthew 25.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- Whereof he hath given assurance ( pistin paraschōn ).
Second aorist active participle of parechō , old verb to furnish, used regularly by Demosth...
Whereof he hath given assurance (
Second aorist active participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:31 - -- In that he hath raised him from the dead ( anastēsas auton ek nekrōn ).
First aorist active participle of anistēmi , causal participle, but lit...
In that he hath raised him from the dead (
First aorist active participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:32 - -- The resurrection of the dead ( anastasin nekrōn ).
Rather, "a resurrection of dead men."No article with either word. The Greeks believed that the s...
The resurrection of the dead (
Rather, "a resurrection of dead men."No article with either word. The Greeks believed that the souls of men lived on, but they had no conception of resurrection of the body. They had listened with respect till Paul spoke of the actual resurrection of Jesus from the dead as a fact, when they did not care to hear more.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:32 - -- Some mocked ( hoi men echleuazon ).
Imperfect active of chleuazō , a common verb (from chleuē , jesting, mockery). Only here in the N.T. though l...
Some mocked (
Imperfect active of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:32 - -- But others ( hoi de ).
A more polite group like those who had invited him to speak (Act 17:19). They were unconvinced, but had better manners and so ...
But others (
A more polite group like those who had invited him to speak (Act 17:19). They were unconvinced, but had better manners and so were in favour of an adjournment. This was done, though it is not clear whether it was a serious postponement or a courteous refusal to hear Paul further (probably this). It was a virtual dismissal of the matter. "It is a sad story--the noblest of ancient cities and the noblest man of history--and he never cared to look on it again"(Furneaux).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:33 - -- Thus Paul went out from among them ( houtōs ho Paulos exēlthen ek mesou autōn ).
No further questions, no effort to arrest him, no further ridi...
Thus Paul went out from among them (
No further questions, no effort to arrest him, no further ridicule. He walked out never to return to Athens. Had he failed?
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:34 - -- Clave unto him and believed ( kollēthentes autōi episteusan ).
First aorist passive of this strong word kollaō , to glue to, common in Acts (Ac...
Clave unto him and believed (
First aorist passive of this strong word
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:34 - -- Dionysius the Areopagite ( Dionusios ho Areopagitēs ).
One of the judges of the Court of the Areopagus. That of itself was no small victory. He was...
Dionysius the Areopagite (
One of the judges of the Court of the Areopagus. That of itself was no small victory. He was one of this college of twelve judges who had helped to make Athens famous. Eusebius says that he became afterwards bishop of the Church at Athens and died a martyr.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 17:34 - -- A woman named Damaris ( gunē onomati Damaris ).
A woman by name Damaris. Not the wife of Dionysius as some have thought, but an aristocratic woman,...
A woman named Damaris (
A woman by name Damaris. Not the wife of Dionysius as some have thought, but an aristocratic woman, not necessarily an educated courtezan as Furneaux holds. And there were "others"(
God
With the article: " the God."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:24 - -- The world ( τὸν κόσμον )
Originally, order, and hence the order of the world; the ordered universe. So in classical Greek. In th...
The world (
Originally, order, and hence the order of the world; the ordered universe. So in classical Greek. In the Septuagint, never the world, but the ordered total of the heavenly bodies; the host of heaven (Deuteronomy 4:19; 17:3; Isaiah 24:21; 40:26). Compare, also, Pro 17:6, and see note on Jam 3:6. In the apocryphal books, of the universe, and mainly in the relation between God and it arising out of the creation. Thus, the king of the world ( 2 Maccabees 7:9); the creator or founder of the world (2 Maccabees 7:23); the great potentate of the world (2 Maccabees 12:15). In the New Testament: 1. In the classical and physical sense, the universe (Joh 17:5; Joh 21:25.; Rom 1:20; Eph 1:4, etc.). 2. As the order of things of which man is the centre (Mat 13:38; Mar 16:15; Luk 9:25; Joh 16:21; Eph 2:12; 1Ti 6:7). 3. Humanity as it manifests itself in and through this order (Mat 18:7; 2Pe 2:5; 2Pe 3:6; Rom 3:19). Then, as sin has entered and disturbed the order of things, and made a breach between the heavenly and the earthly order, which are one in the divine ideal - 4. The order of things which is alienated from God, as manifested in and by the human race: humanity as alienated from God, and acting in opposition to him (Joh 1:10; Joh 12:31; Joh 15:18, Joh 15:19; 1Co 1:21; 1Jo 2:15, etc.). The word is used here in the classical sense of the visible creation, which would appeal to the Athenians. Stanley, speaking of the name by which the Deity is known in the patriarchal age, the plural Elohim, notes that Abraham, in perceiving that all the Elohim worshipped by the numerous clans of his race meant one God, anticipated the declaration of Paul in this passage (" Jewish Church," i., 25). Paul's statement strikes at the belief of the Epicureans, that the world was made by " a fortuitous concourse of atoms," and of the Stoics, who denied the creation of the world by God, holding either that God animated the world, or that the world itself was God.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:24 - -- Made with hands ( χιεροποιήτοις )
Probably pointing to the magnificent temples above and around him. Paul's epistles abound in arc...
Made with hands (
Probably pointing to the magnificent temples above and around him. Paul's epistles abound in architectural metaphors. He here employs the very words of Stephen, in his address to the Sanhedrim, which he very probably heard. See Act 7:48.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:25 - -- Is worshipped ( θεραπεύεται )
Incorrect. Render, as Rev., served. Luke often uses the word in the sense of to heal or cure; bu...
Is worshipped (
Incorrect. Render, as Rev., served. Luke often uses the word in the sense of to heal or cure; but this is its primary sense. See on Luk 5:15. It refers to the clothing of the images of the gods in splendid garments, and bringing them costly gifts and offerings of food and drink.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:25 - -- As though he needed ( προσδεόμενος )
Properly, " needed anything in addition (πρός ) to what he already has."
As though he needed (
Properly, " needed anything in addition (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:26 - -- Before appointed ( προτεταγμένους )
The Rev., properly, omits before, following the reading of the best texts, τεταγμέ...
Before appointed (
The Rev., properly, omits before, following the reading of the best texts,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:26 - -- Bounds ( ὀροθεσίας )
Only here in New Testament. The word, in the singular, means the fixing of boundaries, and so is transferred ...
Bounds (
Only here in New Testament. The word, in the singular, means the fixing of boundaries, and so is transferred to the fixed boundaries themselves.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:27 - -- Might feel after
See on handle, Luk 24:39. Compare Tennyson:
" I stretch lame hands of faith, and grope
And gather dust and chaff, and call
T...
Might feel after
See on handle, Luk 24:39. Compare Tennyson:
" I stretch lame hands of faith, and grope
And gather dust and chaff, and call
To what I feel is Lord of all."
In Memoriam , lv.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:28 - -- We are also his offspring
A line from Aratus, a poet of Paul's own province of Cilicia. The same sentiment, in almost the same words, occurs in t...
We are also his offspring
A line from Aratus, a poet of Paul's own province of Cilicia. The same sentiment, in almost the same words, occurs in the fine hymn of Cleanthes to Jove. Hence the words, " Some of your own poets."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The Godhead (
Lit., that which is divine.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:29 - -- Like to gold, etc
These words must have impressed his hearers profoundly, as they looked at the multitude of statues of divinities which surroun...
Like to gold, etc
These words must have impressed his hearers profoundly, as they looked at the multitude of statues of divinities which surrounded them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:29 - -- Graven ( χαράγματι )
Not a participle, as A. V., but a noun, in apposition with gold, silver, and stone: " a graving or carved ...
Graven (
Not a participle, as A. V., but a noun, in apposition with gold, silver, and stone: " a graving or carved - work of art, " etc.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:30 - -- Winked at ( ὑπεριδὼν )
Only here in New Testament. Originally, to overlook; to suffer to pass unnoticed. So Rev., overlooked.
Winked at (
Only here in New Testament. Originally, to overlook; to suffer to pass unnoticed. So Rev., overlooked.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:32 - -- Resurrection
This word was the signal for a derisive outburst from the crowd.
Resurrection
This word was the signal for a derisive outburst from the crowd.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:32 - -- Mocked ( ἐχλεύαζον )
From χλεύη , a jest. Only here in New Testament, though a compound, διαχλευάζω , mock, occ...
Mocked (
From
In this remarkable speech of Paul are to be noted: his prudence and tact in not needlessly offending his hearers; his courtesy and spirit of conciliation in recognizing their piety toward their gods; his wisdom and readiness in the use of the inscription " to the unknown God," and in citing their own poets; his meeting the radical errors of every class of his hearers, while seeming to dwell only on points of agreement; his lofty views of the nature of God and the great principle of the unity of the human race; his boldness in proclaiming Jesus and the resurrection among those to whom these truths were foolishness; the wonderful terseness and condensation of the whole, and the rapid but powerful and assured movement of the thought.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 17:34 - -- The Areopagite
One of the judges of the court of Areopagus. Of this court Curtius remarks: " Here, instead of a single judge, a college of twelve...
The Areopagite
One of the judges of the court of Areopagus. Of this court Curtius remarks: " Here, instead of a single judge, a college of twelve men of proved integrity conducted the trial. If the accused had an equal number of votes for and against him, he was acquitted. The Court on the hill of Ares is one of the most ancient institutions of Athens, and none achieved for the city an earlier or more widely spread recognition. The Areopagitic penal code was adopted as a norm by all subsequent legislators" (" History of Greece," i., 307).
Wesley: Act 17:24 - -- Thus is demonstrated even to reason, the one true, good God; absolutely different from the creatures, from every part of the visible creation.
Thus is demonstrated even to reason, the one true, good God; absolutely different from the creatures, from every part of the visible creation.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
or person - The Greek word equally takes in both.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:25 - -- That live and breathe; - in him we live; and breathe - In him we move. By breathing life is continued.
That live and breathe; - in him we live; and breathe - In him we move. By breathing life is continued.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:25 - -- For in him we are. So exactly do the parts of this discourse answer each other.
For in him we are. So exactly do the parts of this discourse answer each other.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:26 - -- By this expression the apostle showed them in the most unaffected manner, that though he was a Jew, be was not enslaved to any narrow views, but looke...
By this expression the apostle showed them in the most unaffected manner, that though he was a Jew, be was not enslaved to any narrow views, but looked on all mankind as his brethren: having determined the times - That it is God who gave men the earth to inhabit, Paul proves from the order of times and places, showing the highest wisdom of the Disposer, superior to all human counsels.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
By mountains, seas, rivers, and the like.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The way is open; God is ready to be found.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:27 - -- This is in the midst between seeking and finding. Feeling being the lowest and grossest of all our senses, is fitly applied to the low knowledge of Go...
This is in the midst between seeking and finding. Feeling being the lowest and grossest of all our senses, is fitly applied to the low knowledge of God; though he be not far from every one of us - We need not go far to seek or find him. He is very near us; in us. It is only perverse reason which thinks he is afar off.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:28 - -- Not in ourselves, we live, and move, and have our being - This denotes his necessary, intimate, and most efficacious presence. No words can better exp...
Not in ourselves, we live, and move, and have our being - This denotes his necessary, intimate, and most efficacious presence. No words can better express the continual and necessary dependence of all created beings, in their existence and all their operations, on the first and almighty cause, which the truest philosophy as well as divinity teaches.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:28 - -- Aratus, whose words these are, was an Athenian, who lived almost three hundred years before this time. They are likewise to be found, with the alterat...
Aratus, whose words these are, was an Athenian, who lived almost three hundred years before this time. They are likewise to be found, with the alteration of one letter only, in the hymn of Cleanthes to Jupiter or the supreme being, one of the purest and finest pieces of natural religion in the whole world of Pagan antiquity.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:29 - -- A tender expression especially in the first per son plural. As if he had said, Can God himself be a less noble being than we who are his offspring? No...
A tender expression especially in the first per son plural. As if he had said, Can God himself be a less noble being than we who are his offspring? Nor does he only here deny, that these are like God, but that they have any analogy to him at all, so as to be capable of representing him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:30 - -- What! does he object ignorance to the knowing Athenians? Yes, and they acknowledge it by this very altar.
What! does he object ignorance to the knowing Athenians? Yes, and they acknowledge it by this very altar.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:30 - -- As one paraphrases, "The beams of his eye did in a manner shoot over it." He did not appear to take notice of them, by sending express messages to the...
As one paraphrases, "The beams of his eye did in a manner shoot over it." He did not appear to take notice of them, by sending express messages to them as he did to the Jews.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:30 - -- This day, this hour, saith Paul, puts an end to the Divine forbearance, and brings either greater mercy or punishment.
This day, this hour, saith Paul, puts an end to the Divine forbearance, and brings either greater mercy or punishment.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:30 - -- There is a dignity and grandeur in this expression, becoming an ambassador from the King of heaven. And this universal demand of repentance declared u...
There is a dignity and grandeur in this expression, becoming an ambassador from the King of heaven. And this universal demand of repentance declared universal guilt in the strongest manner, and admirably confronted the pride of the haughtiest Stoic of them all. At the same time it bore down the idle plea of fatality. For how could any one repent of doing what he could not but have done?
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:31 - -- How fitly does he speak this, in their supreme court of justice? By the man - So he speaks, suiting himself to the capacity of his hearers. Whereof he...
How fitly does he speak this, in their supreme court of justice? By the man - So he speaks, suiting himself to the capacity of his hearers. Whereof he hath given assurance to all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead - God raising Jesus demonstrated hereby, that he was to be the glorious Judge of all. We are by no means to imagine that this was all which the apostle intended to have said, but the indolence of some of his hearers and the petulancy of others cut him short.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:32 - -- Interrupting him thereby. They took offence at that which is the principal motive of faith, from the pride of reason. And having once stumbled at this...
Interrupting him thereby. They took offence at that which is the principal motive of faith, from the pride of reason. And having once stumbled at this, they rejected all the rest.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Leaving his hearers divided in their judgment.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 17:34 - -- One of the judges of that court: on whom some spurious writings have been fathered in later ages, by those who are fond of high sounding nonsense.
One of the judges of that court: on whom some spurious writings have been fathered in later ages, by those who are fond of high sounding nonsense.
JFB -> Act 17:24-25; Act 17:24-25; Act 17:24-25; Act 17:24-25; Act 17:25; Act 17:25; Act 17:25; Act 17:25; Act 17:26-27; Act 17:26-27; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:28; Act 17:28; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:32-34; Act 17:32-34; Act 17:33; Act 17:34; Act 17:34; Act 17:34
JFB: Act 17:24-25 - -- The most profound philosophers of Greece were unable to conceive any real distinction between God and the universe. Thick darkness, therefore, behoove...
The most profound philosophers of Greece were unable to conceive any real distinction between God and the universe. Thick darkness, therefore, behooved to rest on all their religious conceptions. To dissipate this, the apostle sets out with a sharp statement of the fact of creation as the central principle of all true religion--not less needed now, against the transcendental idealism of our day.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:24-25 - -- Holding in free and absolute subjection all the works of His hands; presiding in august royalty over them, as well as pervading them all as the princi...
Holding in free and absolute subjection all the works of His hands; presiding in august royalty over them, as well as pervading them all as the principle of their being. How different this from the blind Force or Fate to which all creatures were regarded as in bondage!
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:24-25 - -- This thought, so familiar to Jewish ears (1Ki 8:27; Isa 66:1-2; Act 7:48), and so elementary to Christians, would serve only more sharply to define to...
This thought, so familiar to Jewish ears (1Ki 8:27; Isa 66:1-2; Act 7:48), and so elementary to Christians, would serve only more sharply to define to his heathen audience the spirituality of that living, personal God, whom he "announced" to them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:25 - -- No less familiar as this thought also is to us, even from the earliest times of the Old Testament (Job 35:6, Job 35:8; Psa 16:2-3; Psa 50:12-14; Isa 4...
No less familiar as this thought also is to us, even from the earliest times of the Old Testament (Job 35:6, Job 35:8; Psa 16:2-3; Psa 50:12-14; Isa 40:14-18), it would pour a flood of light upon any candid heathen mind that heard it.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:25 - -- The Giver of all cannot surely be dependent for aught upon the receivers of all (1Ch 29:14). This is the culminating point of a pure Theism.
The Giver of all cannot surely be dependent for aught upon the receivers of all (1Ch 29:14). This is the culminating point of a pure Theism.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:26-27 - -- Holding with the Old Testament teaching, that in the blood is the life (Gen 9:4; Lev 17:11; Deu 12:23), the apostle sees this life stream of the whole...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:26-27 - -- The apostle here opposes both Stoical Fate and Epicurean Chance, ascribing the periods and localities in which men and nations flourish to the soverei...
The apostle here opposes both Stoical Fate and Epicurean Chance, ascribing the periods and localities in which men and nations flourish to the sovereign will and prearrangements of a living God.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:27 - -- That is the high end of all these arrangements of Divine Power, Wisdom, and Love.
That is the high end of all these arrangements of Divine Power, Wisdom, and Love.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
A lively picture of the murky atmosphere of Natural Religion.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:27 - -- The difficulty of finding God outside the pale of revealed religion lies not in His distance from us, but in our distance from Him through the blindin...
The difficulty of finding God outside the pale of revealed religion lies not in His distance from us, but in our distance from Him through the blinding effect of sin.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:28 - -- (or, more briefly, "exist").--This means, not merely, "Without Him we have no life, nor that motion which every inanimate nature displays, nor even ex...
(or, more briefly, "exist").--This means, not merely, "Without Him we have no life, nor that motion which every inanimate nature displays, nor even existence itself" [MEYER], but that God is the living, immanent Principle of all these in men.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:28 - -- The first half of the fifth line, word for word, of an astronomical poem of Aratus, a Greek countryman of the apostle, and his predecessor by about th...
The first half of the fifth line, word for word, of an astronomical poem of Aratus, a Greek countryman of the apostle, and his predecessor by about three centuries. But, as he hints, the same sentiment is to be found in other Greek poets. They meant it doubtless in a pantheistic sense; but the truth which it expresses the apostle turns to his own purpose--to teach a pure, personal, spiritual Theism. (Probably during his quiet retreat at Tarsus. Act 9:30, revolving his special vocation to the Gentiles he gave himself to the study of so much Greek literature as might be turned to Christian account in his future work. Hence this and his other quotations from the Greek poets, 1Co 15:33; Tit 1:12).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The courtesy of this language is worthy of notice.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:29 - -- ("graven by the art or device of man"). One can hardly doubt that the apostle would here point to those matchless monuments of the plastic art, in gol...
("graven by the art or device of man"). One can hardly doubt that the apostle would here point to those matchless monuments of the plastic art, in gold and silver and costliest stone, which lay so profusely beneath and around him. The more intelligent pagan Greeks no more pretended that these sculptured gods and goddesses were real deities, or even their actual likenesses, than Romanist Christians do their images; and Paul doubtless knew this; yet here we find him condemning all such efforts visibly to represent the invisible God. How shamefully inexcusable then are the Greek and Roman churches in paganizing the worship of the Christian Church by the encouragement of pictures and images in religious service! (In the eighth century, the second council of Nicea decreed that the image of God was as proper an object of worship as God Himself).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:30 - -- Literally (and far better), "overlooked," that is, bore with, without interposing to punish it, otherwise than suffering the debasing tendency of such...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
That a new light was risen upon the world.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:30 - -- "That duty--all along lying upon man estranged from his Creator, but hitherto only silently recommending itself and little felt--is now peremptory."
"That duty--all along lying upon man estranged from his Creator, but hitherto only silently recommending itself and little felt--is now peremptory."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:30 - -- (compare Col 1:6, Col 1:23; Tit 1:11) --a tacit allusion to the narrow precincts of favored Judaism, within which immediate and entire repentance was ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:31 - -- Such language beyond doubt teaches that the judgment will, in its essence, be a solemn judicial assize held upon all mankind at once. "Aptly is this u...
Such language beyond doubt teaches that the judgment will, in its essence, be a solemn judicial assize held upon all mankind at once. "Aptly is this uttered on the Areopagus, the seat of judgment" [BENGEL].
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:31 - -- The most patent evidence to mankind at large of the judicial authority with which the Risen One is clothed.
The most patent evidence to mankind at large of the judicial authority with which the Risen One is clothed.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:32-34 - -- As the Greek religion was but the glorification of the present life, by the worship of all its most beauteous forms, the Resurrection, which presuppos...
As the Greek religion was but the glorification of the present life, by the worship of all its most beauteous forms, the Resurrection, which presupposes the vanity of the present life, and is nothing but life out of the death of all that sin has blighted, could have no charm for the true Greek. It gave the death blow to his fundamental and most cherished ideas; nor until these were seen to be false and fatal could the Resurrection, and the Gospel of which it was a primary doctrine, seem otherwise than ridiculous.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:32-34 - -- "an idle compliment to Paul and an opiate to their consciences, such as we often meet with in our own day. They probably, like Felix, feared to hear m...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:33 - -- Whether he would have opened, to any extent, the Gospel scheme in this address, if he had not been interrupted, or whether he reserved this for exposi...
Whether he would have opened, to any extent, the Gospel scheme in this address, if he had not been interrupted, or whether he reserved this for exposition afterwards to earnest inquirers, we cannot tell. Only the speech is not to be judged of as quite complete.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:34 - -- Instead of mocking or politely waiving the subject, having listened eagerly, they joined themselves to the apostle for further instruction; and so the...
Instead of mocking or politely waiving the subject, having listened eagerly, they joined themselves to the apostle for further instruction; and so they "believed."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:34 - -- A member of that august tribunal. Ancient tradition says he was placed by the apostle over the little flock at Athens. "Certainly the number of conver...
A member of that august tribunal. Ancient tradition says he was placed by the apostle over the little flock at Athens. "Certainly the number of converts there and of men fit for office in the Church was not so great that there could be much choice" [OLSHAUSEN].
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 17:34 - -- Not certainly one of the apostle's audience on the Areopagus, but won to the faith either before or after. Nothing else is known of her. Of any furthe...
Not certainly one of the apostle's audience on the Areopagus, but won to the faith either before or after. Nothing else is known of her. Of any further labors of the apostle at Athens, and how long he stayed, we are not informed. Certainly he was not driven away. But "it is a serious and instructive fact that the mercantile populations of Thessalonica and Corinth received the message of God with greater readiness than the highly educated and polished Athenians. Two letters to the Thessalonians, and two to the Corinthians, remain to attest the flourishing state of those churches. But we possess no letter written by Paul to the Athenians; and we do not read that he was ever in Athens again" [HOWSON].
Clarke: Act 17:24 - -- God that made the world, etc. - Though the Epicureans held that the world was not made by God, but was the effect of a fortuitous concourse of atoms...
God that made the world, etc. - Though the Epicureans held that the world was not made by God, but was the effect of a fortuitous concourse of atoms, yet this opinion was not popular; and the Stoics held the contrary
1. St. Paul assumes, as an acknowledged truth, that there was a God who made the world and all things
2. That this God could not be confined within temples made with hands, as he was the Lord or governor of heaven and earth
3. That, by fair consequence, the gods whom they worshipped, which were shut up in their temples could not be this God; and they must be less than the places in which they were contained. This was a strong, decisive stroke against the whole system of the Grecian idolatry.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:25 - -- Neither is worshiped with men’ s hands - This is an indirect stroke against making of images, and offering of sacrifices: he is not worshipped ...
Neither is worshiped with men’ s hands - This is an indirect stroke against making of images, and offering of sacrifices: he is not worshipped with human hands, as if he needed any thing, or required to be represented under a particular form or attitude; nor has he required victims for his support; for it is impossible that he should need any thing who himself gives being, form, and life, to all creatures
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:25 - -- Giveth - life, and breath, and all things - These words are elegantly introduced by St. Paul: God gives life, because he is the fountain of it: he g...
Giveth - life, and breath, and all things - These words are elegantly introduced by St. Paul: God gives life, because he is the fountain of it: he gives breath, the faculty of breathing or respiration, by which this life is preserved; and though breathing or respiration, be the act of the animal, yet the
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:26 - -- Hath made of one blood - In AB, some others, with the Coptic, Ethiopic, Vulgate, Itala, Clement, and Bede, the word αἱματος, blood, is omi...
Hath made of one blood - In AB, some others, with the Coptic, Ethiopic, Vulgate, Itala, Clement, and Bede, the word
I glory in being of that same race and blood
So Virgil, Aen. viii. ver. 142, says
Sic genus amborum scindit se Sanguine ab uno
Thus, from one stock, do both our stems divide
See many examples of this form in Kypke. The Athenians had a foolish notion that they were self-produced, and were the aboriginals of mankind. Lucian ridicules this opinion,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:26 - -- To dwell on all the face of the earth - God in his wisdom produced the whole human race from one man; and, having in his providence scattered them o...
To dwell on all the face of the earth - God in his wisdom produced the whole human race from one man; and, having in his providence scattered them over the face of the earth, by showing them that they sprang from one common source, has precluded all those contentious wars and bloodshed which would necessarily have taken place among the nations of the world, as each in its folly might have arrogated to itself a higher and more excellent origin than another
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:26 - -- And hath determined the times before appointed - Instead of προτεταγμενους καιρους, the times before appointed, ABDE, and more...
And hath determined the times before appointed - Instead of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:26 - -- And the bounds of their habitations - Every family being appointed to a particular place, that their posterity might possess it for the purposes for...
And the bounds of their habitations - Every family being appointed to a particular place, that their posterity might possess it for the purposes for which infinite wisdom and goodness gave them their being, and the place of their abode. Every nation had its lot thus appointed by God, as truly as the Israelites had the land of Canaan. But the removal of the Jews from their own land shows that a people may forfeit their original inheritance, and thus the Canaanites have been supplanted by the Jews; the Jews by the Saracens; the Saracens by the Turks; the Greeks by the Romans; the Romans by the Goths and Vandals; and so of others. See the notes on Genesis 11:1-32 (note).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:27 - -- That they should seek the Lord - This is a conclusion drawn from the preceding statement. God, who is infinitely great and self-sufficient, has mani...
That they should seek the Lord - This is a conclusion drawn from the preceding statement. God, who is infinitely great and self-sufficient, has manifested himself as the maker of the world, the creator, preserver, and governor of men. He has assigned them their portion, and dispensed to them their habitations, and the various blessings of his providence, to the end that they should seek him in all his works
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:27 - -- Feel after him - Ψηλαφησειαν αυτον, That they might grope after him, as a person does his way who is blind or blindfolded. The Gent...
Feel after him -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:28 - -- For in him we live, and move, and have our being - He is the very source of our existence: the principle of life comes from him: the principle of mo...
For in him we live, and move, and have our being - He is the very source of our existence: the principle of life comes from him: the principle of motion, also, comes from him; one of the most difficult things in nature to be properly apprehended; and a strong proof of the continual presence and energy of the Deity
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:28 - -- And have our being - Και εσμεν, And we are: we live in him, move in him, and are in him. Without him we not only can do nothing, but withou...
And have our being -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:28 - -- As certain also of your own poets - Probably he means not only Aratus, in whose poem, entitled Phaenomena, the words quoted by St. Paul are to be fo...
As certain also of your own poets - Probably he means not only Aratus, in whose poem, entitled Phaenomena, the words quoted by St. Paul are to be found literatim,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:28 - -- We are also his offspring - Του γαρ και γενος εσμεν The Phaenomena of Aratus, in which these words are found, begins thus: -
...
We are also his offspring -
With Jove we must begin; nor from him rove
Him always praise, for all is full of Jove
He fills all places where mankind resort
The wide-spread sea, with every shelt’ ring port
Jove’ s presence fills all space, upholds this ball
All need his aid; his power sustains us all
For we his offspring are; and he in lov
Points out to man his labor from above
Where signs unerring show when best the soil
By well-timed culture, shall repay our toil, etc., etc
Aratus was a Cilician, one of St. Paul’ s own countrymen, and with his writings St. Paul was undoubtedly well acquainted, though he had flourished about 300 years before that time.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:29 - -- Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, etc. - This inference of the apostle was very strong and conclusive; and his argument runs thus: "If ...
Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, etc. - This inference of the apostle was very strong and conclusive; and his argument runs thus: "If we are the offspring of God, he cannot be like those images of gold, silver, and stone, which are formed by the art and device of man; for the parent must resemble his offspring. Seeing, therefore, that we are living and intelligent beings, He from whom we have derived that being must be living and intelligent. It is necessary, also, that the object of religious worship should be much more excellent than the worshipper; but a man is, by innumerable degrees, more excellent than an image made out of gold, silver, or stone; and yet it would be impious to worship a man: how much more so to worship these images as gods! Every man in the Areopagus must have felt the power of this conclusion; and, taking it for granted that they had felt it, he proceeds: -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:30 - -- The times of this ignorance God winked at - He who has an indisputable right to demand the worship of all his creatures has mercifully overlooked th...
The times of this ignorance God winked at - He who has an indisputable right to demand the worship of all his creatures has mercifully overlooked those acts of idolatry which have disgraced the world and debased man; but now, as he has condescended to give a revelation of himself, he commands, as the sovereign, all men every where, over every part of his dominions, to repent,
The word
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:31 - -- He hath appointed a day - He has fixed the time in which he will judge the world, though he has not revealed this time to man
He hath appointed a day - He has fixed the time in which he will judge the world, though he has not revealed this time to man
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:31 - -- By that man whom he hath ordained - He has also appointed the judge, by whom the inhabitants of the earth are to be tried
By that man whom he hath ordained - He has also appointed the judge, by whom the inhabitants of the earth are to be tried
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:31 - -- Whereof he hath given assurance - ΠιϚιν παρασχων πασιν, Having given to all this indubitable proof, that Jesus Christ shall judge...
Whereof he hath given assurance -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:32 - -- When they heard of the resurrection, etc. - Paul undoubtedly had not finished his discourse: it is likely that he was about to have proclaimed salva...
When they heard of the resurrection, etc. - Paul undoubtedly had not finished his discourse: it is likely that he was about to have proclaimed salvation through Christ crucified; but, on hearing of the resurrection of the body, the assembly instantly broke up; the Epicureans mocking,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:33 - -- So Paul departed from among them - He could not be convicted of having done any thing contrary to the law; and, when the assembly broke up, he was p...
So Paul departed from among them - He could not be convicted of having done any thing contrary to the law; and, when the assembly broke up, he was permitted to go about his own business.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:34 - -- Certain men clave unto him - Became affectionately united to him, and believed the doctrines he had preached
Certain men clave unto him - Became affectionately united to him, and believed the doctrines he had preached
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 17:34 - -- Dionysius the Areopagite - There can be no doubt that this man was one of the judges of this great court, but whether the president or otherwise we ...
Dionysius the Areopagite - There can be no doubt that this man was one of the judges of this great court, but whether the president or otherwise we cannot tell. Humanly speaking, his conversion must have been an acquisition of considerable importance to the Christian religion; for no person was a judge in the Areopagus who had not borne the office of archon, or chief governor of the city; and none bore the office of judge in this court who was not of the highest reputation among the people for his intelligence and exemplary conduct. In some of the popish writers we find a vast deal of groundless conjecture concerning Dionysius, who, they say, was first bishop of Athens, and raised to that dignity by Paul himself; that he was a martyr for the truth; that Damaris was his wife, etc., etc., concerning which the judicious Calmet says, Tout cela est de peu d’ autorite . "All this has little foundation.
1. In addition to what has been said in the notes on this subject, I may add, the original word
2. That the original word, on the right interpretation of which I have laid so much stress, is taken in a good sense, and signifies religious worship and reverence, I shall show by several proofs; some of which may be seen in Mr. Parkhurst, under the word
3. That the Athenians were reputed, in this respect, a devout people, the following quotations may prove. Pausanias, in Attic. cap. xvii. p. 39, edit. Kuhn., says that the Athenians were not only more humane,
4. In the preceding notes, I have taken for granted that Paul was brought to the Areopagus to be tried on the charge of setting forth strange gods. Bp. Warburton denies that he was brought before the Areopagus on any charge whatever; and that he was taken there that the judges might hear him explain his doctrine, and not to defend himself against a charge which he does not once notice in the whole of his discourse. But there is one circumstance that the bishop has not noticed, viz. that St. Paul was not permitted to finish his discourse, and therefore could not come to those particular parts of the charge brought against him which the bishop thinks he must have taken up most pointedly, had he been accused, and brought there to make his defense. The truth is, we have little more than the apostle’ s exordium, as he was evidently interrupted in the prosecution of his defense. As to the supposition that he was brought by philosophers to the Areopagus, that they might the better hear him explain his doctrine, it appears to have little ground; for they might have heard him to as great advantage in any other place: nor does it appear that this court was ever used, except for the solemn purposes of justice. But the question, whether Paul was brought to the Areopagus that he might be tried by the judges of that court, Bishop Pearce answers with his usual judgment and discrimination. He observes
1. "We are told that one effect of his preaching was, that he converted Dionysius the Areopagite, Act 17:34; and this seems to show that he, who was a judge of that court, was present, and, if so, probably other judges were present also
2. If they who brought Paul to Areopagus wanted only to satisfy their curiosity, they had an opportunity of doing that in the market, mentioned Act 17:17. Why then did they remove him to another place
3. When it is said that they brought Paul to Areopagus, it is said that they took him,
4. It is observable that Paul, in his whole discourse at the Areopagus, did not make the least attempt to move the passions of his audience, as he did when speaking to Felix, Act 24:25, and to Agrippa, Act 26:29; but he used plain and grave reasonings to convince his hearers of the soundness of his doctrine
"Now, we are told by Quinctilian, in Inst. Orat. ii. 16, that Athenis actor movere affectus vetabatur : the actor was forbidden to endeavor to excite the passions. And again, in vi. 1, that Athenis affectus movere etiam per praeconem prohibebatur orator : among the Athenians, the orator was prohibited by the public crier to move the passions of his auditory. And this is confirmed by Philostratus in procem. lib. i. de Vit. Sophist.; and by Athenaeus, in Deipnosoph. xiii. 6. If, therefore, it was strictly forbidden at Athens to move the affections of the courts of justice, especially in that of the Areopagus, we see a good reason why Paul made no attempt in that way; and, at the same time, we learn how improperly the painters have done all they could, when they represent Paul speaking at Athens, endeavoring both by his looks and gestures to raise those several passions in his hearers which their faces are meant to express.
I have only to add here, that, though St. Paul did not endeavor to excite any passions in his address at the Areopagus, yet each sect of the philosophers would feel themselves powerfully affected by every thing in his discourse which tended to show the emptiness or falsity of their doctrines; and, though he attempted to move no passions, yet, from these considerations, their passions would be strongly moved. And this is the idea which the inimitable Raphael took up in his celebrated cartoon on this subject, and which his best copier, Mr. Thomas Holloway, has not only engraved to the life, but has also described in language only inferior to the cartoon itself; and, as it affords no mean comment on the preceding discourse, my readers will be pleased to find it here
By the cartoons of Raphael, we are to understand certain Scripture pieces painted by Raphael d’ Urbino, and now preserved in the palace at Hampton court. They are allowed to be the chefs d’ oeuvre in their kind. They have been often engraved, but never so as to give an adequate representation of the matchless originals, till Mr. Thomas Holloway, who has completely seized the spirit of the artist, undertook this most laborious work, in which he has been wholly engaged for several years; and in which he has, for some time past, associated with himself Messrs. Slann and Webb, two excellent artists, who had formerly been his own pupils. The cartoon to which I have referred has been some time finished, and delivered to the subscribers; and with it that elegant description, from which the following is a copious extract: -
"The eye no sooner glances on this celebrated cartoon than it is immediately struck with the commanding attitude of the speaker, and the various emotions excited in his hearers
"The interest which the first appearance of St. Paul at Athens had occasioned, was not calculated to subside on a sudden; his doctrines were too new, and his zeal too ardent. From the multitude it ascended to the philosophers. The Epicureans and Stoics particularly assailed him. Antecedently to the scene described in the picture, among the various characters already encountered by the apostle, many undoubtedly, in their speculations upon Divine subjects, had often imagined a sublimer religion than that commonly acknowledged: such, therefore, would make it their business to hear him again. Others, to whom truth was of less value than the idle amusement of vain disquisition, felt no other motive than curiosity. By far the greater part, however, obstinately bigoted to their particular tenets, and abhorring innovation, regarded him as impious, or a mere babbler: these also wished to hear him again, but with no other than the insidious view, that, by a more regular and explicit profession of his doctrines, he might expose his own absurdities, or render himself obnoxious to the state. The drapery accords with the majesty of the figure; and the light is so managed, especially on the arms and hands, as greatly to assist the energy of the action
"The painter has proceeded, from the warmth of full conviction, through various gradations, to the extremes of malignant prejudice, and invincible bigotry
"In the foreground, on the right, is Dionysius, who is recorded to have embraced the new religion. With the utmost fervor in his countenance, and with a kind of sympathetic action and unconscious eagerness, he advances a step nearer. His eye is fixed on the apostle: he longs to tell him his conversion, already perhaps preceded by conviction wrought in his mind by the reasonings of the sacred teacher on previous occasions, in the synagogue, and in the forum or marketplace. He appears not only touched with the doctrine he receives, but expresses an evident attachment to his instructer: he would become his host and protector
"This figure is altogether admirable. The gracefulness of the drapery and of the hair; the masculine beauty of the features; the perspective drawing of the arms; the life and sentiment of the hands, the right one especially, are inimitable
"Behind is Damaris, mentioned with him as a fellow believer. This is the only female in the composition; but the painter has fully availed himself of the character, in assisting his principle of contrast; an excellence found in all the works of Raphael. Her discreet distance, her modest deportment, her pious and diffident eye, discovering a degree of awe, the decorum and arrangement of her train, all interest the mind in her favor
"Next to these, but at come distance, is a Stoic. The first survey of this figure conveys the nature of his peculiar philosophy - dignity and austerity. Raphael has well understood what he meant in this instance to illustrate. His head is sunk in his breast; his arms are mechanically folded; his eyes, almost shut, glance towards the ground: he is absorbed in reflection. In spite of his stoicism, discomposure and perplexity invade his soul, mixed with a degree of haughty mortification
"Sir Joshua Reynolds has observed that ‘ the same idea is continued through the whole figure, even to the drapery, which is so closely muffled about him that even his hands are not seen;’ and that, ‘ by this happy correspondence between the expression of the countenance and the disposition of the parts, the figure appears to think from head to foot.’
"Behind the Stoic are two young men, well contrasted in expression: anger in the elder, and in the other, youthful pride, half abashed, are finely discriminated
"Beyond, in the same continued half circle with the Stoic, is perhaps exhibited the most astonishing contrast ever imagined; that of inexorable sternness, and complete placidity
"Of the two figures, the first is denominated a Cynic, who, disappointed in his expectation of the ridiculous appearance which he conceived the apostle, when confronted, would make among them, abandons his mind to rage. His formidable forehead concentrates its whole expression: with a fixed frown and threatening eye, he surveys the object of his indignation. He alone would engage to confute him, or punish his temerity. His eager impatience and irritation are not discovered in his features only; he raises his heel from the ground, and leans with a firmer pressure on his crutch, which seems to bend beneath him
"Pass from him to the more polished Epicurean. This figure exhibits perfect repose of body and mind: no passions agitate the one; no action discomposes the other. His hands, judiciously concealed beneath beautiful drapery, shows there can be no possible motion or employment for them. His feet seem to sleep upon the ground. His countenance, which is highly pleasing, and full of natural gentleness, expresses only a smile of pity at the fancied errors of the apostle, mingled with delight derived from his eloquence. He waits, with an inclined head, in passive and serene expectation. If a shrewd intelligence is discovered in his eyes, it is too gentle to disturb the general expression of tranquillity
"Behind are two other young men: the first discovers a degree of superciliousness with his vexation; his companion is more disgusted, and more morose
"These, and the two young figures previously described, are not introduced merely to fill up the group; they may be intended as pupils to the philosophers before them, though by some considered as young Romans, who have introduced themselves from ennui or curiosity
"Beyond is a character in whose mind the force of truth and eloquence appears to have produced conviction; but pride, vanity, or self-interest, impel him to dissemble. His finger, placed upon the upper lip, shows that he has imposed silence upon himself
"In the centre is seated a group from the academy. The skill of Raphael in this instance is eminent. These figures are not only thrown into shade, to prevent their interference with the principal figure; but, from their posture, they contribute to its elevation, and at the same time vary the line of the standing group
"It seems as if the old philosopher in profile, on the left, had offered some observations on the apostle’ s address; and that he was eagerly listening to the reply of his sage friend, in whose features we behold more of the spirit of mild philosophy. The action of his fingers denotes his habit of reasoning, and regularity of argument. The middle figure behind appears to be watching the effect which his remarks would produce
"The action of the young man, pointing to the apostle, characterizes the keen susceptibility and impetuosity of his age. His countenance expresses disgust, approaching to horror. The other young man turns his head round, as though complaining of unreasonable interruption. The drapery of both the front figures in this group is finely drawn: the opening action of the knees in the one is beautifully followed and described by the folds; in the other, the compression, in consequence of the bent attitude, is equally executed; the turn of the head gives grace and variety to the figure
"The head introduced beyond, and rather apart, is intended to break the two answering lines of the dark contour of the apostle’ s drapery, and the building in the background
"In the group placed behind the apostle, the mind is astonished at the new character of composition. The finest light imaginable is thrown upon the sitting figure; and, as necessary, a mass of shade is cast upon the two others
"It is difficult to ascertain what or whom Raphael meant by that corpulent and haughty personage wearing the cap. His expression, however, is evident: malice and vexation are depicted in his countenance; his stride, and the action of his hand, are characteristic of his temperament
"The figure standing behind is supposed to be a magician. His dark hair and beard, which seem to have been neglected, and the keen mysterious gaze of his eye, certainly exhibit a mind addicted to unusual studies. Under him, the only remaining figure is one who listens with malignant attention, as though intending to report every thing. He has the aspect of a spy. His eye is full of danger to the apostle; and he crouches below that he may not be disturbed by communication
"If this figure be considered with reference to Dionysius, it may be remarked that Raphael has not only contrasted his characters, but even the two ends of his picture. By this means the greatest possible force is given to the subject. At the first survey, the subordinate contrasts may escape the eye, but these greater oppositions must have their effect
"When, from this detailed display of the cartoon, the eye again glances over the whole subject, including the dignity of the architecture; the propriety of the statue of Mars, which faces his temple; the happy management of the landscape, with the two conversation figures; the result must be an acknowledgment that in this one effort of art is combined all that is great in drawing, in expression, and in composition."Holloway’ s description of Raphael’ s Cartoon of Paul preaching at Athens.
Calvin: Act 17:24 - -- 24.God, who hath made the world Paul’s drift is to teach what God is. Furthermore, because he hath to deal with profane men, he draweth proofs from...
24.God, who hath made the world Paul’s drift is to teach what God is. Furthermore, because he hath to deal with profane men, he draweth proofs from nature itself; for in vain should he have cited − 291 testimonies of Scripture. I said that this was the holy man’s purpose, to bring the men of Athens unto the true God. For they were persuaded that there was some divinity; only their preposterous religion was to be reformed. Whence we gather, that the world doth go astray through bending crooks and boughts, yea, that it is in a mere labyrinth, so long as there remaineth a confused opinion concerning the nature of God. For this is the true rule of godliness, distinctly and plainly to know who that God whom we worship is. If any man will intreat generally of religion, this must be the first point, that there is some divine power or godhead which men ought to worship. But because that was out of question, Paul descendeth unto the second point, that true God must be distinguished from all vain inventions. So that he beginneth with the definition of God, that he may thence prove how he ought to be worshipped; because the one dependeth upon the other. For whence came so many false worshippings, and such rashness to increase the same oftentimes, save only because all men forged to themselves a God at their pleasure? And nothing is more easy than to corrupt the pure worship of God, when men esteem God after their sense and wit. −
Wherefore, there is nothing more fit to destroy all corrupt worshippings, than to make this beginning, and to show of what sort the nature of God is. Also our Savior Christ reasoneth thus, Joh 4:24, “God is a Spirit.” Therefore he alloweth no other worshippers but such as worship him spiritually. And surely he doth not subtilely dispute of the secret substance [essence] of God; but by his works he declareth which is the profitable knowledge of him. And what doth Paul gather thence, because God is the creator, framer, and Lord of the world? to wit, that he dwelleth not in temples made with hands. For, seeing that it appeareth plainly by the creation of the world, that the righteousness, wisdom, goodness, and power of God doth reach beyond the bounds of heaven and earth; it followeth, that he can be included and shut up within no space of place. −
Notwithstanding this demonstration seemeth to have been in vain, because they might readily have said, that images and pictures were placed in temples to testify God’s presence; and that none was so gross but that he knew that God did fulfill [fill] all things. I answer, that that is true which I said a little before, that idolatry is contrary to itself. The unbelievers said, that they worshipped the gods before their images; but unless they had tied the Godhead and power of God to images, and had hoped − 292 to be holpen thereby, would they have directed their prayers thither? Hereby it came also to pass, that one temple was more holy than another. They ran to Delphos that they might fet [fetch] the oracles of Apollo thence. Minerva had her seat and mansion at Athens. Now we see that Paul doth touch that false opinion, whereby men have always been deceived; because they feigned to themselves a carnal God. −
This is the first entrance into the true knowledge of God, if we go without ourselves, and do not measure him by the capacity of our mind; yea, if we imagine nothing of him according to the understanding of our flesh, − 293 but place him above the world, and distinguish him from creatures. From which sobriety the whole world was always far; because this wickedness is in men, naturally to deform God’s glory with their inventions. For as they be carnal and earthy, they will have one that shall be answerable to their nature. Secondly, after their boldness they fashion him so as they may comprehend him. By such inventions is the sincere and plain knowledge of God corrupt; yea, his truth, as saith Paul, is turned into a lie, ( Rom 1:25.) For whosoever doth not ascend high above the world, he apprehendeth vain shadows and ghosts instead of God. Again, unless we be carried up into heaven with the wings of faith, we must needs vanish away in our own cogitations. And no marvel if the Gentiles were so grossly deluded and deceived, to include God in the elements of the world, after that they had pulled him out of his heavenly throne; seeing that the same befell the Jews, to whom notwithstanding the Lord had showed his spiritual glory. For it is not without cause that Isaiah doth chide them for including God within the walls of the temple, ( Isa 66:1.) And we gather out of Stephen’s sermon, that this vice was common to all ages; which sermon is set down by Luke in − Act 7:49. −
If any man asked the Jews whose grossness the Holy Ghost reproveth, if they thought that God was included in their temple, they would stoutly have denied that they were in any such gross error. But because they did only behold the temple, and did rise no higher in their minds, and trusting the temple, and did boast that God was as it were bound to them, the Spirit doth for good causes reprehend them, for tying him to the temple as If he were a mortal man. For this is true which I said even now, that superstition is contrary to itself, and that it doth vanish away into divers imaginations. Neither have the Papists at this day any defense, saying that wherewith their errors after a sort. In some, superstition doth feign that God dwelleth in temples made with hands, not that it will shut him up as it were in a prison; − 294 but because it doth dream of a carnal (or fleshly) God, and doth attribute a certain power to idols, and doth translate the glory of God unto external shows. −
But if God do not dwell in temples made with hands, ( 2Kg 19:15,) why doth he testify in so many places of Scripture, that he sitteth between the cherubims, and that the temple is his eternal rest? ( Psa 80:1.) I answer, As he was not tied to any place, so he meant nothing less than to tie his people to earthly signs, but rather he cometh down to them that he might lift them up unto himself. Therefore, those men did wickedly abuse the temple and the ark, who did so behold those things that they stayed still upon the earth, and did depart from the spiritual worship of God. Hereby we see that there was great difference between those tokens of God’s presence which men invented to themselves unadvisedly, and those which were ordained by God, because men do always incline downward, that they may lay hold upon [apprehend] God after a carnal manner; but God by the leading of his word doth lift them upward. Only he useth middle signs and tokens, whereby he doth insinuate himself with slow men, − 295 until they may ascend into heaven by degrees (and steps.) −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:25 - -- 25.Neither is he worshipped with man’s hands The same question which was answered of late concerning the temple, may now be objected touching cerem...
25.Neither is he worshipped with man’s hands The same question which was answered of late concerning the temple, may now be objected touching ceremonies. For it seemeth that that may be translated unto the worshippings of the law of Moses, which Paul condemneth in the ceremonies of the Gentiles. But we may readily answer, that the faithful did never properly place the worship of God in ceremonies; but they did only count them helps wherewith they might exercise themselves according to their infirmity. When they did slay beasts, offered bread and drink offerings, light torches and other lights, they knew that godliness was not placed in these things, but being holpen by these, − 296 they did always look unto the spiritual worship of God, and they made account of it alone. And God himself saith plainly in many places, that he doth not pass for any external or visible thing, that ceremonies are of themselves of no importance, and that he is worshipped no otherwise but by faith, a pure conscience, by prayer and thankfulness. What did the Gentiles then? to wit, when they erected images, they offered incense, they set forth plays, and laid their cushions before their idols, they thought they had fulfilled the offices of godliness excellent well. Not only the philosophers, but also the poets, do sometimes deride the folly of the common people, because they did disorderly place the worship of God in the pomp and gorgeousness of ceremonies. That I may omit infinite testimonies, that of Persius is well known: −
“Tell me, ye priests to sacred rites, what profit gold doth bring? The same which Venus’ puppets fine, certes no other thing. Why give not we to gods that which the blear-eyed issue could of great Messiah never give from out their dish of gold? Right justly deem’d a conscience clear, and heavenly thoughts of mind, A breast with mildness such adorn’d, as virtue hath assign’d, Let me in temples offer these, Then sacrifice the gods shall please.” −
And, undoubtedly, the Lord caused profane men to utter such speeches, that they might take away all color of ignorance. But it doth plainly appear, that those who spake thus did straightway slide back again unto common madness; yea, that they did never thoroughly understand what this meant. For though those who pass the common people in wit be enforced to confess that bare ceremonies are in no estimation, yet it is impossible to pull from them this persuasion, but that they will think that they be a part of the divine worship. Therefore, the more diligently they give themselves to such vanities, they do not doubt but that they do the duties of godliness well. Therefore, because all mortal men, from the highest to the lowest, do think that God is pacified with external things, and they will, with their own works, fulfill their duty towards him, that doth Paul refute. There is also a reason added, because, seeing he is Lord of heaven and earth, he needeth nothing, because, seeing that he giveth bread and life to men, he can receive nothing of them again. For what can they bring of their own, who, being destitute of all good things, have nothing but of his free goodness, yea, who are nothing but by his mere grace, who shall forthwith be brought to nought, if he withdraw the Spirit whereby they live? Whereupon it followeth, that they are not only dull, but too proud, if they thrust in themselves to worship God with the works of their own hands. −
For whereas he saith, that alms and the duties of love are sweet-smelling sacrifices, that must be distinguished from the matter which we have now in hand, where Paul doth only intreat of the ceremonies which the unbelievers put in place of the spiritual worship of God. By life and breath is mean the life which men live so long as the soul and body are joined together. Touching the end of the sentence, though some Greek books − 297 agree in this reading, [
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:26 - -- 26.And he hath made of one blood Paul doth now show unto the men of Athens to what end mankind was created, that he may by this means invite and exho...
26.And he hath made of one blood Paul doth now show unto the men of Athens to what end mankind was created, that he may by this means invite and exhort them to consider the end of their life. This is surely filthy unthankfulness of men, seeing they all enjoy the common life, not to consider to what end God hath given them life; and yet this beastly blockishness doth possess the more part, so that do not consider to what end they be placed in the world, neither do they remember the Creator of heaven and earth, whose good things they do devour. Therefore, after that Paul hath intreated of the nature of God, he putteth in this admonition in due season, that men must be very careful to know God, because they be created for the same end, and born for that purpose; for he doth briefly assign unto them this cause of life, to seek God. Again, forasmuch as there was not one kind of religion only in the world, but the Gentiles were distract into divers sects, he telleth them that this variety came from corruption. For to this end, in my judgment, tendeth that when he saith, that all were created of one blood. For consanguinity and the same original ought to have been a bond of mutual consent among them; but it is religion which doth most of all join men together, or cause them to fly one another’s company. Whereupon it followeth, that they be revolted from nature who disagree so much in religion and the worship of God; because, wheresoever they be born, and whatsoever place [clime] of the world they inhabit, they have all one Maker and Father, who must be sought of all men with one consent. And surely neither distance of places, nor bounds of countries, nor diversity of manners, neither any cause of separation among men, doth make God unlike to himself. In sum, he meant to teach that the order of nature was broken, when as religion was pulled in pieces among them, and that that diversity, which is among them, is a testimony that godliness is quite overthrown, because they are fallen away from God the Father of all, upon whom all kindred dependeth. −
To dwell upon the face of the earth Luke doth briefly gather, as he useth to do, the sum of Paul’s sermon; and it is not to be doubted, but that Paul did first show that men are set here as upon a theater, to behold the works of God; and, secondly, that he spake of the providence of God, which doth show forth itself in the whole government of the world. For when he saith, that God appointeth the times ordained before, and the bounds of men’s habitations, his meaning is, that this world is governed by his hand and counsel, and that men’s affairs fall not out by chance, as profane men dream. And so we gather out of a few words of Luke, that Paul did handle most weighty matters. For when he saith that the times were ordained before by him, he doth testify that he had determined, before men were created, what their condition and estate should be. When we see divers changes in the world; when we see realms come to ruin, lands altered, cities destroyed, nations laid waste, we foolishly imagine that either fate or fortune beareth the swing in these matters; but God doth testify in this place by the mouth of Paul, that it was appointed before in his counsel how long he would have the state of every people to continue, and within what bounds he would have them contained. But and if he have appointed them a certain time and appointed the bounds of countries, undoubtedly he hath also set in order the whole course of their life. −
And we must note, that Paul doth attribute to God not only a bare foreknowledge and cold speculation, as some men do indiscreetly, but he placeth the cause of those things which fall out, in his counsel and beck. For he saith not that the times were only foreseen, but that they were appointed and set in such order as pleased him best. And when he addeth also that God had appointed from the beginning those things which he had ordained before his meaning is, that he executeth by the power of his Spirit those things which he hath decreed in his counsel according to that: −
“Our God is in heaven; he hath done whatsoever he would,”
( Psa 115:3.) −
Now, we see, as in a camp, every troop and band hath his appointed place, so men are placed upon earth, that every people may be content with their bounds, and that among these people every particular person may have his mansion. But though ambition have, oftentimes raged, and many, being incensed with wicked lust, have past their bounds, yet the lust of men hath never brought to pass, but that God hath governed all events from out of his holy sanctuary. For though men, by raging upon earth, do seem to assault heaven, that they may overthrow God’s providence, yet they are enforced, whether they will or no, rather to establish the same. Therefore, let us know that the world is so turned over through divers tumults, that God doth at length bring all things unto the end which he hath appointed. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:27 - -- 27.That they might seek God This sentence hath two members; to wit, that it is man’s duty to seek God; secondly, that God himself cometh forth to m...
27.That they might seek God This sentence hath two members; to wit, that it is man’s duty to seek God; secondly, that God himself cometh forth to meet us, and doth show himself by such manifest tokens, that we can have no excuse for our ignorance. Therefore, let us remember that those men do wickedly abuse this life, and that they be unworthy to dwell upon earth, which do not apply their studies to seek him; as if every kind of brute beasts should fall from that inclination which they have naturally, which should for good causes be called monstrous. And, surely, nothing is more absurd, than that men should be ignorant of their Author, who are endued with understanding principally for this use. And we must especially note the goodness of God, in that he doth so familiarly insinuate himself, that even the blind may grope after him. For which cause the blindness of men is more shameful and intolerable, who, in so manifest and evident a manifestation, are touched with no feeling of God’s presence. Whithersoever they cast their eyes upward or downward, they must needs light upon lively and also infinite images of God’s power, wisdom, and goodness. For God hath not darkly shadowed his glory in the creation of the world, but he hath everywhere engraven such manifest marks, that even blind men may know them by groping. Whence we gather that men are not only blind but blockish, when, being helped by such excellent testimonies, they profit nothing. −
Yet here ariseth a question, whether men can naturally come unto the true and merciful − 298 knowledge of God. For Paul doth give us to understand, that their own sluggishness is the cause that they cannot perceive that God is present; because, though they shut their eyes, yet may they grope after him. I answer, that their ignorance and blockishness is mixed with such frowardness, that being void of right judgment, they pass over without understanding all such signs of God’s glory as appear manifestly both in heaven and earth. Yea, seeing that the true knowledge of God is a singular gift of his, and faith (by which alone he is rightly known) cometh only from the illumination of the Spirit, it followeth that our minds cannot pierce so far, having nature only for our guide. Neither doth Paul intreat in this place of the ability of men, but he doth only show that they be without excuse, when as they be so blind in such clear light, as he saith in the first chapter to the Romans, ( Rom 1:20.) Therefore, though men’s senses fail them in seeking out God, yet have they no cloak for their fault, because, though he offer himself to be handled and groped, they continue, notwithstanding, in a quandary; − 299 concerning which thing we have spoken more in the fourteenth chapter, ( Act 14:17.) −
Though he be not far from every one of us To the end he may the more touch the frowardness of men, he saith that God is not to be sought through many crooks, neither need we make any long journey to find him; because every man shall find him in himself, if so be that he will take any heed. By which experience we are convicted that our dullness is not without fault, which we had from the fault of Adam. For though no corner of the world be void of the testimony of God’s glory, yet we need not go without ourselves to lay hold upon him. For he doth affect and move every one of us inwardly with his power in such sort, that our blockishness is like to a monster, in that in feeling him we feel him not. In this respect certain of the philosophers called man the little world, [a microcosm;] because he is above all other creatures a token of God’s glory, replenished with infinite miracles. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:28 - -- 28.For in him I grant that the apostles, according to the Hebrew phrase, do oftentimes take this preposition in for per, or by or through; but ...
28.For in him I grant that the apostles, according to the Hebrew phrase, do oftentimes take this preposition in for per, or by or through; but because this speech, that we live in God, hath greater force, and doth express more, I thought I would not change it; for I do not doubt but that Paul’s meaning is, that we be after a sort contained in God, because he dwelleth in us by his power. And, therefore, God himself doth separate himself from all creatures by this word Jehovah, that we may know that in speaking properly he is alone, and that we have our being in him, inasmuch as by his Spirit he keepeth us in life, and upholdeth us. For the power of the Spirit is spread abroad throughout all parts of the world, that it may preserve them in their state; that he may minister unto the heaven and earth that force and vigor which we see, and motion to all living creatures. Not as brain-sick men do trifle, that all things are full of gods, yea, that stones are gods; but because God doth, by the wonderful power and inspiration of his Spirit, preserve those things which he hath created of nothing. But mention is made in this place properly of men, because Paul said, that they needed not to seek God far, whom they have within them. −
Furthermore, forasmuch as the life of man is more excellent than motion, and motion doth excel essence, [mere existence,] Paul putteth that in the highest place which was the chiefest, that he might go down by steps unto essence or being, thus, We have not only no life but in God, but not so much as moving; yea, no being, which is inferior to both. I say that life hath the pre-eminence in men, because they have not only sense and motion as brute beasts have, but they be endued with reason and understanding. Wherefore, the Scripture doth for good causes give that singular gift which God hath given us, a title and commendation by itself. So in John, when mention is made of the creation of all things, it is added apart, not without cause, that life was the light of men, ( Joh 1:4.) −
Now, we see that all those who know not God know not; because they have God present with them not only in the excellent gifts of the mind, but in their very essence; because it belongeth to God alone to be, all other things have their being in him. Also, we learn out of this place that God did not so create the world once that he did afterward depart from his work; but that it standeth by his power, and that the same God is the governor thereof who was the Creator. We must well think upon this continual comforting and strengthening, that we may remember God every minute. −
Certain of your poets He citeth half a verse out of Aratus, not so much for authority’s sake, as that he may make the men of Athens ashamed; for such sayings of the poets came from no other fountain save only from nature and common reason. Neither is it any marvel if Paul, who spake unto men who were infidels and ignorant of true godliness, do use the testimony of a poet, wherein was extant a confession of that knowledge which is naturally engraven in men’s minds. The Papists take another course. For they so lean to the testimonies of men, that they set them against the oracles of God; and they do not only make Jerome, or Ambrose and the residue of the holy fathers, masters of faith, but they will no less tie us to the stinking [vile] answers of their Popes than if God himself should speak. Yea, that which more s, they have not been afraid to give so great authority to Aristotle that the apostles and prophets were silent in their schools rather than he. −
Now, that I may return unto this sentence which I have in hand, it is not to be doubted but that Aratus spake of Jupiter; neither doth Paul, in applying that unto the true God, which he spake unskillfully of his Jupiter, wrest it unto a contrary sense. For because men have naturally some perseverance of God, − 300 they draw true principles from that fountain. And though so soon as they begin to think upon God, they vanish away in wicked inventions, and so pure seed doth degenerate into corruptions; yet the first general knowledge of God doth nevertheless remain still in them. After this sort, no man of a sound mind can doubt to apply that unto the true God which we read in Virgil touching the reigned and false joy, that All things are full of joy. Yea, when Virgil meant to express the power of God, through error he put in a wrong name. −
As touching the meaning of the words, it may be that Aratus did imagine that there was some parcel of the divinity in men’s minds, as the Manichees did say, that the souls of men are of the nature of God. − 301 So when Virgil saith concerning the world, − The Spirit doth nourish within, and the mind being dispersed through all the joints, doth move your whole huge weight, he doth rather play the philosopher, and subtilely dispute after the manner of Plato, than purely mean that the world is supported by the secret inspiration of God. But this invention ought not to have hindered Paul from retaining a true maxim, though it were corrupt with men’s fables, that men are the generation of God, because by the excellency of nature they resemble some divine thing. This is that which the Scripture teacheth, that we are created after the image and similitude of God, ( Gen 1:27.) The same Scripture teacheth also, in many places, that we be made the sons of God by faith and free adoption when we are engrafted into the body of Christ, and being regenerate by the Spirit, we begin to be new creatures, ( Gal 3:26.) But as it giveth the same Spirit divers names because of his manifold graces, so no marvel if the word sons be diversely taken. All mortal men are called sons in general, because they draw near to God in mind and understanding; but because the image of God is almost blotted out in them, so that there appear scarce any slender lines, [lineaments,] this name is by good right restrained unto the faithful, who having the Spirit of adoption given them, resemble their heavenly Father in the light of reason, in righteousness and holiness. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:29 - -- 29.Therefore seeing that He gathereth that God cannot be figured or resembled by any graven image forasmuch as he would have his image extant in us. ...
29.Therefore seeing that He gathereth that God cannot be figured or resembled by any graven image forasmuch as he would have his image extant in us. For the soul wherein the image of God is properly engraven cannot be painted; therefore it is a thing more absurd to go about to paint God. Now, we see what great injury they do to God which give him a bodily shape; when as man’s soul, which doth scarce resemble a small sparkle of the infinite glory of God, cannot be expressed in any bodily shape. −
Furthermore, forasmuch as it is certain that Paul doth in this place inveigh against the common superstition of all the Gentiles, because they would worship God under bodily shapes, we must hold this general doctrine that God is falsely and wickedly transfigured, and that his truth is turned into a lie so often as his Majesty is represented by any visible shape; as the same Paul teacheth in the first chapter to the Romans, ( Rom 1:23.) And though the idolaters of all times wanted not their cloaks and colors, yet that was not without cause always objected to them by the prophets which Paul doth now object that God is made like to wood, or stone or gold, when there is any image made to him of dead and corruptible matter. The Gentiles used images that, according to their rudeness, they might better conceive that God was nigh unto them. But seeing that God doth far surpass the capacity of our mind, whosoever attempteth with his mind to comprehend him, he deformeth and disfigureth his glory with a wicked and false imagination. Wherefore, it is wickedness to imagine anything of him according to our own sense. Again, that which worse is, it appeareth plainly that men erect pictures and images to God for no other cause, save only because they conceive some carnal thing of him, wherein he is blasphemed. −
The Papists also are at this day no whit more excusable. For what colors soever they invent to paint and color those images, whereby they go about to express God, yet because they be enwrapped in the same error, wherein the men of old time were entangled, they be urged with the of the prophets. And that the heathen did use the same excuses in times past, wherewith the Papists go about to cover themselves at this day, it is well known out of their own books. Therefore, the prophets do not escape the mocks of certain, as if they laid too great grossness to their charge, yea, burthen them with false accusations; but when all things are well weighed, those who will judge rightly shall find, that whatsoever starting holes [evasions] even the most witty men have sought, yet were they taken with this madness, that God is well pleased with the sacrifice done before images. Whereas we, with Erasmus, translate it numen, Luke putteth [
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:30 - -- 30.And the times of this ignorance Because that is commonly thought to be good which hath been used of long time, and is approved by the common conse...
30.And the times of this ignorance Because that is commonly thought to be good which hath been used of long time, and is approved by the common consent of all men; it might have been objected to Paul, why dost thou disannul those things which have been received, and used continually since the beginning of the world? and whom canst thou persuade that the whole world hath been deceived so long? as is no kind of abomination so filthy, which the Papists do not think to be well fortified with this buckler. Paul preventeth − 302 this question; showing that men went astray so long therefore, because God did not reach out his hand from heaven, that he might bring them back again into the way. It may seem an inconvenient [a strange] thing, that men endued with reason and judgment should err so grossly and filthily in a most weighty matter. But Paul’s meaning is, that men do never make an end of erring, until God do help them. And now he assigneth no other cause why he did not redress this any sooner, save only his good pleasure. −
And assuredly we be not able to comprehend the reason why God did at a sudden set up the light of his doctrine, when he suffered men to walk in darkness four thousand years; at least seeing the Scripture doth conceal it, let us here make more account of sobriety than of preposterous wisdom. For they go about to bring God within bounds, which is a most unseemly thing, and contrary to nature herself, whosoever they be that will not suffer him to speak or hold his peace at his pleasure. Again, those that will not be content with his wisdom and secret counsel, must needs murmur against Paul, who teacheth manifestly that ignorance did reign in the world, so long as it pleased God to wink at it. Other some interpret it otherwise, that God did spare ignorance, as if he did wink, being unwilling to punish it; but that surmise is altogether contrary to Paul’s meaning and purpose, who meant not to lessen man’s fault, but to magnify the grace of God which did appear at a sudden, and it is proved to be false out of other places, because those who have sinned without law shall notwithstanding perish without law, ( Rom 2:12.) −
In some, Paul’s words carry with them this meaning only, that men were set upon blindness, until God did reveal himself unto them; and that we ought not too curiously and boldly to demand and require the cause why he put away darkness no sooner; but that whatsoever pleased him ought seem to us right and equal without making any more ado. For though this be a hard speech that men were miserably deceived long time, whilst that God made as though he saw it not, yet must we be content with, and stay ourselves upon his providence. And if at any time there come upon us a vain and perverse desire to know more than is meet for us, let us straightway call to mind that which Paul teacheth in many places, that it was a mystery hid since the beginning of the world, in that the light of the gospel did appear to the Gentiles at a sudden, ( Rom 16:25; Eph 3:9;) and that this is a token of the manifold wisdom of God, which swalloweth up all the senses of men. Again, let us remember that it doth not lessen the fault of men, because God would not heal their errors; forasmuch as their own conscience shall always hold them convict, that they cannot escape just damnation. And Paul (not that he might lay the fault and blame upon God, but that he might cut off occasion of curious and hurtful questions) said, that the world did err whilst God did wink. And hereby we learn how reverently we ought to think of God’s providence, lest any man should be so bold, as man’s nature is proud, to demand a reason of God of his works. −
Furthermore, this admonition is no less profitable for us than for the men of that time. The enemies of the gospel, when it beginneth to spring again, count it a great absurdity that God did suffer men to go astray so long under the apostasy of the Pope, as if (though there appear no reason) it were not as lawful for him now to wink at men’s ignorance as in times past. And we must principally note to what end he saith this; to wit, that the ignorance of former times may not hinder us from obeying God without delay when he speaketh. Most men think that they have a fair color for their error, so they have their fathers to keep them company, or so they get some patronage or defense by long custom; yea, they would willingly creep out here, − 303 that they may not obey the word of God. But Paul saith, that we not fet [seek] an excuse from our fathers’ ignorance when God speaketh unto us; because, though they be not guiltless before God, yet our sluggishness is more intolerable if we be blind at noonday, and lie as deaf, or as if we were asleep, when the trumpet of the gospel doth sound. − 304 −
Now he willeth all men In these words Paul teacheth that we must give ear to God so soon as he speaketh, as it is written, “Today, if ye will hear his voice harden not your hearts,” ( Psa 95:7; Heb 3:7.) For the stubbornness of those men is without excuse, who foreslow [neglect] this opportunity when God doth gently call them unto him. Also, we gather out of this place to what end the gospel is preached, to wit, that God may gather us to himself from the former errors of our life. Therefore, so oft as the voice of the gospel doth sound in our ears, let us know that God doth exhort us unto repentance. We must also note that he attributeth to God the person of the speaker, though he do it by man. For otherwise the gospel hath not so full authority as the heavenly truth deserveth, save only when our faith doth look unto him who is the governor of the prophetical function, and doth depend upon his mouth. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:31 - -- 31.Because he hath appointed a day He maketh mention of the last judgment, that he may awake them out of their dream. For we know how hard a matter i...
31.Because he hath appointed a day He maketh mention of the last judgment, that he may awake them out of their dream. For we know how hard a matter it is for men to deny themselves. Therefore, they must be violently enforced unto repentance, which cannot be done better than when they be cited to appear before God’s judgment-seat, and that fearful judgment is set before them, which they may neither despise nor escape. Therefore, let us remember that the doctrine of repentance doth then take place, when men, who would naturally desire to flatter themselves, are awaked with fear of God’s judgment and that none are fit teachers of the gospel but those who are the criers or apparitors of the highest Judge, who bring those who are to come the Judge to plead their cause, and denounce the judgment hanging over their heads, even as if it were in their own hand. Neither is this added in vain, in righteousness, or righteously. For though all men in the world confess that God is a just Judge, yet we see how they, for the most part, pamper and flatter themselves; for they will not suffer God to demand an account farther than their knowledge and understanding doth reach. Therefore, Paul’s meaning is, that men do profit themselves nothing by vain flattery; because they shall not prejudice God’s justice by this means, which showeth that all that is an abomination before God which seemeth goodly in the sight of men, because he will not follow the decrees of men, but that form which himself hath appointed. −
By the man whom he hath appointed It is not to be doubted but that Paul spake more largely concerning Christ, that the Athenians might know that he is the Son of God, by whom salvation was brought to the world, and who had all power given him in heaven and earth; otherwise this speech, which we read here, should have had but small force to persuade. But Luke thought it sufficient to gather the sum of the sermon briefly. Yet is it to be thought that Paul spake first concerning the grace of Christ and that he did first preach him to be the Redeemer of men, before he made him a Judge. But because Christ is oftentimes contemned, when he offereth himself to be a Redeemer, Paul denounceth that he will once sharply punish such wicked contempt, because the whole world must be judged by him. The word [
The will of God alone ought to be so reverenced among us, that every man for himself subscribe to his decrees without delay. Because the cloak and color of ignorance useth oftentimes to be objected, therefore Paul saith plainly, that Christ was by his resurrection openly showed to be the Judge of the world, and that that was revealed to the eyes of men, which God had before determined with himself concerning him. For that point of doctrine, which Luke toucheth briefly in few words, was handled by Paul at large. He said not only in a word that Christ rose from death, but he did also intreat of the power of his resurrection as was meet. For to what end did Christ rise, but that he might be the first fruits of those which rise again? ( 1Co 15:23.) And to what end shall we rise again, but either to life or death? Whereupon it followeth, that Christ by his resurrection is declared and proved to be the Judge of the world. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:32 - -- 32.Some mocked By this we see how great the carelessness of men is, whom neither the tribunal-seat of God, nor the majesty of the highest [supreme] J...
32.Some mocked By this we see how great the carelessness of men is, whom neither the tribunal-seat of God, nor the majesty of the highest [supreme] Judge, doth make afraid, ( Act 26:23.) We have said that this is a most sharp prick, wherewith men’s minds are pricked forward to fear God, when his judgment is set before their eyes; but there is such unspeakable hardness in the contemners, that they are not afraid to count that a fable or lie which is spoken concerning the giving of an account of our life once. − 305 Notwithstanding, there is no cause why the ministers of the gospel should omit. − 306 the preaching of the judgment which is enjoined them. Though the wicked do laugh and mock, yet this doctrine, which they go about to make of none effect, shall so gird them, that they shall at length perceive that they have striven in vain with their snare. − 307 And no marvel if this point of Paul’s doctrine were derided at Athens; for it is a mystery hid from men’s minds, whereon the chiefest philosophers did never think, neither can we otherwise comprehend it, than when we lift up the eyes of faith unto the infinite power of God. And yet Paul’s sermon was not altogether without fruit; because there were some of the hearers which were desirous to profit and go forward. For when they say that they will hear him again, their meaning is, that though they were not as yet thoroughly persuaded, yet had they some taste, which did provoke them to be desirous to profit. Surely this desire was contrary to loathsomeness. − 308 −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 17:34 - -- 34.Among whom was also Dionysius Seeing that Luke doth name one man and one woman only, it appeareth that there was but a small number of those which...
34.Among whom was also Dionysius Seeing that Luke doth name one man and one woman only, it appeareth that there was but a small number of those which believed at the first. For those other of whom he maketh mention remained indifferent; because they did neither wholly despise Paul’s doctrine, neither were they so thoroughly touched, that they joined themselves unto him that they might be his scholars. Luke maketh mention of Dionysius above the rest, because he was in no small authority among his citizens. Therefore, it is likely that Damaris was also a woman of some renown, [rank.] −
Furthermore, it is ridiculous in that the Papists [have] made of a judge an astrologer. But this is to be imputed partly to their ignorance, partly to their boldness, − 309 who, seeing they knew not what Areopagus or Mars’ Street meant, took to themselves liberty to feign whatsoever they would. And their rudeness is too gross, who ascribe the books of the heavenly and ecclesiastical hierarchy, and of the names of God, to this Dionysius. For the heavenly hierarchy is stuffed not only with many doltish and monkish trifles, but also with many absurd inventions, and wicked speculations. And the books of the Ecclesiastical Hierarchy do themselves declare that they were made many years after, when as the purity of Christianity was corrupt with an huge heap of ceremonies. As for the book of the names of God, though it have in it some things which are not altogether to be despised, yet it doth rather breathe out subtilties than sound godliness.
Defender: Act 17:24 - -- This message to the pagan intellectuals at Athens can be considered typical of Paul's method with people who did not already know and respect the Scri...
This message to the pagan intellectuals at Athens can be considered typical of Paul's method with people who did not already know and respect the Scriptures, just as his message in the synagogue at Pisidian Antioch can be considered typical of his approach to those who did (Acts 13:16-41). In the one case, he began with God's witness in creation, in the other with Scriptures; in both cases, he ended with Christ and the resurrection, urging his hearers to believe.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:24 - -- Athens was filled with beautiful temples, monuments and images, but to Paul they were merely depressing symbols of the city's idolatry."
Athens was filled with beautiful temples, monuments and images, but to Paul they were merely depressing symbols of the city's idolatry."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:25 - -- This is the only occurrence of "breath" in the New Testament. The Greek word pnoe occurs elsewhere only in Act 2:2, speaking of the Holy Spirit coming...
This is the only occurrence of "breath" in the New Testament. The Greek word
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:26 - -- The concept of "race" has no basis in Scripture; all men are descended from Adam, through Noah, and thus all are members of only one race - the human ...
The concept of "race" has no basis in Scripture; all men are descended from Adam, through Noah, and thus all are members of only one race - the human race. The term "race," as ordinarily used, is strictly an evolutionary concept, with "race" understood as a sub-species in the process of evolving into a new species. There is no observational scientific evidence for such evolutionary transformations, among either men or animals.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:26 - -- In ways unknown, yet real, God raises nations up and puts them down, as He will in accordance with their faithfulness to His respective purposes for t...
In ways unknown, yet real, God raises nations up and puts them down, as He will in accordance with their faithfulness to His respective purposes for them (Deu 32:7-9; Dan 2:20, Dan 2:21). "Blessed is the nation whose God is the Lord" (Psa 33:12). "The wicked shall be turned into hell, and all the nations that forget God" (Psa 9:17)."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:28 - -- The God of creation sustains the very life of every person, even those who don't believe He exists, so that "he [is] not far from every one of us" (Ac...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:28 - -- Paul here seems to be referring to Epimenides, Aratus and Cleanthes, each of whom seemed to have had some insight, however attained, into the fact tha...
Paul here seems to be referring to Epimenides, Aratus and Cleanthes, each of whom seemed to have had some insight, however attained, into the fact that one supreme God had created all men. We are all the "offspring" (Greek
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:29 - -- This is the first of three New Testament references to the "Godhead" (Rom 1:20; Col 2:9). Each translates from a slightly different Greek noun, but al...
This is the first of three New Testament references to the "Godhead" (Rom 1:20; Col 2:9). Each translates from a slightly different Greek noun, but all refer essentially to the "Godhead" of God - that is, the nature or structure of God, to God as He has revealed Himself. Since He has revealed Himself as a triune God (Father, Son, Spirit), the term has commonly been used to refer to the Trinity. In this verse, we are told that God can never be represented by an image or mode which man can make, either with his hands or his mind. However, what man cannot do, God has done. That is, He has constructed a marvelous model of the Godhead in His creation (see notes on Rom 1:20)."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:30 - -- Now that God has revealed Himself, not only in creation but also in His human incarnation in the Lord Jesus, He is no longer dealing mainly with just ...
Now that God has revealed Himself, not only in creation but also in His human incarnation in the Lord Jesus, He is no longer dealing mainly with just one nation. The gospel of salvation is for all men, and all must "repent" (that is, "change their minds") concerning the true God and their responsibility before Him."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:31 - -- God, who created all men, must be the Judge of all men, and "the Judge of all the earth" will certainly "do right" (Gen 18:25). And since God both "cr...
God, who created all men, must be the Judge of all men, and "the Judge of all the earth" will certainly "do right" (Gen 18:25). And since God both "created all things by Jesus Christ" (Eph 3:9), and has also "made peace through the blood of his cross, by him to reconcile all things unto himself" (Col 1:20), it is appropriate that "He shall judge" all things by Christ (Joh 5:22, Joh 5:27; Mat 25:31).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:31 - -- Death has always been man's greatest, and finally victorious, enemy (1Co 15:26), and only the Creator of life, the Judge who imposed the sentence of d...
Death has always been man's greatest, and finally victorious, enemy (1Co 15:26), and only the Creator of life, the Judge who imposed the sentence of death because of sin (Gen 3:17-20), can conquer death. The founders and leaders of all other religions and philosophies eventually die, but Jesus Christ is alive! His tomb is empty, and He has ascended in His resurrection body to the Father in heaven. His bodily resurrection, which is the best-proved fact of biblical history, is the certain assurance that He is the Creator and Judge of all."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:32 - -- The response is typical. Whenever one preaches or witnesses of the creation and resurrection to unbelievers, especially to pagan evolutionists such as...
The response is typical. Whenever one preaches or witnesses of the creation and resurrection to unbelievers, especially to pagan evolutionists such as the Stoics and Epicureans, many will ridicule, some will defer judgment, and some will believe. The same is true, for that matter, when one witnesses to those monotheists (Jews, Muslims) who believe in a Creator but refuse to acknowledge that He must also be the Redeemer."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Defender: Act 17:34 - -- This term probably means that Dionysius was a member of the official council hearing Paul at the Areopagus ("hill of Ares" tribunal)."
This term probably means that Dionysius was a member of the official council hearing Paul at the Areopagus ("hill of Ares" tribunal)."
TSK: Act 17:24 - -- that made : Act 17:26-28, Act 4:24, Act 14:15; Psa 146:5; Isa 40:12, Isa 40:28, Isa 45:18; Jer 10:11, Jer 32:17; Zec 12:1; Joh 1:1; Heb 1:2, Heb 3:4
s...
that made : Act 17:26-28, Act 4:24, Act 14:15; Psa 146:5; Isa 40:12, Isa 40:28, Isa 45:18; Jer 10:11, Jer 32:17; Zec 12:1; Joh 1:1; Heb 1:2, Heb 3:4
seeing : Gen 14:19, Gen 14:22; 2Ki 19:15; Psa 24:1, Psa 115:16, Psa 148:13; Jer 23:24; Dan 4:35; Mat 5:34, Mat 11:25; Luk 10:21; Rev 20:11
dwelleth : Act 7:48; 1Ki 8:27; 2Ch 2:6, 2Ch 6:18; Isa 66:1; Joh 4:22, Joh 4:23
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:25 - -- is : Job 22:2, Job 35:6, Job 35:7; Psa 16:2, Psa 50:8-13; Jer 7:20-23; Amo 5:21-23; Mat 9:13
seeing : Act 17:28, Act 14:17; Gen 2:7; Num 16:22, Num 27...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:26 - -- hath made : Gen 3:20, Gen 9:19; Mal 2:10; Rom 5:12-19; 1Co 15:22, 1Co 15:47
hath determined : Act 15:18; Deu 32:7, Deu 32:8; Job 14:5; Psa 31:15; Isa ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:27 - -- they : Act 15:17; Psa 19:1-6; Rom 1:20, Rom 2:4
he be : Act 14:17; 1Ki 8:27; Psa 139:1-13; Jer 23:23, Jer 23:24
they : Act 15:17; Psa 19:1-6; Rom 1:20, Rom 2:4
he be : Act 14:17; 1Ki 8:27; Psa 139:1-13; Jer 23:23, Jer 23:24
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:28 - -- in him : 1Sa 25:29; Job 12:10; Psa 36:9, Psa 66:9; Luk 20:38; Joh 5:26, Joh 11:25; Col 1:17; Heb 1:3
as : Tit 1:12
we are : Luk 3:38; Heb 12:9
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:29 - -- we ought : Psa 94:7-9, Psa 106:20, Psa 115:4-8; Isa 40:12-18, Isa 44:9-20; Hab 2:19, Hab 2:20; Rom 1:20-23
graven : Exo 20:4, Exo 32:4; Isa 46:5, Isa ...
we ought : Psa 94:7-9, Psa 106:20, Psa 115:4-8; Isa 40:12-18, Isa 44:9-20; Hab 2:19, Hab 2:20; Rom 1:20-23
graven : Exo 20:4, Exo 32:4; Isa 46:5, Isa 46:6; Jer 10:4-10
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:30 - -- the times : Act 14:16; Psa 50:21; Rom 1:28, Rom 3:23, Rom 3:25
but : Act 3:19, Act 11:18, Act 20:21, Act 26:17-20; Mat 3:2, Mat 4:17; Mar 6:12; Luk 13...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:31 - -- he hath appointed : Act 10:42; Matt. 25:31-46; Joh 5:22, Joh 5:23; Rom 2:5, Rom 2:16, Rom 14:9, Rom 14:10; 1Co 4:5; 2Co 5:10; 2Ti 4:1; 2Pe 3:7; Jud 1:...
he hath appointed : Act 10:42; Matt. 25:31-46; Joh 5:22, Joh 5:23; Rom 2:5, Rom 2:16, Rom 14:9, Rom 14:10; 1Co 4:5; 2Co 5:10; 2Ti 4:1; 2Pe 3:7; Jud 1:14, Jud 1:15
given assurance : or, offered faith
in that : Act 17:18, Act 2:23, Act 2:24, Act 2:32, Act 3:15, Act 3:16, Act 4:10, Act 5:30-32, Act 10:39-41, Act 13:30,Act 13:31; Luk 24:46-48; 1Co 15:3-8
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:32 - -- some : Act 17:18, Act 2:13, Act 13:41, Act 25:19, Act 26:8, Act 26:24, Act 26:25; Gen 19:14; 2Ch 30:9-11, 2Ch 36:16; Luk 22:63, Luk 23:11, Luk 23:36; ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 17:34 - -- certain : Act 17:4, Act 13:48; Isa 55:10-11; Mat 20:16; Rom 11:5, Rom 11:6
the Areopagite : Act 17:19; Joh 7:48-52, Joh 19:38-42; Phi 4:22
certain : Act 17:4, Act 13:48; Isa 55:10-11; Mat 20:16; Rom 11:5, Rom 11:6
the Areopagite : Act 17:19; Joh 7:48-52, Joh 19:38-42; Phi 4:22
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Act 17:24 - -- God that made the world - The main object of this discourse of Paul is to convince them of the folly of idolatry Act 17:29, and thus to lead th...
God that made the world - The main object of this discourse of Paul is to convince them of the folly of idolatry Act 17:29, and thus to lead them to repentance. For this purpose he commences with a statement of the true doctrine respecting God as the Creator of all things. We may observe here:
(1) That he speaks here of God as the Creator of the world, thus opposing indirectly their opinions that there were many gods.
\caps1 (2) h\caps0 e speaks of him as the Creator of the world, and thus opposes the opinion that matter was eternal; that all things were controlled by Fate; and that God could be confined to temples. The Epicureans held that matter was eternal, and that the world was formed by a fortuitous concourse of atoms. To this opinion Paul opposed the doctrine that all things were made by one God. Compare Act 14:15.
Seeing that ... - Greek: "He being Lord of heaven and earth."
Lord of heaven and earth - Proprietor and Ruler of heaven and earth. It is highly absurd, therefore, to suppose that he who is present in heaven and in earth at the same time, and who rules over all, should be confined to a temple of an earthly structure, or dependent on man for anything.
Dwelleth not ... - See the notes on Act 7:48.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:25 - -- Neither is worshipped with men’ s hands - The word here rendered "worshipped"( θεραπέυεται therapeuetai ) denotes to "ser...
Neither is worshipped with men’ s hands - The word here rendered "worshipped"(
For every beast of the forest is mine;
And the cattle upon a thousand hills.
I know all the fowls of the mountain;
And the wild beasts of the field are mine.
If I were hungry, I would not tell thee;
For the world is mine, and the fulness thereof.
Seeing he giveth - Greek: he having given to all, etc.
Life - He is the source of life, and therefore he cannot be dependent on that life which he has himself imparted.
And breath - The power of breathing, by which life is sustained. He not only originally gave life, but he gives it at each moment; he gives the power of drawing each breath by which life is supported. It is possible that the phrase "life and breath may be the figure hendyades, by which one thing is expressed by two words. It is highly probable that Paul here had reference to Gen 2:7; "And the Lord God breathed into his nostrils the breath of life."The same idea occurs in Job 12:10;
In whose hand is the life (margin) of every living thing;
And the breath of all mankind.
And all things - All things necessary to sustain life. We may see here how dependent man is on God. There can be no more absolute dependence than that for every breath. How easy it would be for God to suspend our breathing! How incessant the care, how unceasing the providence, by which, whether we sleep or wake - whether we remember or forget him, he heaves our chest, fills our lungs, restores the vitality of our blood, and infuses vigor into our frame! Compare the notes on Rom 11:36.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:26 - -- And hath made of one blood - All the families of mankind are descended from one origin or stock. However different their complexion, features, ...
And hath made of one blood - All the families of mankind are descended from one origin or stock. However different their complexion, features, or language, yet they are derived from a common parent. The word blood is often used to denote "race, stock, kindred."This passage affirms that all the human family are descended from the same ancestor; and that, consequently, all the variety of complexion, etc., is to be traced to some other cause than that they were originally different races created. See Gen. 1; compare Mal 2:10. The design of the apostle in this affirmation was probably to convince the Greeks that he regarded them all as brethren; that, although he was a Jew, yet he was not enslaved to any narrow notions or prejudices in reference to other people. It follows from the truth here stated that no one nation, and no individual, can claim any pre-eminence over others in virtue of birth or blood. All are in this respect equal; and the whole human family, however they may differ in complexion, customs, and laws, are to be regarded and treated as brethren. It follows, also, that no one part of the race has a right to enslave or oppress any other part, on account of difference of complexion. No one has a right because:
He finds his fellow guilty of a skin
Not colored like his own; and having power
T’ enforce the wrong, for such a worthy cause to
Doom and devote him as his lawful prey.
For to dwell ... - To cultivate and until the earth. This was the original command Gen 1:28; and God, by his providence, has so ordered it that the descendants of one family have found their way to all lands, and have become adapted to the climate where he has placed them.
And hath determined - Greek:
The times before appointed - This evidently refers to the dispersion and migration of nations. And it means that God had, in his plan, fixed the times when each country should be settled, and the rise, the prosperity, and the fall of each nation. The different continents and islands have not, therefore, been settled by chance, but by a wise rule, and in accordance with God’ s arrangement and design.
And the bounds of their habitation - Their limits and boundaries as a people. By customs, laws, inclinations, and habits he has fixed the boundaries of their habitations, and disposed them to dwell there. We may learn:
(1) That the revolutions and changes of nations are under the direction of infinite wisdom;
(2) That people should not be restless and dissatisfied with the place where God has located them;
(3) That God has given sufficient limits to all, so that it is not needful to invade others; and,
(4) That wars of conquest are evil.
God has given to people their places of abode, and we have no right to disturb those abodes, or to attempt to displace them in a violent manner. This strain of remark by the apostle was also opposed to all the notions of the Epicurean philosophers, and yet so obviously true and just that they could not gainsay or resist it.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:27 - -- That they should seek the Lord - Greek: to seek the Lord. The design of thus placing them on the earth - of gang them their habitation among hi...
That they should seek the Lord - Greek: to seek the Lord. The design of thus placing them on the earth - of gang them their habitation among his works - was, that they should contemplate his wisdom in his works, and thus come to a knowledge of his existence and character. All nations, though living in different regions and climates, have thus the opportunity of becoming acquainted with God, Rom 1:19-20. The fact that the nations did not thus learn the character of the true God shows their great stupidity and wickedness. The design of Paul in this was doubtless to reprove the idolatry of the Athenians. The argument is this: "God has given to each nation its proper opportunity to learn his character. Idolatry, therefore, is folly and wickedness, since it is possible to find out the existence of the one God from his works."
If haply -
They might feel after him - The word used here
And find him - Find the proofs of his existence. Become acquainted with his perfections and laws.
Though he be not far ... - This seems to be stated by the apostle to show that it was possible to find him; and that even those who were without a revelation need not despair of becoming acquainted with his existence and perfections. He is near to us:
(1) Because the proofs of his existence and power are round about us everywhere, Psa 19:1-6.
\caps1 (2) b\caps0 ecause he fills all things in heaven and earth by his essential presence, Psa 139:7-10; Jer 23:23-24; Amo 9:2-4; 1Ki 8:27. We should learn then:
(1) To be afraid of sin. God is present with us, and sees all.
\caps1 (2) h\caps0 e can protect the righteous. He is always with them.
\caps1 (3) h\caps0 e can detect and punish the wicked. He sees all their plans and thoughts, and records all their doings.
\caps1 (4) w\caps0 e should seek him continually. It is the design for which he has made us; and he has given us abundant opportunities to learn his existence and perfections.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:28 - -- For in him we live - The expression "in him"evidently means by him; by his originally forming us, and continually sustaining us. No words can b...
For in him we live - The expression "in him"evidently means by him; by his originally forming us, and continually sustaining us. No words can better express our constant dependence on God. He is the original fountain of life, and he upholds us each moment. A similar sentiment is found in Plautus (5, 4,14): "O Jupiter, who dost cherish and nourish the race of man; by whom we live, and with whom is the hope of the life of all men"(Kuinoel). It does not appear, however, that Paul designed this as a quotation; yet he doubtless intended to state a sentiment with which they were familiar, and with which they would agree.
And move -
And have our being -
As certain also - As some. The sentiment which he quotes was found substantially in several Greek poets.
Of your own poets - He does not refer particularly here to poets of Athens, but to Greek poets who had written in their language.
For we are also his offspring - This precise expression is found in Aratus ("Phaenom.,"v. 5), and in Cleanthus in a hymn to Jupiter. Substantially the same sentiment is found in several other Greek poets. Aratus was a Greek poet of Cilicia the native place of Paul, and flourished about 277 years before Christ. As Paul was a native of the same country it is highly probable he was acquainted with his writings. Aratus passed much of his time at the court of Antigonus Gonatas, king of Macedonia. His principal work was the "Phoenomena,"which is here quoted, and was so highly esteemed in Greece that many learned men wrote commentaries on it. The sentiment here quoted was directly at variance with the views of the Epicureans; and it is proof of Paul’ s address and skill, as well as his acquaintance with his auditors and with the Greek poets, that he was able to adduce a sentiment so directly in point, and that had the concurrent testimony of so many of the Greeks themselves. It is one instance among thousands where an acquaintance with profane learning may be of use to a minister of the gospel.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:29 - -- Forasmuch then - Admitting or assuming this to be true. The argument which follows is drawn from the concessions of their own writers. We ...
Forasmuch then - Admitting or assuming this to be true. The argument which follows is drawn from the concessions of their own writers.
We ought not to think - It is absurd to suppose. The argument of the apostle is this: "Since we are formed by God; since we are like him, living and intelligent beings; since we are more excellent in our nature than the most precious and ingenious works of art, it is absurd to suppose that the original source of our existence can be like gold, and silver, and stone. Man himself is far more excellent than an image of wood and stone; how much more excellent still must be the great Fountain and Source of all our wisdom and intelligence."See this thought pursued at length in Isa 40:18-23.
The Godhead - The divinity (
Is like unto gold ... - All these things were used in making images or statues of the gods. It is absurd to think that the source of all life and intelligence resembles a lifeless block of wood or stone. Even degraded pagan, one would think, might see the force of an argument like this.
Graven - Sculptured; made into an image.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:30 - -- And the times of this ignorance - The long period when people were ignorant of the true God, and when they worshipped stocks and stones. Paul h...
And the times of this ignorance - The long period when people were ignorant of the true God, and when they worshipped stocks and stones. Paul here refers to the times preceding the gospel.
God winked at -
But now commandeth - By the gospel, Luk 24:47.
All men - Not Jews only, who had been favored with special privileges, but all nations. The barrier was broken down, and the call to repentance was sent abroad into all the earth.
To repent - To exercise sorrow for their sins, and to forsake them. If God commands all people to repent, we may observe:
(1) That it is their duty to do it. There is no higher obligation than to obey the command of God.
\caps1 (2) i\caps0 t can be done. God would not command an impossibility.
\caps1 (3) i\caps0 t is binding on all. The rich, the learned, the great, the frivolous, are as much bound as the beggar and the slave.
\caps1 (4) i\caps0 t must be done, or the soul lost. It is not safe to neglect a plain Law of God. It will not be well to die reflecting that we have all our life despised his commands.
\caps1 (5) w\caps0 e should send the gospel to the pagan. God calls on the nations to repent, and to be saved. It is the duty of Christians to make known to them the command, and to invite them to the blessings of pardon and heaven.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:31 - -- Because he hath appointed a day - This is given as a reason why God commands people to repent. They must be judged; and if they are not peniten...
Because he hath appointed a day - This is given as a reason why God commands people to repent. They must be judged; and if they are not penitent and pardoned, they must be condemned. See the notes on Rom 2:16.
Judge the world - The whole world - Jews and Gentiles.
In righteousness - According to the principles of strict justice.
Whom he hath ordained - Or whom he has constituted or appointed as judge. See the Act 10:42 notes; Joh 5:25 notes.
Hath given assurance - Has afforded evidence of this. That evidence consists:
(1) In the fact that Jesus declared that he would judge the nations Joh 5:25-26; Matt. 25; and,
(2) God confirmed the truth of his declarations by raising him from the dead, or gave his sanction to what the Lord Jesus had said, for God would nor work a miracle in favor of an impostor.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:32 - -- Some mocked - Some of the philosophers derided him. The doctrine of the resurrection of the dead was believed by none of the Greeks; it seemed ...
Some mocked - Some of the philosophers derided him. The doctrine of the resurrection of the dead was believed by none of the Greeks; it seemed incredible; and they regarded it as so absurd as not to admit of an argument, It has nor been uncommon for even professed philosophers to mock at the doctrines of religion, and to meet the arguments of Christianity with a sneer. The Epicureans particularly would be likely to deride this, as they denied altogether any future state. It is not improbable that this derision by the Epicureans produced such a disturbance as to break off Paul’ s discourse, as that of Stephen had been by the clamor of the Jews, Act 7:54.
And others said - Probably some of the Stoics. The doctrine of a future state was not denied by them; and the fact, affirmed by Paul, that one had been raised up from the dead, would appear more plausible to them, and it might be a matter worth inquiry to ascertain whether the alleged fact did not furnish a new argument for their views. They therefore proposed to examine this further at some future time. That the inquiry was prosecuted any further does not appear probable, for:
(1) No church was organized at Athens.
\caps1 (2) t\caps0 here is no account of any future interview with Paul.
\caps1 (3) h\caps0 e departed almost immediately from them, Act 18:1. People who defer inquiry on the subject of religion seldom find the favorable period arrive. Those who propose to examine its doctrines at a future time often do it to avoid the inconvenience of becoming Christians now, and as a plausible and easy way of rejecting the gospel altogether, without appearing to be rude, or to give offence.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:33 - -- So Paul departed - Seeing there was little hope of saving them. It was not his custom to labor long in a barren field, or to preach where there...
So Paul departed - Seeing there was little hope of saving them. It was not his custom to labor long in a barren field, or to preach where there was no prospect of success.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 17:34 - -- Clave unto him - Adhered to him firmly; embraced the Christian religion. Dionysius - Nothing more is certainly known of this man than is ...
Clave unto him - Adhered to him firmly; embraced the Christian religion.
Dionysius - Nothing more is certainly known of this man than is here stated.
The Areopagite - Connected with the court of Areopagus, but in what way is not known. It is probable that he was one of the judges. The conversion of one man was worth the labor of Paul, and that conversion might have had an extensive influence on others.
In regard to this account of the visit of Paul to Athens probably the only one which he made to that splendid capital - we may remark:
(1) That he was indefatigable and constant in his great work.
(2) Christians, amidst the splendor and gaieties of such cities, should have their hearts deeply affected in view of the moral desolations of the people.
\caps1 (3) t\caps0 hey should be willing to do their duty, and to bear witness to the pure and simple gospel in the presence of the great and the noble.
\caps1 (4) t\caps0 hey should not consider it their main business to admire splendid temples, statues, and paintings - the works of art; but their main business should be to do good as they may have opportunity.
\caps1 (5) a\caps0 discourse, even in the midst of such wickedness and idolatry, may be calm and dignified; not an appeal merely to the passions, but to the understanding. Paul reasoned with the philosophers of Athens; he did not denounce them; he endeavored calmly to convince them, not harshly to censure them.
\caps1 (6) t\caps0 he example of Paul is a good one for all Christians. In all places cities, towns, or country; amidst all people - philosophers, the rich, the poor; among friends and countrymen, or among strangers and foreigners, the great object should be to do good, to instruct mankind, to seek to elevate the human character, and to promote human happiness by diffusing the pare precepts of the gospel of Christ.
Poole: Act 17:24 - -- God that made the world this seems to be directed against the Epicureans, who held, that the world was without beginning.
Dwelleth not in temples ma...
God that made the world this seems to be directed against the Epicureans, who held, that the world was without beginning.
Dwelleth not in temples made with hands as if he could be tied to them, or circumcised by them: yet God did in some respect dwell in his temple, where he did manifest himself more clearly than in other places; but that was a type of heaven, the throne of God.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:25 - -- As though he needed any thing God is not worshipped or served by holy men, because he wants their service, or any thing that can be offered unto him ...
As though he needed any thing God is not worshipped or served by holy men, because he wants their service, or any thing that can be offered unto him by them; but because it is their duty and advantage to be employed in his service and worship, Psa 50:10,11 .
Life, and breath; the breath of life Gen 2:7 . And in this respect God is called the God of the spirits of all flesh, Num 16:22 ; as the cause of life and breath in all creatures, but especially in man; which made that charge so great against Belshazzar, Dan 5:23 , that his breath was in God’ s hand, and yet he had not glorified him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:26 - -- Hath made of one blood:
1. To teach all charity and compassion towards one another, being so nearly allied to one another.
2. As also to admire God...
Hath made of one blood:
1. To teach all charity and compassion towards one another, being so nearly allied to one another.
2. As also to admire God more in that variety that appears in men’ s shapes and voices, but especially in the dispositions of their minds; whenas they all come from one stock and stem.
Hath determined the times. &c.: the apostle asserts the providence of God against these Athenian philosophers, that nothing comes by chance, or a fatuitous concourse of atoms; but that God is in every thing, though men know it not, or rather will not consider it, Job 7:1 14:5,14 . This doctrine was preached by Moses, who tells the people, that God is their life, and the length of their days, that they might love him, and obey his voice, and cleave unto him, Deu 30:20 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:27 - -- That they should seek the Lord: the apostle tells these philosophers, to whom he spake, the true use of their philosophy, to improve their knowledge ...
That they should seek the Lord: the apostle tells these philosophers, to whom he spake, the true use of their philosophy, to improve their knowledge of natural things, to beget in them by it an admiration of the God of nature; for as from him, so for him are all things, Rom 11:36 .
If haply they might feel after him, and find him and although God himself is incorporeal, yet the things which he made are palpable; and did they seek as they ought, they might find out a great deal of God by the creatures, in which his wisdom, power, and goodness are manifested, Rom 1:20 .
Though he be not far from every one of us God filleth all things, especially he is near in the effects of his wisdom, goodness, and faithfulness, by which he orders and disposes of all things, to the falling out of a hair from our heads.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:28 - -- In him we live, &c. he is the God that made us, that preserves us, and not we ourselves; he keeps us as in the hollow of his hand, and compasseth our...
In him we live, &c. he is the God that made us, that preserves us, and not we ourselves; he keeps us as in the hollow of his hand, and compasseth our paths. Our breath is in our nostrils, and when we send it forth we have none to take in again, unless God furnish us with it, as out of his own hand.
As certain also of your own poets Aratus, a Greek poet: not that St. Paul thought to derive any authority from these poets unto what he had said, but that he might shame them the more by the testimony of their allowed authors. Such quotations as these are (as the bringing in of a Greek into the temple) very rare; yet, besides this, we meet with the like, 1Co 15:33 Tit 1:12 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:29 - -- We are the offspring of God this is spoken by the apostle in a poetical expression, according unto what he had cited. We are indeed the children, and...
We are the offspring of God this is spoken by the apostle in a poetical expression, according unto what he had cited. We are indeed the children, and in our souls bear the image of God. But as many as have the Spirit of adoption, they partake of God’ s holiness, and imitate his goodness, and are more like unto him, by whom they are begotten again unto a lively hope, 1Pe 1:3 ; and at the resurrection they will appear unto all to be his children, when they shall be acknowledged his heirs, and coheirs with Jesus Christ, Rom 8:17 .
We ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver: taking man in his natural principles, consisting of soul and body, he is not made of gold and silver; much less can God be made of them. Our soul in which we bear the image of God, cannot be expressed by any graving or painting; much less God, whose image it is. There are two things to be considered in every image: its matter, and its form or shape. The matter of an image, let it be never so precious, is much inferior to man; for it lies in the earth, (be it gold or silver), for man to trample upon, until he dig it up, and take it out. As for the form of the image, it is that which men please to give it, and man is a kind of creator of it; howsoever, it is his workmanship, and the work is more ignoble than the workman, at least not to be adored by him.
By art and man’ s device according to man’ s will and pleasure, for the image cannot determine itself to be made as it would.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:30 - -- The times of this ignorance God winked at to prevent an objection, lest any should think that they might continue in their unbelief, and fare as well...
The times of this ignorance God winked at to prevent an objection, lest any should think that they might continue in their unbelief, and fare as well as their progenitors, God is said to have overlooked them; as if he had counted them unworthy of his care and providence, and therefore he did not correct or instruct them. When any are left to go on in their sin, without God’ s instruction or correction, it is a sad sign that God scorns to look upon them, or to use any means to recover them.
But now commandeth all men every where to repent: under the gospel we are so far from having liberty to do what we list, that we are more nearly concerned to repent and become holy, Rom 13:11 Tit 2:11,12 1Pe 1:14,15 ; and all men, every where, without exception of time or place, are under this command of repentance; and cursed indeed will he be that does not observe it.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:31 - -- He hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world: that God will judge the world his enemies have with trembling acknowledged, but when G...
He hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world: that God will judge the world his enemies have with trembling acknowledged, but when God will judge the world he hath concealed from his friends; yet the time is already set, Psa 96:13 2Co 5:10 , and we ought to be daily prepared for it.
In righteousness: shall not the Judge of all the world do right?
By that man whom he hath ordained our blessed Saviour, called here man, suitably to his death and resurrection, which St. Paul preached of; as also as man he is thus highly exalted for his debasing of himself for our sakes, Phi 2:9-11 .
Whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead an undeniable proof or argument, it being so difficult a matter to believe a world to come, when we see all things remain as they did in this world; and especially to believe, that in the general judgment Christ, whom they had judged, condemned, and executed, should be Judge: God therefore did glorify him, by raising him from the dead, that they and we might not be faithless, but believe, Rom 1:4 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:32 - -- Some mocked the Epicureans, whom Paul had spoken against in his doctrine of the resurrection from the dead, and judgment to come.
Others said, We wi...
Some mocked the Epicureans, whom Paul had spoken against in his doctrine of the resurrection from the dead, and judgment to come.
Others said, We will hear thee again of this matter it is thought the Stoics, who did not think the resurrection to be impossible, but did acknowledge rewards and punishments in the world to come; yet, though this seem most likely, the grace of God is free and powerful, and can subdue any unto itself. We are sure that there are different soils into which the seed of the word is cast, Mat 13:1 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Leaving what he had said to God’ s blessing and their consideration.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 17:34 - -- Clave unto him in more than ordinary friendship; they were as glued to him; great was their love to the apostle, by whom their eyes were opened, nay,...
Clave unto him in more than ordinary friendship; they were as glued to him; great was their love to the apostle, by whom their eyes were opened, nay, by whose ministry they were raised from the dead.
Dionysius the Areopagite one of that great council mentioned Act 17:19 , whose conversion might have a great influence on many.
Damaris who is thought to have been an honourable woman; such are mentioned Act 17:12 : or she might have been specially eminent for some grace or goodness she excelled in, and therefore hath a name upon record in the word of God.
Haydock: Act 17:24 - -- God...dwelleth not in temples. He who is infinite cannot be confined to space; nor stand in need of what human hands can furnish. Temples are not f...
God...dwelleth not in temples. He who is infinite cannot be confined to space; nor stand in need of what human hands can furnish. Temples are not for God, but for man. It is the latter who derives assistance from them. The same may be observed of all exterior acts of worship. They are serviceable, inasmuch as they proceed from, or powerfully assist, interior devotion, by the impressions which exterior objects leave upon the soul. The reciprocal action of one upon the other, in our present state of existence, is great and inevitable. (Haydock) See chap. vii. above, ver. 48. ---
God, indeed, dwelleth in the temple, yes, and in the soul of the just man, but his is not confined there, as the idols were to their temples. Hence the prayer of Solomon at the consecration of the temple: if heaven, and the heaven of heavens cannot contain thy immensity, how much less this house, which I have erected? God dwelleth there, then, to receive the prayers and sacrifices of the faithful, but not as though he needed any thing. See ver. 25. ---
God is not contained in temples; so as to need them for his dwelling, or any other uses, as the heathens imagined. Yet by his omnipresence, he is bother there and every where. (Challoner)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:27 - -- Feel after him. Si forte attrectent eum, Greek: ei arage pselapheseian. It signifies palpare quasi in tenebris. (Witham)
Feel after him. Si forte attrectent eum, Greek: ei arage pselapheseian. It signifies palpare quasi in tenebris. (Witham)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:28 - -- St. Paul here cites Aratus, a Greek poet, and his own countryman, a native of Cilicia.
St. Paul here cites Aratus, a Greek poet, and his own countryman, a native of Cilicia.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:29 - -- Cherubim, which extended wings, were ordered by God to be made, and placed over the propitiatory; (Exodus xxxvii. 7.) the brazen serpent is declared b...
Cherubim, which extended wings, were ordered by God to be made, and placed over the propitiatory; (Exodus xxxvii. 7.) the brazen serpent is declared by Jesus Christ himself to have been a figure of him; therefore to blame the universally received practice of the Catholic Church, with regard to pictures and images, betrays either great prevention, or great ignorance. St. Gregory says: "What writing does for readers, that a picture does for the ignorant; for in it they see what they ought to follow, and in it they read, who know no letters." And he sharply rebukes Serenus's indiscreet zeal for removing pictures, instead of teaching the people what use may be made of them. (lib. ix. ep. 9.)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:30 - -- Overlooked. Despiciens, Greek: uperidon. It may either signify looking down on the ignorant world, and so taking pity of it; or rather that God h...
Overlooked. Despiciens, Greek: uperidon. It may either signify looking down on the ignorant world, and so taking pity of it; or rather that God having overlooked, and permitted mankind to go on so long in their sins, now invites them to repentance, by sending Jesus, their Saviour and Redeemer. See the Analysis, dissert. xxxiv. (Witham)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:31 - -- Because he hath appointed a day for judging all men with equity, by the man, to wit, Christ Jesus, a man, and also his true Son, whom he has appoin...
Because he hath appointed a day for judging all men with equity, by the man, to wit, Christ Jesus, a man, and also his true Son, whom he has appointed to be their judge; and by raising him (Jesus) from the dead, he hath made it credible, and given sufficient proofs of this truth, that every one shall rise from death. (Witham)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:32 - -- When they heard of the resurrection of the dead. This seemed so impossible, even to the philosophers among them, that some of them presently laugh...
When they heard of the resurrection of the dead. This seemed so impossible, even to the philosophers among them, that some of them presently laughed, and made a jest of it. Others said, we will hear thee on this another time, and some believed. (Witham)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 17:34 - -- Dionysius the Areopagite. This illustrious convert was made the first bishop of Athens. They martyrologies say, St. Paul raised him to that dignity...
Dionysius the Areopagite. This illustrious convert was made the first bishop of Athens. They martyrologies say, St. Paul raised him to that dignity. It is the same person, who, observing the convulsions of nature, which paid homage, as it were, to its God, expiring upon the cross, and not knowing the cause, is said to have exclaimed: Either the universe is falling to ruin, or the God of nature must be suffering. It appears from his writings, that he was, previous to his conversion, of the Platonic school. Ven. Bede was mistaken in supposing that he was afterwards the bishop of Corinth, of that name, who so successfully employed his pen for the good of the Church. This Dionysius lived a whole century after the Areopagite. (Estius)
Gill: Act 17:24 - -- God that made the world, and all things therein,.... In this account of the divine Being, as the Creator of the world, and all things in it, as the ap...
God that made the world, and all things therein,.... In this account of the divine Being, as the Creator of the world, and all things in it, as the apostle agrees with Moses, and the rest of the sacred Scriptures; so he condemns both the notion of the Epicurean philosophers, who denied that the world was made by God, but said that it owed its being to a fortuitous concourse of atoms; and the notion of the Peripatetics, or Aristotelians, who asserted the eternity of the world; and some of both sects were doubtless present.
Seeing that he is the Lord of heaven and earth; as appears by his being the Creator of both; hence he supports them in their being, and governs all creatures in them by his providence.
Dwelleth not in temples made with hands; such as were the idol temples at Athens; nor in any other edifices built by man, so as to be there fixed and limited; no, not in the temple at Jerusalem: but he dwells in temples that are not made with hands, as in the temple of Christ's human nature, in which the fulness of the Godhead dwells bodily, and in the hearts of his people, who are the temples of the Holy Ghost. This strikes at a notion of the Athenians, as if God was limited, and circumscribed, and included within the bounds of a shrine, or temple, though it is not at all contrary to his promises, or the hopes of his own people, of his presence in places appointed for divine worship, but is expressive of the infinity and immensity of God.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:25 - -- Neither is worshipped with men's hands,.... Or "served" with them; or "ministered unto" by them, as the Syriac version renders it: and the sense is, t...
Neither is worshipped with men's hands,.... Or "served" with them; or "ministered unto" by them, as the Syriac version renders it: and the sense is, that men by worshipping God do not give anything to him, that can be of any use or service to him; he, being God all sufficient, stands in need of nothing; for external worship is not here intended by worshipping with men's hands, in distinction from, and opposition to, internal worship, or to the worship of God with the heart; but that whether it be with the one or with the other, or both, nothing is given to God, as adding any thing to his essential glory and happiness:
as though he needed anything; for he does not, he is "El Shaddai", God all sufficient; nor can anything be given to him, he has not; or otherwise all perfection would not be in him: but that he cannot be indigent of anything, appears from hence,
seeing he giveth to all life and breath; or "the breath of life", as the Ethiopic version renders it; this God breathed into man at first, and he became a living soul; and every animate creature, everyone that has life and breath, have them from God; he gives them to them, and continues them:
and all things; that are enjoyed by them, and are necessary for their subsistence, and for the comfort of life, and for both their use and profit, and for their delight and pleasure; wherefore he that gives them all things, cannot want anything himself, nor receive anything at their hands. This clause is left out in the Syriac, Arabic, and Ethiopic versions.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:26 - -- And hath made of one blood,.... That is, of one man's blood; the Vulgate Latin version reads, "of one"; and the Arabic version of De Dieu reads, "of o...
And hath made of one blood,.... That is, of one man's blood; the Vulgate Latin version reads, "of one"; and the Arabic version of De Dieu reads, "of one man"; of Adam, the first parent of all mankind, and who had the blood of all men in his veins: hence the Jews u say,
"the first man was
and this by propagation has been derived from him, and communicated to all mankind. They also say w, that
"the reason why man was created alone (or there was but one man created) was, on account of families, that they might not be stirred up one against another;''
that is, strive and contend with one another about pre-eminence: and they add,
"that the righteous might not say we are the sons of the righteous, and ye are the sons of the wicked.''
And it is a certain truth that follows upon this, that no man has any reason to vaunt over another, and boast of his blood and family; and as little reason have any to have any dependence upon their being the children of believers, or to distinguish themselves from others, and reject them as the children of unbelievers, when all belong to one family, and are of one man's blood, whether Adam or Noah: of whom are
all nations of men, for to dwell on all the face of the earth; for from Adam sprung a race of men, which multiplied on the face of the earth, and peopled the world before the flood; these being destroyed by the flood, and Noah and his family saved, his descendants were scattered all over the earth, and repeopled it: and this is the original of all the nations of men, and of all the inhabitants of the earth; and stands opposed to the fabulous accounts of the Heathens, which the apostle might have in his view, that men at first grew up out of the earth, or after the flood were formed of stones, which Deucalion and Prometheus threw over their heads; and particularly the Athenians boasted that they sprung out of the earth, which Diogenes ridiculed as common with mice and worms. But the apostle ascribes all to one blood:
and hath determined the times before appointed; how long the world he has made shall continue; and the several distinct periods, ages, and generations, in which such and such men should live, such and such nations should exist, and such monarchies should be in being, as the Assyrian, Persian, Grecian, and Roman, and how long they should subsist; as also the several seasons of the year, as seedtime and harvest, cold and heat, summer and winter, and day and night; and which are so bounded, and kept so distinct in their revolutions, as not to interfere with, and encroach upon each other; and likewise the several years, months, and days of every man's life; see Job 7:1 to which may be added, the times of the law and Gospel; the time of Christ's birth and death; the time of the conversion of particular persons; and all their times of desertion, temptation, affliction, and comfort; the times of the church's sufferings, both under Rome Pagan and Rome Papal; of the holy city being trodden under foot, of the witnesses prophesying in sackcloth, and of their being killed, and their bodies lying unburied, and of their resurrection and ascension to heaven, Rev 2:10 Rev 11:12 the time of antichrist's reign and ruin, Rev 13:5 and of Christ's personal coming, and the day of judgment, 1Ti 6:15 and of his reign on earth for a thousand years, Rev 20:4. All these are appointed times, and determined by the Creator and Governor of the world:
and the bounds of their habitation; where men shall dwell, and how long they shall continue there the age or distinct period of time, in which every man was, or is to come into the world, is fixed and determined by God; nor can, nor does anyone come into the world sooner or later than that time; and also the particular country, city, town, and spot of ground where he shall dwell; and the term of time how long he shall dwell there, and then remove to another place, or be removed by death. And to this agrees the Ethiopic version, which renders the whole thus, "and hath appointed his times, and his years, how long they shall dwell"; see Deu 32:8 to which the apostle seems to refer.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:27 - -- That they should seek the Lord,.... Or "God", as the Alexandrian copy and others, and the Vulgate Latin, Syriac, and Ethiopic versions read; their Cre...
That they should seek the Lord,.... Or "God", as the Alexandrian copy and others, and the Vulgate Latin, Syriac, and Ethiopic versions read; their Creator, and kind Benefactor, and who has appointed their time of life, and their habitations for them; and this should engage them to seek to know him, who has done all this for them, and to fear and serve him, and to glorify his name:
if haply they might feel after him, and find him; which shows, that though it is possible for men, by a contemplation of the perfections of God, visible in the works of creation and providence, so to find God, as to know that there is one, and that there is but one God, who has made all things; and so as to be convinced of the vanity and falsehood of all other gods, and to see the folly, wickedness, and weakness of idolatrous worship; yet, at the same time, it very strongly intimates, how dim and obscure the light of nature is; since those, who have nothing else to direct them, are like persons in the dark, who "feel" and grope about after God, whom they cannot see; and after all their search and groping, there is only an "haply", a peradventure, a may be, that they find him:
though he be not far from everyone of us; not only by his omnipresence, and immensity, whereby he is everywhere; but by his power in supporting all in their being; and by his goodness in continually communicating the blessings of providence to them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:28 - -- For in him we live, and move, and have our being,.... The natural life which men live is from God; and they are supported in it by him; and from him t...
For in him we live, and move, and have our being,.... The natural life which men live is from God; and they are supported in it by him; and from him they have all the comforts and blessings of life; and all motions, whether external or internal, of body or of mind, are of God, and none of them are without the concourse of his providence, and strength assistance from him; though the disorder and irregularity of these motions, whereby they become sinful, are of themselves, or of the devil; and their being, and the maintenance of it, and continuance in it, are all owing to the power and providence of God.
As certain also of your own poets have said; the Syriac version reads in the singular number, "as a certain one of your wise men has said"; but all others read in the plural; and some have thought, that the apostle refers to what goes before, that being an Iambic verse of some of the poets, as well as to what follows, which is a citation from Aratus x and whom the apostle might have called his own, as he was his countryman; for Aratus was a native of Solis, a city of Cilicia, not far from Tarsus yea, some say y he was of Tarsus, where the apostle was born: but Aratus being an Heathen, and the apostle speaking to Heathens, calls him one of them; and the rather, that what is cited might be the more regarded by them: though the expression is also z said to be in an hymn to Jove, written by Cleanthes, who taught at Athens; and so the apostle addressing the Athenians, might, with greater propriety, say, "as certain of your own poets say": it is also said to be in Aratus the astronomer, and in the poet Homer; so that the plural number may well be used. Which is,
for we are also his offspring; the offspring of Jove, says Aratus; which the apostle applies to the true Jehovah, the Creator of all men, by whom, and after whose image, they are made, and so are truly his offspring; upon which the apostle argues as follows.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:29 - -- Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God,.... In the sense before given; for the apostle is not here speaking of himself, and other saints, as be...
Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God,.... In the sense before given; for the apostle is not here speaking of himself, and other saints, as being the children of God, by adoption, and by regenerating grace, and faith in Christ Jesus, but as men in common with others, and with these Athenians:
we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man's device; for men themselves, who are the offspring of God, and made after his image, are not to be compared to graven images of gold, silver, and stone, but are vastly preferable to them, they being formed by their art, and the device of their minds; and much less then should God, the Creator of men, and from whom they spring, be likened to, or represented by, any such thing; for so to think of God, is to think very unworthily of him; for if to think thus of ourselves, who are descended from him, would be a debasing of us, then much more to think so of God, the Father of spirits, must be a depreciating of him; and which by no means ought to be done, and argues great stupidity: if living rational creatures are not to be equalled to, and compared with, senseless statues, much less God, the former of men and angels.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:30 - -- And the times of this ignorance God winked at,.... Not that he approved of, or encouraged such blindness and folly, as appeared among the Gentiles, wh...
And the times of this ignorance God winked at,.... Not that he approved of, or encouraged such blindness and folly, as appeared among the Gentiles, when they worshipped idols of gold, silver, and stone, taking them for deities; but rather the sense is, he despised this, and them for it, and was displeased and angry with them; and as an evidence of such contempt and indignation, he overlooked them, and took no notice of them, and gave them no revelation to direct them, nor prophets to instruct them, and left them to their stupidity and ignorance:
but now commandeth all men everywhere to repent; that is, he hath given orders, that the doctrine of repentance, as well as remission of sins, should be preached to all nations, to Gentiles as well as Jews; and that it becomes them to repent of their idolatries, and turn from their idols, and worship the one, only, living and true God: and though for many hundreds of years God had neglected them, and sent no messengers, nor messages to them, to acquaint them with his will, and to show them their follies and mistakes; yet now he had sent his apostles unto them, to lay before them their sins, and call them to repentance; and to stir them up to this, the apostle informs them of the future judgment in the following verse. Repentance being represented as a command, does not suppose it to be in the power of men, or contradict evangelical repentance, being the free grace gift of God, but only shows the need men stand in of it, and how necessary and requisite it is; and when it is said to be a command to all, this does not destroy its being a special blessing of the covenant of grace to some; but points out the sad condition that all men are in as sinners, and that without repentance they must perish: and indeed, all men are obliged to natural repentance for sin, though to all men the grace of evangelical repentance is not given: the Jews a call repentance
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:31 - -- Because he hath appointed a day,.... The day of judgment is fixed by God in his eternal purposes, and is sure and certain, and will come, though it is...
Because he hath appointed a day,.... The day of judgment is fixed by God in his eternal purposes, and is sure and certain, and will come, though it is not known by men or angels; and this is a reason why God will have the doctrine of repentance everywhere published, both to Jews and Gentiles, since all must come to judgment: and the day for it is appointed by him,
in the which he will judge the world in righteousness; the whole world will be judged, and every individual in it, good and bad, righteous and wicked; and this judgment will be a righteous one; it will proceed according to the strict rules of justice and equity, and upon the foot of the righteousness of Christ, as that has been received or rejected by men, or as men are clothed with, or are without that righteousness:
by that man whom he hath ordained; Beza's ancient copy reads, "the man Jesus": not that the apostle means that Christ is a mere man; for then he would not be fit to be a Judge of quick and dead, and to pass and execute the definitive sentence; which requires omniscience and omnipotence: but preaching to mere Heathens, he chose not at once to assert the deity of Christ, though he tacitly suggests it: but intended, by degrees, to open the glories of his nature and office to them, he being the person God had from all eternity ordained, and in time had signified, should have all judgment committed to him, and by whom the last judgment shall be managed and transacted:
whereof he hath given assurance to all men: or full proof, both of his being the Judge, and of his fitness to be one, and also of the righteousness, according to which he will judge:
in that he hath raised him from the dead; whereby he was declared to be the Son of God; and when all power in heaven and in earth was given to him; and which was done for the justification of all those for whose offences he was delivered: and this seems to be the reason why the apostle calls Christ the Judge a man, that he might have the opportunity of mentioning his resurrection from the dead.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:32 - -- When they heard of the resurrection of the dead,.... Of a certain man that the apostle said God had raised from the dead, though they knew not who he ...
When they heard of the resurrection of the dead,.... Of a certain man that the apostle said God had raised from the dead, though they knew not who he was:
some mocked; at him, and at the doctrine he preached: these very likely were of the Epicurean sect, who disbelieved a future state; though, as Tertullian observes b, the doctrine of the resurrection was denied by every sect of the philosophers: it is a doctrine of pure revelation, and what the light of nature never taught men, and by which men being only guided, have declared against, and have treated it with the utmost ridicule and contempt. Pliny c reckons it, among childish fancies, and calls it vanity, and downright madness to believe it; as does also Caecilius in Minutius Felix d, and who even calls it a lie, and places it among old wives' fables; and Celsus in Origen e represents it as exceeding detestable, abominable, and impossible.
And others said, we will hear thee again of this matter; some think these were of the Stoic sect, who held a future state, and that the soul would live after the body, and had some notions which looked inclining to this doctrine: however, these thought there might be something in what the apostle said; they could not receive it readily, and yet could not deny it; they were willing to take time to consider of it; and were desirous of hearing him again upon that subject; in which they might be very open and upright; and this might not be a mere excuse to shift off any further hearing at that time, like that of Felix, in Act 24:1.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:33 - -- So Paul departed from among them. As it was high time, when they fell to deriding and scoffing at him; for hereby they judged themselves unworthy of t...
So Paul departed from among them. As it was high time, when they fell to deriding and scoffing at him; for hereby they judged themselves unworthy of the Gospel ministry: the Ethiopic version adds, "from Athens"; but it does not appear that the apostle went directly out of the city; we read afterwards of his departing from Athens, Act 18:1 but the sense is, that he went out of the Areopagus, from that court of judicature; and from among the judges of it, and the philosophers of every sect, that stood around him in it; they having no more to say to him, nor he to them. And this shows, that he was not brought to be tried and judged, in order to be punished, but only to be heard concerning his doctrine; of which, when they had heard enough, he departed quietly, no one molesting him, unless with scoffs and jeers.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 17:34 - -- Howbeit, certain men clave unto him, and believed,.... There were some who were ordained to eternal life, to whom the Gospel came in power, and they r...
Howbeit, certain men clave unto him, and believed,.... There were some who were ordained to eternal life, to whom the Gospel came in power, and they received the love of the truth, and their hearts and affections were knit unto the apostle; and they followed him, and kept to him, and privately conversed with him, and believed his doctrine, and in Jesus Christ, whom he preached unto them; to these the Gospel was the savour of life unto life, when to the scoffers and mockers it was the savour of death unto death: and this is the fruit and effect of the Gospel ministry, wherever it comes:
among the which was Dionysius the Areopagite; a judge in the court of Areopagus: how many judges that court consisted of, is not certain, nor whether there was one who was superior to the rest; if there was such an one, Dionysius seems to have been he, since he is called the Areopagite. The business of this court was not only to try causes of murder, which seems to have been the original business of it; but by these judges the rights of the city were preserved and defended, war was proclaimed, and all law suits adjusted and decided; and they made it their business to look after idle and slothful persons, and inquire how they lived f: they always heard and judged causes in the night, in the dark, because they would only know facts, and not persons, lest they should be influenced by their afflictions, and be led wrong g; they were very famous in other nations for their wisdom and skill, and for their gravity and strict justice. Dolabella, proconsul of Asia, having a woman brought before him for poisoning her husband and son, which she confessed, and gave reasons for doing it, referred the matter to a council, who refused to pass sentence; upon which he sent the case to Athens, to the Areopagites, as to judges "more grave" and "more experienced" h: and hence these words of Julian the emperor i,
"let an Areopagite be judge, and we will not be afraid of the judgment.''
This Dionysius the Areopagite is said, by another Dionysius, bishop of the Corinthians, a very ancient writer k, to be the first bishop of the Athenians, which is more likely than that he should be a bishop in France. It is reported of him, that being at Heliopolis in Egypt, along with Apollophanes, a philosopher, at the time of Christ's sufferings, he should say concerning the unusual eclipse that then was, that "a God unknown, and clothed with flesh, suffered", on whose account the whole world was darkened; or, as, others affirm, he said, "either the God of nature suffers, or the frame of the world will be dissolved": it is also related of him that when he was converted by the apostle at Athens, he went to Clemens, bishop of Rome, and was sent by him with others into the west, to preach the Gospel; some of which went to Spain, and others to France, and that he steered his course to Paris, and there, with Rusticus and Eleutherius his "colleagues", suffered martyrdom l. The books ascribed unto him concerning the divine names, and ecclesiastical hierarchy, are spurious things, stuffed with foolish, absurd, and impious notions, and seem to have been written in the "fifth" century.
And a woman named Damaris; some of the ancients, and also some modern writers, take this woman to be the wife of Dionysius; but had she been his wife, she would have been doubtless called so; however, by the particular mention of her name, she seems to have been a person of some note and figure: the name is a diminutive from
And others with them; with these two, as the Arabic version renders it; that is, with Dionysius and Damaris. These laid the foundation of a Gospel church at Athens. Dionysius, as before observed, was the first bishop, or pastor of it; it is also said that Narcissus, one of the seventy disciples, was bishop of this place; See Gill on Luk 10:1. In the "second" century Publius was bishop of the church at Athens, who suffered martyrdom for Christ in the time of Hadrian; and was succeeded by Quadratus m, who was famous for a writing he presented to the said emperor, in favour of the churches in common, and the success of it, about the year 128; at the same time, Aristides, a famous philosopher and Christian, flourished in the church at Athens, who wrote an apology for the Christian religion; and also Jovius, a presbyter and martyr, and a disciple of Dionysius; likewise Athenagoras, a man of great learning and piety, who wrote also an apology for the Christians, and a treatise concerning the resurrection of the dead, which are still extant; the former was written to the emperors Antoninus and Commodus: in the "third" century mention is made of the church at Athens; and Origen n speaks very honourably of it, as meek and quiet, and desirous of approving itself to God. In the "fourth" century it appears that there were Christians there, since Maximus the emperor stirred up wicked men to molest and distress them; and there was a Christian school there, in which Bazil and Gregory Nazianzen were brought up. In the "fifth" century there was a church in this place; and in the "sixth", a Christian school, in which Boethius Patricius learned the liberal arts; and in the "seventh" century mention is made of a bishop of Athens, who was in the sixth council at Constantinople o: thus far this church state is to be traced.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes -> Act 17:24; Act 17:24; Act 17:24; Act 17:25; Act 17:25; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:26; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:27; Act 17:28; Act 17:28; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:29; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:30; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:31; Act 17:32; Act 17:32; Act 17:33; Act 17:34; Act 17:34; Act 17:34; Act 17:34; Act 17:34
NET Notes: Act 17:24 On the statement does not live in temples made by human hands compare Acts 7:48. This has implications for idols as well. God cannot be represented by...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:26 Grk “the boundaries of their habitation.” L&N 80.5 has “fixed limits of the places where they would live” for this phrase.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:27 The participle ὑπάρχοντα (Juparconta) has been translated as a concessive adverbial participle.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:28 This quotation is from Aratus (ca. 310-245 b.c.), Phaenomena 5. Paul asserted a general relationship and accountability to God for all humanity.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:29 Or “thought.” BDAG 336 s.v. ἐνθύμησις has “thought, reflection, idea” as the cat...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:30 He now commands all people everywhere to repent. God was now asking all mankind to turn to him. No nation or race was excluded.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:32 L&N 33.408 has “some scoffed (at him) Ac 17:32” for ἐχλεύαζον (ecleuazon) here; the impe...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:33 Grk “left out of their midst”; the referent (the Areopagus) has been specified in the translation for clarity.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 17:34 Grk “and a woman”; but this καί (kai) has not been translated since English normally uses a coordinating conjunction only b...
Geneva Bible: Act 17:24 ( 13 ) God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands;
( 13 ) It...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:26 ( 14 ) And hath made of ( o ) one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:27 That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might ( p ) feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us:
( p ) For as blind...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:29 Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, ( q ) graven by art and ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:30 ( 15 ) And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent:
( 15 ) The oldness of the error does not excu...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:31 Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by [that] man whom he hath ordained; [whereof] he hath given ( ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 17:32 ( 16 ) And when they heard of the resurrection of the dead, some mocked: and others said, We will hear thee again of this [matter].
( 16 ) Men, to sh...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Act 17:1-34
TSK Synopsis: Act 17:1-34 - --1 Paul preaches at Thessalonica, where some believe,5 and others persecute him.10 He is sent to Berea, and preaches there.13 Being persecuted by Jews ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Combined Bible: Act 17:32 - --33. (32) " And when they heard of a resurrection of the dead, some mocked; but others said, We will hear you again concerning this matter. (33) So P...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Combined Bible: Act 17:34 - --Although his discourse terminated amid the mockery of a portion of his audience, the apostle's effort was not altogether fruitless. (34) " But certain...
Maclaren -> Act 17:22-34; Act 17:31
Maclaren: Act 17:22-34 - --Paul At Athens
Then Paul stood in the midst of Mars-hill, and said, Ye men of Athens, I perceive that in all things ye are too superstitious. 23. For...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Maclaren: Act 17:31 - --The Man Who Is Judge
He will judge the world in righteousness by that Man whom He hath ordained; whereof He hath given assurance unto all men, in tha...
MHCC -> Act 17:22-31; Act 17:32-34
MHCC: Act 17:22-31 - --Here we have a sermon to heathens, who worshipped false gods, and were without the true God in the world; and to them the scope of the discourse was d...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
MHCC: Act 17:32-34 - --The apostle was treated with more outward civility at Athens than in some other places; but none more despised his doctrine, or treated it with more i...
Matthew Henry -> Act 17:22-31; Act 17:32-34
Matthew Henry: Act 17:22-31 - -- We have here St. Paul's sermon at Athens. Divers sermons we have had, which the apostles preached to the Jews, or such Gentiles as had an acquaintan...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Matthew Henry: Act 17:32-34 - -- We have here a short account of the issue of Paul's preaching at Athens. I. Few were the better: the gospel had as little success at Athens as any w...
Barclay -> Act 17:22-31; Act 17:32-34
Barclay: Act 17:22-31 - --There were many altars to unknown gods in Athens. Six hundred years before this a terrible pestilence had fallen on the city which nothing could halt...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barclay: Act 17:32-34 - --It would seem on the whole that Paul had less success in Athens than anywhere else. It was typical of the Athenians that all they wanted was to talk....
Constable: Act 9:32--Rom 1:1 - --III. THE WITNESS TO THE UTTERMOST PART OF THE EARTH 9:32--28:31
Luke next recorded the church's expansion beyond...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 16:6--19:21 - --C. The extension of the church to the Aegean shores 16:6-19:20
The missionary outreach narrated in this ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 17:16--18:18 - --3. The ministry in Achaia 17:16-18:17
Luke recorded this section to document the advance of the ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 17:22-31 - --Paul's sermon to the Athenians 17:22-31
Luke probably recorded Paul's address (vv. 22-31) as a sample of his preaching to intellectual pagans (cf. 13:...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 17:32-34 - --The response to Paul's preaching 17:32-34
Most Greeks rejected the possibility o...
College -> Act 17:1-34
College: Act 17:1-34 - --ACTS 17
9. The Visits at Amphipolis and Apollonia (17:1a)
1 When they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia,
After leaving Philippi Paul's st...
McGarvey: Act 17:22-31 - --22-31. After persevering, but necessarily disconnected conversational efforts on the streets, Paul has now an audience assembled for the special purpo...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
McGarvey: Act 17:32-33 - --32, 33. (32) " And when they heard of a resurrection of the dead, some mocked; but others said, We will hear you again concerning this matter. (33) So...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
McGarvey: Act 17:34 - --34. Although his discourse terminated amid the mockery of a portion of his audience, the apostle's effort was not altogether fruitless. (34) " But cer...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Other
Critics Ask -> Act 17:28
Critics Ask: Act 17:28 ACTS 17:28 —Why did Paul quote an uninspired pagan poet?
(See comments on Titus 1:12 .)
Evidence: Act 17:24 Evolution should not be taught . Dr. Colin Patterson, senior paleontologist, British Museum of Natural History, gave a keynote address at the American...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Evidence: Act 17:26 Mormons believe that God cursed Cain with black skin and a flat nose. However, the " mark" was set upon Cain before the Flood. In that Flood all fles...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Evidence: Act 17:29 USING THE LAW IN EVANGELISM Paul was preaching the essence of the First and Second Commandments to show his hearers that they were idolaters. See Ac...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Evidence: Act 17:30 Repentance—its necessity for salvation . See Act 20:21 . " If my six-year-old daughter was out on the road playing in front of my house and I saw ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)